The objective of this article critique is to review and evaluate several empirical studies which have examined mathematics perception cross-culturally. The main study that focuses on examining mathematics perception cross-culturally is a study that was done in 2004 by Dr. Yea-Ling Tsao. In this study, researchers proved that Taiwanese students consistently score higher in cross-national studies of achievement than American students. Several other studies were done that also support this theory. Therefore, the main purpose of this article critique is to evaluate Tsao’s study in order to properly assess both the validity of Tsao’s design and the inferences drawn from the study. This critique will also show that, while different studies were done at different times, researchers still have come up with one consistent hypothesis: American students are constantly scoring below the national average in academic testing.
In order for Tsao to complete her study, she came up with specific research questions and hypotheses for her study. The study done in 2004 was to determine why is it that Chinese students are constantly amongst the top scorers in cross-national studies of achievement and American students are constantly below the national average. Dr. Yea-Ling Tsao gives an example early on in her article about how different studies have shown that American students are consistently performing poorly on tests of mathematics and science. She also gives an example of how in a recent national study of mathematics achievement, American students in the middle school grades were performing lower than the national average in problem solving, geometry, algebra, calculus, and other areas of mathematics. In contrast, Japanese students from the same grade level had significantly higher average scores.
In this study, Dr. Yea-Ling Tsao is trying to understand the reasons for the different perceptions of mathematics of Taiwanese children compared to American children. Tsao is concerned in taking a deeper look at the cross-cultural differences in mathematics perception and attitudes of younger children. Those tested were 21 students in Denver, Colorado, and 37 students in Taipei, Taiwan.
The researcher’s main concern in the study was to determine if attitudes and beliefs ...
... middle of paper ...
All of the studies that were analyzed were given to young subjects. While we do need the relevancy of young children, we also need to see the effect of the parent and care-givers of the young children. As we all know, most thoughts and perceptions of children stem from their parent’s thoughts and perceptions. That is why it is absolutely vital for researchers to first study how children are taught and who better to show this than their parents.
Stevenson, Harold W., Lee, Shin-ying & Stigler, James W. (1986). Mathematics Achievement of Chinese, Japanese, and American Children. Science, New Series, Vol. 231, No. 4739, 693-699.
Stevenson, Harold W., Chen, Chuansheng & Lee, Shin-ying. (1993). Mathematics Achievement of Chinese, Japanese, and American Children: Ten Years Later. Science, New Series, Vol. 259, No. 5091, 53-58.
Stigler, James W., Lee, Shin-Ying & Stevenson, Harold W. (1987). Mathematics Classrooms in Japan, Taiwan, and the United States. Child Development, 58, 1272-1285.
Tsao, Y. (2004). A comparison of American and Taiwanese Students: Their Math Perception. Journal of Instructional Psychology, 31, 206-213.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Some Background behind Taiwan Taiwan, a small island on the coast of Mainland China, after WWII was occupied by the KMT, led by Chiang Kai-Shek along with his followers fled to Taiwan due to the loss of the Chinese Civil War. The U.S financially backing the KMT, due to their fight against communism during the Cold War Era, led to massive industrialization in Taiwan and political tension between Taiwan and China. Thus during the 1950s and on, Taiwanese people, mostly students, started to immigrate into America and try to assimilate into the American lifestyle.... [tags: Taiwanese Americans]
1508 words (4.3 pages)
- Mexican American Mothers’ Perceptions of Childhood Obesity The purpose of this literature review is to characterize Mexican American parents’ perceptions regarding childhood obesity, current prevention efforts, and their role in prevention. The findings are categorized by a theory-guided approach. The aims regarding this Mexican American mothers’ perception and knowledge will critically evaluate the methodological quality of the research conducted, and how the purposes of preventative behavior construct is applied to prevention using specific criteria.... [tags: Scientific method, Perception, Mexican American]
734 words (2.1 pages)
- Chang and McConkey (2008) deliberate over the fact that Taiwan has few family service programs for families of disabled children and at that, the facilities do not measure to programs available in western cultures (Sloper, 1999). Therefore, most financial assistance and medical testing are available based on if the children have a certificate of disability and with this, the main support for these families come from close family members (Chang & McConkey, 2008). As a result, the family unit is strained.... [tags: Disability, Developmental disability]
702 words (2 pages)
- Taiwan has struggled to find its identity in the world ever since 1971 when Taiwan (The Republic of China) was replaced by the People’s Republic of China in the United Nations. The Current Relationship between Taiwan and China is very complicated and every person has a different understanding of it. People often times questions the truthfulness of the history between and China and Taiwan and it has almost came to the conclusion that this simply cannot be described in detail and cannot be proven to be the truth.... [tags: Taiwanese Identity ]
1738 words (5 pages)
- MEC 7501 Professional Article Review Article Critique: Perceptions of Children with ADHD Maddy La Voe Wilmington University Abstract This paper examines and analyzes the article “Exasperating or Exceptional. Parents’ Interpretations of Their Child’s ADHD Behavior” by Heather C. Lench, Linda J. Levine, and Carol K. Whalen. The paper provides an analysis of a study conducted in 2013 which examined the role of behavioral perception in families affected by ADHD. An introduction, rationale of the study, description of procedure and participants, and results are all included.... [tags: Psychology, Perception]
915 words (2.6 pages)
- Western Perceptions of the American Indian In this reflective essay, I discuss how the Europeans perceived the American Indians and the factors that shaped these perceptions. I have paid particular attention to the first-hand accounts of the encounters with the natives, written by Western explorers, missionaries, and visitors to the New World. It is particularly interesting to note how these accounts were distorted and exploited by different groups, each trying to mold the situation in their own way.... [tags: Indians Native American Essays]
2554 words (7.3 pages)
- My Mother is Taiwanese, I’m American The musty air and the sagging seats with stuffing spilling out indicate the weariness of the high school auditorium. I drum my fingers on the polished wood of the armrests, over the grooves of carved initials: "J.Y. + C.A." Indifferently, I wonder if their relationship has endured as long as the engraved proclamation. J.Y. must be a girl, I decide for no particular reason. Jayne . . . Johanna . . . Jackie . . . . Slouched down in the shabby velvet seat, I feign aloofness to the excitement buzzing around me.... [tags: Personal Narrative Profile Essays]
747 words (2.1 pages)
- Childhood obesity in America is a growing disease that has become an epidemic that has lasting psychological effects because of advertisement of fast food, lack of physical activities, and parental control has made food become a major health issue in many young teenagers’ lives today. Who is to blame. Childhood obesity has more than tripled in the past 30 years (cdc.gov). this takes us to the focus of how childhood obesity has become an enormous issue today. For us to understand the impact of obesity and why we should prevent it, we will need to figure out the causes of obesity and what keeps people obese.... [tags: Obesity in Children]
1492 words (4.3 pages)
- Photos of Japanese American Children in Internment Camps, 1942-1945 Amid a growing anti-Japanese sentiment during World War II, President Franklin Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066 on February 19, 1942, which called for the evacuation of all persons of Japanese descent from the West Coast. Many individuals and families evacuated to assembly centers and eventually internment camps in ten inland locations across the country. Among the more than 100,000 people of Japanese ancestry interned, many of those were children, and most of these children were American citizens.... [tags: Photos Japanese American Children Essays]
2104 words (6 pages)
- Canadian and Taiwanese Schools School is the best place for people to be educated. Everyone has to go through this stage in order to be knowledgeable, so they can be useful in society and solve any problems they encounter. Not only they are educated for themselves but also for their countries. Different countries have different systems on how to teach students. Canada's educational system is a perfect and ideal way to ensure that students will live successful lives. Canadian high school students study both compulsory and elective courses together.... [tags: Education Teaching Essays]
659 words (1.9 pages)