Traditional Western and Disney Ideals as Seen in Mulan Essay example

Traditional Western and Disney Ideals as Seen in Mulan Essay example

Length: 2958 words (8.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Traditional Western and Disney Ideals as Seen in Mulan

Fairy tales have been a long tradition in almost all cultures, starting as oral traditions to and gradually evolving into written texts intended for future generations to enjoy. Today, a common medium for relaying these ancient stories is through animation. The Walt Disney Company is probably the most well known for its animated portrayals of many classic fairy tales. These fairy tales are considered, by fairy tale researcher Justyna Deszcz to be “cultural institutions, which exist within an institutional framework of production, distribution, and reception, as well as fulfilling specific social functions, such as the preservation of the cultural heritage of a given country.” The majority of these Disney fairy tales are derivatives of European stories. However, in 1998 Disney opened its first animated feature with an Asian theme in both the United States and Asia. Disney’s Mulan seems to stray from the traditional structure of a Disney fairytale, those which have a “relatively uncomplicated sequence of adventures, revolving around impeccably positive characters, who, depending on their gender, either conquer evil or passively wait to be rescued” (Deszcz). Disney’s Mulan was aimed to please both the Asian and modern American markets. However, the Walt Disney Company fails to completely step away from its established model in terms of portrayals of minorities, Western depictions of men being dominant in the fairy-tale world, and a woman’s ultimate role and happiness being conditional on men. Mulan continues to promote Disney’s idea of Western cultures as being ideal and its sexist views regarding women.
     The story of the great Chinese female warrior, Hua Mulan, first appeared as a ballad titled “Ode to Mulan” in approximately 500 A. D. In the ballad, there is a young woman by the name of Mulan who is feeling dejected because she has just gone into town where she saw lists of men’s names who are being called to serve in the Chinese army. One man on the list is Mulan’s crippled father. Because she has no older brother who can take his place, Mulan, with the consent of her parents, then decides to go to the marketplace and buy a horse and saddle so that she may go to war. Mulan leaves and fights in the war against the Huns for twelve years. When she returns, her troop is honore...


... middle of paper ...


...rsity of Southern California Lib., Los Angeles, CA. 22 April 2004 .
Gleiberman, Owen. “Mulan.” Entertainment Weekly 17 July 1998: 63.
He, Zhongshun. “What Does the American Mulan Look Like?.” Chinese Sociology &
Anthropology 32.2 (1999):23-24.
Kuhn, Anthony. “China to Show 'Mulan,' Seeming to End Its Dispute With Disney.” The
Los Angeles Times. 8 Feb. 1999: 14. Proquest. Electric Lib University of
Southern California Lib., Los Angeles, CA. 22 April 2004 .
Li, Fei. “Plan for Mulan’s Marketing Strategy.” Chinese Sociology & Anthropology 32.2
(1999): 15-19.
“Mulan’s China Woes.” Asiaweek. 2 April 1999. 26 April 2004. .
Shao, Peng. “Analysis of Mulan’s Selling Points and Marketing Operations.” Chinese
Sociology & Anthropology 32.2 (1999):11-14.
Song, Quanzhong. “Mulan’s Former Home Hitches a Ride with Disney.” Chinese
Sociology & Anthropology 32.2 (1999): 33-34.
Zhang, Renjie. “Ode to Mulan.” Chinese Sociology & Anthropology 32.2 (1999): 30-32.

Zhang, Yang. “Thoughts Elicited by Illustration.” Chinese Sociology & Anthropology
32.2 (1999): 26-27.
Zhu, Yi. “Seeing Mulan in the United States.” Chinese Sociology & Anthropology 32.2
(1999): 20-22.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Disney's Inaccurate Portrayal of Mulan and Pocahontas Essay

- Many times, things are not what they seem. Deception is often used to publicize things in a different light and it distorts actual historical content and facts. One example of this is when Disney inaccurately portrays the actual life of historical characters such as Mulan and Pocahontas. In the movie Mulan, based on the “Ballad of Mulan,” Disney inaccurately portrays her life causing many incongruities. In the movie, Mulan is portrayed as being weak and unskilled with weapons and horsemanship....   [tags: Mulan, Pocahontas]

Strong Essays
913 words (2.6 pages)

Media and the Antifeminist Agenda Essays

- ... Merida’s coming of age brings forth the inevitable adult duties that she must assume as a woman. Through the context of the film, marriage is a tradition, intended to keep the peace among clans with a history of warfare, and therefore its Merida’s duty to maintain amity among these groups; a theme that is not at all to different from modern day society, were marriage is used as means to build bridges or insure economic/financial stability. “A princess doesn’t raise her voice; she is cautious, clean” and above all, strives for perfection.” (Brave....   [tags: media, cinemias, pixar, disney]

Strong Essays
813 words (2.3 pages)

Disney's Approach to Cultural Difference Essay

- Disney’s approach to cultural difference is deeply rooted in its need to appeal to an American audience. The film Mulan (1998), while celebrated for its vast improvement of stereotypical depictions of other cultures, is not different in its paternalistic approach to Chinese culture. Mulan contains orientalism which is depicted through the stereotypical depictions of both the Chinese and the Huns, the view of Chinese traditions and cultural norms as restrictive to Mulan, and the constant bombardment of American culture within the film all of which is to better appeal to an American audience....   [tags: film mulan, orientalism, chinese]

Strong Essays
1268 words (3.6 pages)

White Tigers vs. Mulan Essay

- William Shakespeare once said, “[My] honor is my life; both grow in one; take honor from me, and my life is done.” The idea is touched upon in both the book Woman Warrior by Maxine Hong Kingston as well as Disney’s Mulan were family honor is more important than anything else. Mulan was directed by Tony Bancroft and Barry Cook, and produced by Walt Disney Pictures. The film Mulan retold the story of a woman warrior who took her father’s place in battle and became a savior of China.The movie uses many elements from the original story told in the chapter “White Tigers,” but adds many modern twists in order to make the story more appealing for a newer generation....   [tags: Woman Warrior, Maxine Hong Kingston, Disney]

Strong Essays
973 words (2.8 pages)

The Legend of Hua Mulan Essay example

- The legend states that Hua Mulan lived during the Northern Wei dynasty. She is a mythical figure from ancient China portrayed in the Chinese poem, Ballad of Mulan. Though both princess warrior show and movie, The Legend of Hua Mulan and Disney’s Mulan have different character personalities and reasons of going to war. The Legend of Hua Mulan is straightforward and seeks to depict Mulan as a warrior. Disney’s Mulan, however, depicts Mulan as trying to prove her parents wrong and bring home a man as in all Disney movies....   [tags: China, warrior, Disney]

Strong Essays
748 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about Gender Roles in Mulan

- The Disney movie, Mulan, is a fantastic movie that depicts gender-stereotyped roles, socialization of gender roles, and consequences of over stepping one’s gender role. Both males and females have a specific role in the Chinese society that one must follow. Mulan made a brave choice pretending to be a man and going to war against the Huns in place of her father, risking serious consequences if she were to get caught. She broke the socialization of gender roles and could have been faced with very serious consequences of her actions....   [tags: Disney movie analysis]

Strong Essays
753 words (2.2 pages)

Film Reproduction: Cultural Reconstruction or Deterioration? Essay

- Mulan, an American animated musical action-comedy-drama film released in 1998, has been well received by critics and the public with grossing $304 million, earning Academy Award nominations and winning several Annie Awards including Best Animated Feature. Adapted from an ancient Chinese story on a legendary girl Mulan who volunteers to join the army by masquerading as a man in order to replace her aged father, the film integrates non-Chinese value, ideology and expectation into the original narrative....   [tags: Mulan, Disney, authentic]

Strong Essays
2626 words (7.5 pages)

Essay on Movie Analysis : Mulan 's Mulan

- Mulan seems to be a feminist film which encourages individual women to take care of themselves. However, the film is not free from traditional gender roles. While the film may be progressive by removing the "damsel in distress" plot, further analysis shows it isn’t a feminist film at all. Disney’s Mulan reinforces a black and white societal role of gender that privilege men over women. In contrast the poem is incredibly progressive, it shows a woman fighting just as well as men and men accepting her as a powerful warrior not being jealous of her power....   [tags: Gender role, Gender, Man, Woman]

Strong Essays
1066 words (3 pages)

Essay on Sociological Analysis Of Mulan 's Mulan

- Sociology in Mulan Mulan tells that the story of brave Mulan. Mulan did not want her elderly father to fight in the war, so she disguised as a man and joined in her father 's army. Finally, Mulan defeated the Huns and Shan Yu (leader of the Huns) with her partners in barracks. This Disney film portrays the conflict perspective, feminism, and symbolic interaction perspective. The conflict theory is the perspective that opposition and conflict define a given society and are necessary for social evolution....   [tags: Sociology, Gender role, Gender, Patriarchy]

Strong Essays
1452 words (4.1 pages)

Movie Analysis : Mulan 's ' Mulan ' Essay

- The classic Disney movie, Mulan, is often praised as a film involving feminist empowerment, but upon closer look just the opposite appears to be true. The classic storyline includes Mulan, a young Chinese woman, taking over her fragile father’s place in the Chinese army, disguised as a man named Ping. She trains among the other soldiers, becoming one of the very best with her accompanying guardian dragon, Mushu and a cricket her grandmother gave her for luck for the matchmakers by her side. She ends up saving all of China by revealing that the Huns are back and invading the country, and is honored as a hero....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Woman, Masculinity]

Strong Essays
1331 words (3.8 pages)