Argument Against a National Identification System Essay

Argument Against a National Identification System Essay

Length: 1327 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Argument Against a National Identification System

The concept of a national ID card has been debated in the United States for over three decades. In the past, the opposition as well as its allies has been strong. As a result of the September 11th terrorist attacks there has been new interest in the concept of national ID cards. While this idea is not all a new, it is closer to becoming more of a reality than ever, gaining the approval by the key members of congress. Currently the Bush Administration objects this renewed idea, however due to the intense emotion from the recent terrorist attacks the nation is closer to the idea than ever before. The idea of a national identity (ID) card seems simple enough. Take the photographic and alpha-numerical information on our birth certificates, Social Security cards, driver s licenses, and voter registration card; add a bar code, fingerprint, microchip, or other biometric identifier; and display all that information on a neat plastic card no bigger than a credit card. But beneath this smooth surface hides a complex issues and perhaps the greatest threat to personal freedom Americans have ever confronted. A national ID system will Require Americans to obtain federal government authorization to travel, work, rent or buy housing, obtain medical care, use financial services, and make many purchases.

     This federal authorization could be denied for many reasons, including database errors, a suspicious transaction profile, being a deadbeat parent, failure to pay taxes or fines, and any other social control measures Congress wishes to hang on the system.
    
 The system will almost certainly create an outlaw class--as large as 10 to 20% of the population--cut off from "normal" life in America. This outlaw class will sustain the underground economy for the use of future terrorists (and ordinary criminals). (Dority Barbara, p10)

     The general questions about national ID cards and concepts involved in the debates, found on the Privacy International website at www.privacy.org/pi/activities/idcard/idcard_faq.html. Can be summarized as below:

1.     Who uses ID cards now? About a hundred countries currently utilize official, compulsory, national IDs for various purposes. These include Belgium, France, Germany, Greece, and Spain. Among the developed countries that don't have such a card are Australia, Canad...


... middle of paper ...


... promote new forms of discrimination and harassment of anyone who looks or sounds "foreign." Failure to carry a national I.D. card would likely come to be viewed as a reason for search, detention or arrest of minorities. The disgrace and humiliation of constantly having to prove that they are Americans or legal immigrants would ponder heavily on such groups.

      There I strongly believe that national ID system is not the solution for the problems we are facing today. We have seen before that technological solutions involve risks that should be identified and understood in advance of its use to the greatest extent possible. These risks should be discussed and understood in detail before any decisions regarding its adoption is any form should be made.


Work Cited

     Dority, Barbara. ?Halt and show your paper!? Humanist. 1 March.2002, Vol.62 Issue 2

     Mohl, Jeff. ?How public is personal information?? Communications & Mass Media Complete, 1 September 2003, Vol. 91, Issue 7

     Safire, William. ?The Threat of National ID.? Kirszner and Mandell 586-88.
     http://www.aclu.org

     Privacy International www.privacy.org/pi/activities/idcard/idcard_faq.html.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Photo Identification Legislation Essay example

- ... Supporters say that this legislation allows for variation and opportunities for citizens to get the proper identification before Election Day. Supporters believe that this legislation will not decrease voter turnout as a result. On the other side of controversy surrounding the photo identification legislation are people against photo identification. The main reason for the lack of support has to do with voter turnout. Low voter turnout is already an upstanding problem with the Election and voting process....   [tags: voter polls]

Strong Essays
1590 words (4.5 pages)

Argument Against The Death Penalty Essay

- "The question with which we must deal is not whether a substantial proportion of American citizens, would today, if polled, opine that capital punishment is barbarously cruel, but whether they would find it to be so in light of all information presently available. -Justice Thurgood Marshall Family members of the wrongfully convicted, This letter is for everyone out there who has ever suffered. Anyone who has ever felt the infallibility of our criminal justice system. Anyone who believes that death is scary....   [tags: Exemplification Essays]

Strong Essays
1998 words (5.7 pages)

Identity Vs Identification: The Naqib and Women's Access to Public Services

- As a multi-cultural society, Canada by definition must embrace attitudes and beliefs that are difficult to integrate into public society and/or held by a minority of the population. Our nation's laws and services are beholden to no particular belief system, and when religious doctrine runs counter to those policies every effort should be made to accommodate. However, if such accommodation is not possible, it is the dogma which must give way, and the Islamic custom of the niqab - which covers all of a woman's face but for her eyes - is no exception....   [tags: Canada's multi-cultural society]

Strong Essays
1395 words (4 pages)

Essay on The Argument Behind Gun Control

- ... The police, Department of Justice, as well as mental health facilities must report their findings to the database to ensure public safety. The NICS cannot do what it was intended to do without proper reporting and that lets dangerous people do as they please. One other way in which people will acquire firearms legally whilst being unfit to own one legally is commonly referred to as the “Gun Show Loophole.” This loophole is best described as an unlicensed private seller selling with no background check....   [tags: Firearm, Gun politics in the United States]

Strong Essays
2544 words (7.3 pages)

Virginia Held's Essay, Criticism’s against Traditional Ethical Theories

- Criticism’s against Traditional Ethical Theories Virginia Held brings up many criticisms of traditional ethical theories in her essay. The ethics of care can be considered as a suitable substitution for other widely accepted ethical theories such as Kantian ethics. The ethics of care recognizes the importance of interpersonal relationships, especially those within the family unit. All people need care at some point during their life, be it at birth or old age. Caring for people that can not provide sufficient care for themselves is a fundamental part of a moral society....   [tags: relationships, morals, capital punishment]

Strong Essays
1002 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about An Ethical Argument Against Abortion

- Each day throughout our world, medical professionals suction thousands of babies from their mothers’ wombs through a procedure called abortion. The law protects and provides consent to both the mother and the medical professionals for these procedures. However, the babies seemingly have no right to protection or life themselves because of the argument regarding when a fetus is determined be human and have life. Pro-life author, Sarah Terzo, in a LifeSiteNews.com article, relays the following testimony supporting this from a medical student upon witnessing his first abortion, “Rejected by their mothers and regarded as medical waste by their killers, society allows these babies to die silently...   [tags: Argument Against Abortion]

Strong Essays
2133 words (6.1 pages)

Essay on Argument Against Euthanasia

- Euthanasia is a Greek word which means, gentle and easy death. However, it is the other way around. It is not a gentle or easy death because there is not a type of death which can called gentle in the world. According to Ian Dowbiggin, in Ancient Greece people used euthanasia without patient's permission. It means that, in Ancient Greece they did not care about the voluntariness. Also, there are just few doctors who adjust themselves according to the Hippocratic Oath. (250 pp.) After coming of Christianity, church learnt how evil suicide was and they told people killing another person or themselves was a brutal behavior....   [tags: Argument Against Assisted Suicide]

Free Essays
1204 words (3.4 pages)

The concept of the Democratic Peace Theory Essay

- ... Autocrats, by contrast, are said to be less threatening opponents, either because they have difficulty locating resources, or because they think they can lose wars without inflicting much domestic pain and therefore choose to spend fewer resources on the war effort. Following this logic, citizens may be averted from using force against democracies because they anticipate high costs of war and a low probability of victory. If there was evidence that democracy affected perceptions of cost and success, this would contravene the idea that democracies are deterred from attacking other democracies because they see them as particularly formidable adversaries....   [tags: political science, political system]

Strong Essays
1755 words (5 pages)

The Benefits of Wearable Identification Tags Essay

- Purpose of Report The purpose of this report is to outline the benefits that an investment in wearable identification tags could bring to the business. This organisation is very human resource intensive and this technology will save resources in this department which will directly benefit the business. Assumptions In preparing this business case, I have made several assumptions regarding the implementation of this technology: • As this is an international company, each separate office has a HR presence and processes time-sheeting locally....   [tags: Radio Frequency Identification Tags]

Strong Essays
1900 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on Argument Against Abortion And Abortion

- ... Judith Jarvis’s main argument is the right to life is not an absolute right, therefore in some cases abortion is permissible. But in another one of her arguments, Jarvis says that it seems like it is not morally permissible to kill a child. Take one of her thought experiments, called the violinist case; You wake up in a hospital with a famous violinist attached to your kidneys, and he needs use of your kidneys for nine months. (1) Every person has a right to life. (2) The violinist is a person....   [tags: Abortion, Morality, Pregnancy, Argument]

Strong Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)