An Analysis of The Thurber Carnival Essay

An Analysis of The Thurber Carnival Essay

Length: 1078 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

An Analysis of The Thurber Carnival  

    The Fables for Our Time contained in Thurber's The Thurber Carnival are, in my opinion, particularly good examples of a writer successfully 'breaking frames' in order to create humor and satire. In this essay I am going to explore the main methods Thurber uses to create humor and satire in the fables "The Shrike and the Chipmunks" and "The Unicorn in the Garden"2.

Firstly though, what do I mean by the 'broken frame'? This is a reference to the idea that the violation of our 'frames of reference', and the recognition of the incongruity caused by it, is the basic element of humour. If the incongruity needs to be explained, the humour will be lost. Kant expresses this idea when he says "Laughter is an affection arising from a strained expectation being suddenly reduced to nothing"3.

Thurber violates several different types of expectation in his attempts to create humour and satire. These range from expectation of the rules of fable and other literature, to expectation of characterisation, and expectation of the familiar saying.

"The Shrike and the Chipmunks", is first and foremost a parody of the traditional fable. It has all the traditional ingredients: the anthropomorphised Chipmunks, corresponding with stereotyped human characters, the building of suspense over a perceived right and wrong type of behaviour, a corresponding climax, and a moral at the end.

Anthropomorphism is a common technique of humour. Umberto Eco explains that this is so that the audience can laugh at the 'broken frame', without the discomfort of empathy with the frame breaker. "It is for this reason that the animalisation of the comic hero is so important"4. But quite apart from this use, Thur...

... middle of paper ...

... 1-9.

Kant, Immanuel.

Critique of Judgement, Book II. E307 Photocopy. pp. 196-203.

Thurber, James.

The Thurber Carnival. Harmondsworth, Middlesex, England: Penguin Books, 1983.


End Notes

1. Umberto Eco, "Frames of Comic Freedom," in Carnival!, ed. T. A. Sebeok (Berlin: Mouton Publishers, 1984), p. 4.

2. James Thurber, The Thurber Carnival (Harmondsworth, Middlesex, England: Penguin Books, 1983). Fables for Our Time pp. 278 - 305. "The Shrike and the Chipmunks" pp. 290-291. "The Unicorn in the Garden" pp. 304-305.

3. Immanuel Kant, Critique of Judgement, Book II, E307 Photocoy. p. 199.

4. Eco, p. 2.

5. Thurber, p. 290.

6. Thurber, p. 290.

7. Thurber, p. 291.

8. Thurber, p.305.

9. Burton Bernstein, Thurber: A Biography (Great Britain: Lowe & Brydone, 1975), p. 308.

10. Eco, p. 2.



Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Review of University Days by James Thurber Essay examples

- In the essay, “University Days” James Thurber does a sensational job keeping the reader’s interest throughout the entire story. He explains his college experiences in a way that makes the reader both interested and amused at the same time. Thurber portrays the message that the all-star football player was not the brightest bulb on the tree, which is humorous because many people can relate to that because it’s the same at their school. The author uses a creative writing style to try and capture his audience’s attention throughout the entire essay....   [tags: James Thurber]

Strong Essays
1349 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Seeking an Identity through Carnival

- According to the article History of Carnival, in the past carnival was a tradition that celebrated the day before lent. As stated in the article History of Carnival, "Hundred and hundreds of years ago, the followers of the Catholic religion in Italy started the tradition of holding a wild costume festival right before the first day of Lent. Because Catholics are not supposed to eat meat during Lent, they called their festival, carnevale — which means “to put away the meat.” The French, who migrated to Trinidad, brought this tradition with them....   [tags: article review, culture, trinidad carnival]

Strong Essays
1030 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Humorist for the Common Man: James Thurber

- As America was changing during the early twentieth century, so was humor and few writers could easily adapt to this change with success as well as James Thurber did as a cartoonist, journalist, and an author of short stories, fables, fairytales, and plays, Thurber highlighted the problems of everyday life that were often the result of the transition in America from a masculine, frontier society, to an urban, more feminized society (Buckley, New Criterion). He shied away from major problems of the world and instead made his focus “the immemorial stupidities, cruelties and perversities of men that lie at the root of our ills” (Hasley)....   [tags: humor, james thurber, common man]

Strong Essays
1196 words (3.4 pages)

A Modern Fable: “The Catbird Seat” by James Thurber Essay

- This short story entitled “The Catbird Seat” is a modern fable. The definition of a fable is a simple story with animal characters in which the big strong animal is bested, overcome by, or made a fool of by the weaker character. A modern fable is a fable that takes place in modern times. This short story by James Thurber takes place in New York City around the 1940s. Many fables written before are very much alike “The Catbird Seat” when it comes to being a fable. For example, in “The Tortoise and the Hare” the cocky, arrogant rabbit keeps on boasting about how speedy he is to the scrawny, sluggish turtle....   [tags: Catbird Seat, James Thurber, ]

Strong Essays
1288 words (3.7 pages)

Analysis Of ' N Go And Samba Carnival Essay

- Blog 26 – Get ready to party with Play’n GO and Samba Carnival It may only be January, but the online casino industry is already showing signs that this year will be even bigger and better than last. Building off the barnstorming years of online slots action that have previously been served up, developers around the world are putting their thinking caps on to create some truly imaginative new games. Making sure that they aren’t surpassed by the competition is seems that Play’n GO has plenty of Brazilian brilliance tucked up their sleeve....   [tags: Gambling, Casino, Slot machine, Samba]

Strong Essays
1731 words (4.9 pages)

Chopin VS Thurber and Relationships Essay

- In the stories “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty” by James Thurber (Clugston, sec. h1.1) and “The Story of an Hour” by Kate Chopin (Clugston, sec. h2.1) escapism is a similar theme with in both these stories, yet there is a slight variance in how each of these authors place these characters into their escape from reality, relationships, and everyday chaos. In each of these stories the author shows the characters escaping the realities of the relationship, one through Walter Mitts’ daydreams, and the other through one brief hour when Louise Mallard pictures her new life of freedom....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Strong Essays
2538 words (7.3 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' The ' Essay

- The narrator, Montresor, opens the story by stating that he has been irreparably insulted by his acquaintance, Fortunato, and that he seeks revenge. He wants to exact this revenge, however, in a measured way, without placing himself at risk. He decides to use Fortunato’s fondness for wine against him. During the carnival season, Montresor, wearing a mask of black silk, approaches Fortunato. He tells Fortunato that he has acquired something that could pass for Amontillado, a light Spanish sherry....   [tags: The Cask of Amontillado, Sherry, Carnival]

Strong Essays
1277 words (3.6 pages)

Essay about Analysis of "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty" by James Thurber

- James Thurber, one of America’s best known humorists, is mainly known for “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty.” The story was first published in 1939 in the New Yorker magazine, for which he worked in, and received much appraise for it. Although Thurber did not receive much education, he had a talent of hiding the themes of his stories, which some critics considered “dark,” underneath the humorous plots. In “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty,” Thurber uses his comical character and settings, along with other elements of his stories, to fully express his views on society....   [tags: routine, dull society, realism]

Strong Essays
1193 words (3.4 pages)

Dickens, Thurber, Andersen, London and Perseus Essay

- Dickens, Thurber, Andersen, London and Perseus As far back as I can remember, my mind has always thought and learned by association. My brain fancifully connects things like computer terminals and bus terminals, Indian reservations with plane ticket confirmations, and carpetbaggers with rug stealers. Don’t ask me why, but I think I get bored with ordinary human communications and then lapse into my imaginary fantasy’ association world, finding it much more fascinating than the nightly news, soap operas and talking head yakety-yak cable tabloid shows....   [tags: science]

Free Essays
884 words (2.5 pages)

The Shoe Carnival Essay

- The Shoe Carnival Character List: Whitley (Cashier) Raymond (Floor Supervisor) Jessica (Floor Supervisor) Brett (Sales Associate) Karen (Loss Prevention) Shoplifter(female) Customer #1 Police Officer Extra Customers in store Setting: The Shoe Carnival is a retail store where this scene takes place. It is approximately 7 p.m. and one of the employee’s, Whitley is returning to work after a brief break. Just as she is approaching the entrance to the store she notices the flashing police lights and a crowd of spectators....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
457 words (1.3 pages)