Narrative vs. Montage Essay

Narrative vs. Montage Essay

Length: 1091 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Each film has a distinct purpose associated with it. Whether this purpose is as simple as teaching children a valuable lesson or as complex as criticizing a society’s barriers, there are explicit goals which must be discerningly conveyed. There are specific elements to filmmaking which are designed to contribute to the goals set forth when making a film. Such elements include what would be considered “aesthetics of astonishment,” or striking images, editing conflict and other techniques associated with montage filmmaking. Each of these techniques imprint a thought or logic on a film – a kind of “watermark” – that pushes the film itself towards the accomplishment of the original goals. Regardless of the need for the completion of these “higher goals”, a director’s ability to keep a viewer’s undivided attention is crucial to the success of a film. Each viewer must remain fascinated from start to finish by the plot and characters, or he will lose interest in the film. So, when a film relies on a strong narrative base to keep its audience captivated, there is little room for variation from the elements which depict the story best. Striking montage images or techniques, if not carefully placed, can have a tendency to take the viewer’s eye from the progression of the narrative and turn their thought to something else.
     Quite often, montage aspects of a film are deliberately placed to invoke specific thoughts or feelings. Such techniques can be employed to even go so far as to provide an alternate connotation to an event than what the average viewer would normally formulate. Parallelism is a method designed to do just that. This technique allows directors to have his audience associate a single action or event with a secondary action or event. The Strike parallels the slaughter of a cow and the execution of factory workers to generate a deeper emotion than one would normally associate with murder. The audience does not view the execution as merely mass murder, but instead they compare the soldiers to a butcher and connect the murder itself to something heartless and revolting – a slaughter. The Strike seems to tastefully use this method to strengthen the purpose of the film itself: a criticism of murder and execution. There is, however a fine line between what is tasteful and what is not. If this techniqu...

... middle of paper ...

...en were sickened by the excessive visual conflict. Needless to say, these flashes took a significant amount of attention away from the narrative itself, and one can safely assume that such an event would tend to make a film rather unpopular.
     If the aesthetics of astonishment are not employed whatsoever, the film loses its purpose and becomes an empty recital of the actions of its characters. This deems the striking montage elements necessary. If these elements are overdone, then the audience can and will lose sight of the narrative element. Should this cause the audience to lose interest in the film altogether, then the film is a failure and the director loses credibility. The most important aspect of creating a film is finding a healthy medium between completing the objective of the film and presenting the narrative. Directors are responsible for depicting the necessary montage elements in a film while avoiding creating what Gunning describes as “an excess of mimesis” (FTC). One could argue that this very conflict is what distinguishes films that find this medium as “great films.”

Books used to support this paper:
Film Theory and Criticism
Film Art

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Montage in Films and Music Videos Essay

- In the 1920s, artist like Sergei Eisenstein, Dziga Vertov and Vsevolod Pudovkin started experimenting with the new technique in their abstractfilms which is known as montage. Montage which is a synonym for Editing is a technique where two or more shots are juxtaposed which create a new meaning thatis not existent looking at the shots individually (Manovich, 2001). Few of the early examples of films using this technique are The Battleship Potemkin(1925) by Eisenstein and Man with a Movie Camera(1929) by Vertov.Montages are widely used in many other TV production areas like Advertisement, Dramas, News Programs and Music Videos....   [tags: Film Review, Montage]

Strong Essays
2456 words (7 pages)

Essay on Breakfast Montage Clip in Orsen Welles' Citizen Kane

- Citizen Kane, is a 1941 American film, written, produced, and starred by Orson Welles. This film is often proclaimed by critics,filmmakers, and fans as one of the best if not the best film ever made. Citizen Kane is an unbelievable film becuase of how advanced it is compared to other films of its time. In the film, the producer used many different narrative elements to capture the audiences imagination. It truly is astounding how the filmmakers used certain editing techniques, sounds, and different narrative elements to illustrate the story and the plot....   [tags: technique, editing, narrative]

Strong Essays
694 words (2 pages)

Theory of Montage in Pudovkin’s, Eisenstein’s and Vertov’s movie. Essay

- Introduction In the presented essay I will compare the style of work of selected artists in the montage of the film. I will try to point out some general regularities and features of Soviet cinema. At the same time I will try to capture especially what is common in their systems and similar or conversely what differ. For my analysis, I will draw on the feature films of the Soviet avantgarde, namely these are the movies - The Battleship Potemkin (S. Eisenstein, 1925), Mother (V. Pudovkin, 1926) and The Man with a movie camera (D....   [tags: Soviet Cinema, School of Cinema, Film Analysis]

Strong Essays
1016 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Narrative Report : Alfred Hitchcock 's ' Marnie '

- Narrative Report – Alfred Hitchcock’s ‘Marnie’ 1964 Marnie 1964 is about a woman suffering repressed childhood trauma. As a child, she killed a man and has a difficult relationship with her mother. In adult life, Marnie cannot bare intimacy and commits larceny under false identities. Marnie is blackmailed into marriage and her husband attempts to resolve her behaviour. Marnie confronts repressed memories resulting in newfound self-awareness and possibility of love and stability. I. Story and Plot The above storyline is an explicit and chronological account of events within the film as a whole....   [tags: Fiction, Narrative, Plot, Narratology]

Strong Essays
1378 words (3.9 pages)

Essay about Narrative Analysis Of Trailer ' 12 Years A Slave '

- Part 2: Narrative Analysis of Trailer 12 Years a Slave is a very iconic movie about Solomon Northrup and his being kidnapped into slavery. Northrup was a free man, a professional violinist, and a farmer. After being drugged, he was shipped away from his family and forced to work in New Orleans. During his slavery, he was forced to pick cotton and endure many hardships for 12 years. Eventually, he was freed and returned to his family. The people who captured and enslaved him served no punishment for their crimes since blacks were not allowed to sue white people at that time....   [tags: Slavery, Slavery in the United States]

Strong Essays
2297 words (6.6 pages)

Features of Narrative and Genre in First Ten Minutes of Minority Report Essay

- Features of Narrative and Genre in First Ten Minutes of Minority Report Minority Report has the definite genre of a futuristic sci-fi. Right from the start of the film there are genre conventions to show the viewer what type of film they are watching. At the beginning, the title sequences are contrasted in dark and light shades of blue and the title sequences move like water. The colour blue is used often in futuristic films because it makes everything look futuristic and digital....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
2310 words (6.6 pages)

The Creative Decision Making in a Documentary Production Essay

- This journal inspects the importance of creative decision making in various aspects of documentary production, examines whether those decisions help to make the film an engaging cinematic piece, and explores the influences it might have on the society, the cinema and the subject, in relation to my own experience in producing a 15min documentary film Hackney Pirates, and my understandings of relevant practice from the contemporary cinema. Introduction Films about education for children in critical situations have been seen in cinema since the 1990s....   [tags: folim, narrative, reaction, documentary]

Strong Essays
2073 words (5.9 pages)

Function of Montage in the Film, The Night of the Hunter Essay examples

- Function of Montage in the Film, The Night of the Hunter In The Night of the Hunter various montages are utilized throughout the plot to capture the literal and figurative messages of the movie. The director uses montages to basically allow the audience to grasp the ideas that are being put forth. For instance, when the widow and Icy are talking about marriage plans with Harry Powell, clips of a train interrupt the seemingly continuous conversation. The two women discuss the joyous plans for the marriage and ironically this conversation gets interrupted by a runaway train....   [tags: Movie Film Essays]

Free Essays
346 words (1 pages)

Essay about Use of Montage in the Movie, Night of the Hunter

- Use of Montage in the Movie, Night of the Hunter Ebert said it best when he describes the characters of Night of the Hunter as Norman Rockwell archetypes. Taking place in an unassuming river town presumably during the Great Depression, the plot unravels around $10,000, stolen during a poorly planned bank robbery. No thought need be heeded on the heist, however, seeing as it was not important enough to waste film on. The money serves only to set up the dominoes that will be knocked down rather linearly in this predictable storyline....   [tags: Movie Film Essays]

Free Essays
412 words (1.2 pages)

Essay about Personal Narative- Tough Girl

- Personal Narative- Tough Girl She went to the land of Hollywood with a diamond wedding necklace hanging loosely from her neck like a noose before it gives its snapping goodbye. She went to the land of dreams with pride coloring her shadow; a haughty swing of her thick plait; and why not. Her name was Serina –she was named after a dream. Why not. I thought, though I cried the night before because she got the chance bestowed to her curvy hips, her white Colgate smile, her crystal blue eyes. And what about me....   [tags: Personal Narrative Writing]

Free Essays
1367 words (3.9 pages)