Legal Case Analysis
? Paul Cronan was a long-term New England Telephone Company (NET) employee (1973 - 1986), assigned at South Boston.
? Paul was diagnosed with AIDS Related Complex (ARC) in 1985.
? Paul informed his supervisor about ARC when asked about his third request to leave work for a medical appointment (1985).
? Paul had a poor attendance history. His tardiness and medical appointments concerned his supervision.
? Paul was granted NET sickness benefits in June 1985.
? Disparaging comments about Paul and AIDS were observed in NET restrooms (summer 1985).
? Paul obtained medical permission to return to work with NET, but his requests for transfer way from the South Boston dispatch center were not processed by his new supervisor (August 1885).
? NET issues new AIDS policy (September 1985).
? Paul is hospitalized (September 1985), and receives a memo from NET offering to return him to his previous position with reasonable accommodation for limitations.
? Paul files suit against NET for ?privacy law violations? and ?discrimination? using Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts (December 1985).
? NET tried to move the case to Federal court and failed (January 1986). The court determined that neither federal law nor union contracts preempted Massachusetts state laws on discrimination and privacy.
? NET informs Paul his illness benefits have run out and place him on long-term disability (June 1986).
? Paul and NET settle out of court, including allowing Paul to return to work at Needham facility (October 1886).
? AIDS awareness training provided to NET personnel at Needham by medical AIDS specialists before Paul comes back to work (October 1986).
? On Paul?s first day back at NET Needham, he finds a hostile work environment and IBEW Local 2222 workers file a grievance over safety concerns related to exposure to AIDS (October 1986).
? On Paul?s second day back to work, 29 of 39 employees refused to enter the NET Needham facility and walked off the job. Several of these employees made statements regarding their fear AIDS and discomfort around Cronan (October 1986).
Critical Legal Issues:
? Was Paul Cronan discriminated against on the basis of a handicap, AIDS?
? Was AIDS/ARC a handicap?
... middle of paper ...
... a large sum of money to go away (the easy way out).
? NET could have accommodated Paul immediately and used his services doing something that prevented or limited his contact with employees or other people. This may have been a breech of union contract.
Judgement and Rationale:
? Once errors were made and the damage was done, NET was best served by taking the actions they did in settling out of court with Paul Cronan. This minimized the extent of financial loss, and prevented further tarnishing their corporate image. In this case it was NETs responsibility to do the right thing from the beginning.
? NET would have lost the legal battle in court. Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 19732 clearly prohibits discrimination in employment against qualified individuals with a disability. Like the ADA, a qualified individual with a disability is a person who: (1) has a physical or mental impairment which ?substantially limits? one or more major life activities, (2) has a record of such impairment, or (3) is regarded as having such an impairment. In this case the court would likely have determined that AIDS and the perception of AIDS qualified it as a disability.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- 1. Identification of the “critical or relevant facts” from the case” Paul Cronan was working for New England Telephone Company while diagnosed with ARC – Aids Related Complex and started showing symptoms of AIDS. His supervisors started to get concern with his job performance and health due to his very poor attendance, and the increased amount of absences. During spring 1985, Paul had requested permission on two different days to leave work due to a doctor’s appointment. Paul’s supervisor Charles O’Brian refused to grant him permission a third time, unless he informs him on the reason for the appointment.... [tags: essays research papers]
1111 words (3.2 pages)
- Paul Cronan and New England Telephone Company Case Analysis Legal Case Analysis Facts: ? Paul Cronan was a long-term New England Telephone Company (NET) employee (1973 - 1986), assigned at South Boston. ? Paul was diagnosed with AIDS Related Complex (ARC) in 1985. ? Paul informed his supervisor about ARC when asked about his third request to leave work for a medical appointment (1985). ? Paul had a poor attendance history. His tardiness and medical appointments concerned his supervision.... [tags: Business Case Analysis Essays]
2134 words (6.1 pages)
- Analysis of the Paul Cronan Case I. Legal Analysis, Issue 1 Issue: Does party bringing suit (Plaintiff – Paul Cronan) qualify under the ADA for disability. Rule: In Review of ADA and the principles set forth at that time, there are several relevancies to consider here. A disability is described as follows: “For purposes of nondiscrimination laws (e.g. the Americans with Disabilities Act, Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and Section 188 of the Workforce Investment Act), a person with a disability is generally defined as someone who (1) has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more "major life activities," (2) has a record of such an impairment, or... [tags: Legal Analysis Discrimination Equality Essays]
3733 words (10.7 pages)
- Cronan Case Analysis Legal Analysis The legal issues in the Cronan case are primarily centered on job discrimination. For employment discrimination to be present, three basic elements must be involved. First, it is a decision against one or more employees that is not based on individual merit, such as the ability to perform the job. This element presumably has been satisfied in the Cronan case as no evidence was presented indicating that Cronan was unable to perform his job. Second, the decision derives solely or in part from racial or sexual prejudice, false stereotypes, or some other kind of morally unjustified attitude against members of the class to which the employee belongs.... [tags: essays research papers]
1641 words (4.7 pages)
- A. Relevant Dates and Facts a. 1973 – Paul Cronan hired by New England Telephone (NET) straight from high school. He began working as a file clerk. b. 1983 – Cronan was promoted to Service Technician. c. January to June 1985 – Cronan was ill at various times, having symptoms of AIDS-related complex (ARC). d. June 1985 – Cronan was denied permission to leave work for a medical appointment by his supervisor, Charles O’Brian. O’Brian had given permission on two other occasions, but refused this third time unless Cronan revealed the reason for the appointment.... [tags: essays research papers]
2124 words (6.1 pages)
- Paul Cronan Paul Cronan Case This case involves a corporate response to AIDS in the workplace. The return to work of Paul Cronan, a person with AIDS, after a much publicized law suit, led to a walkout of his coworkers. This case documents the circumstances which preceded the work stoppage. Analyzing this case from Paul Cronan’s supervisors point of view there are three main ethical issues to be considered: duty to protect the interests of the company, New England Telephone (NET); obligation to maintain the rights of the other employees; and duty to provide for the safety and privacy of Paul Cronan.... [tags: Essays Papers]
2666 words (7.6 pages)
- The 17th century lifestyle in New England differed greatly from the lifestyle in the South and England at the time. New England colonists reaped the benefits of longevity and as a result, many families grew to be extremely large and developed. The colonists, primarily united under the shared goal of escaping religious persecution, established many small towns that were one of the first to exercise democracy. Education was also an important part of the New England lifestyle. Due to the climate, the economy in New England was vastly different compared to the South.... [tags: Slavery, Thirteen Colonies, New England]
1208 words (3.5 pages)
- Sarbjit Kaur History 17 A Essay question Q 1. The American colonies were divided into three distinct regions and these regions were different from each other in their origins, populations, economics and agriculture, religious makeup, and connection to England .write an essay comparing and contrasting the New England, middle, and southern colonies with specific examples. The American colonies new England ,middle and southern colonies were very similar but different.The New England, Middle, and Southern Colonies grew differently over the period on 1619-1760.... [tags: Thirteen Colonies, New England Colonies]
895 words (2.6 pages)
- By 1700, differences in religious convictions, wealth, and climate transformed the New England and Chesapeake Bay colonies into distinct societies with markedly contrasting cultures and values. Having fled England because of religious persecution, the Puritans placed a greater emphasis on religion. In contrast, the Chesapeake society, consisting mostly of men who were affected by the primogeniture laws, placed more importance on wealth and land. The climates of the two societies fostered distinct economies and new cultural practices, such as the tobacco wives in the Chesapeake region.... [tags: chesapeake society, new england, puritans]
670 words (1.9 pages)
- Use of Allegories in A New England Nun In "A New England Nun", Mary E. Wilkins Freeman depicts the life of the classic New England spinster. The image of a spinster is of an old maid; a woman never married waiting for a man. The woman waiting to be married is restricted in her life. She does chores and receives education to make her more desirable as a wife. This leads to the allegories used in this short story. The protagonist life paralleled both of her pets' lives, her dog Caesar's and that of her little yellow canary.... [tags: New England Nun Essays]
1725 words (4.9 pages)