Many Views of Melville's Bartelby The Scrivener Essay

Many Views of Melville's Bartelby The Scrivener Essay

Length: 2395 words (6.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Research Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

     All literary works are written from a specific standpoint. This standpoint originates from the mind of the author. The author, when creating his literary work, has a specific diagram/plan and vision of what the story is supposed to convey. However, not all readers will interpret the literary work in the way that the author him/herself has presented it. Many times, in fact, the audience will perceive the literary work as having an entirely different meaning than what it was meant to have.

The short story, Bartelby the Scrivener by Herman Melville, has been reviewed by several different critics as having several different standpoints. These standpoints include Bartelby as a Psychological Double to the Narrator, an apostle of reason, having biblical ties, and as being Melville himself. A personal standpoint that proves to be different than those that have come before it is to perceive the story, Bartelby the Scrivener, as a story of family. Of all of these views and interpretations of the story Bartelby the Scrivener, none can be perceived as correct, except by the author. Furthermore, none can be seen as incorrect because literary works, unlike visual works of art, leave us the option to imagine. In fact, our interpretation of another critic’s thesis is merely a product of our views on their standpoints. I say that only to justify that we are able to formulate our own opinions and form our own thesis just by reading the words on the page.

Bartelby as a Psychological Double
     The critic of this standpoint is Mordecai Marcus. He feels that Bartelby is a paralleled character or a “psychological double” of the narrator. In his criticism of Bartelby the Scrivener, he writes:
               “I believe that the character of Bartelby is a psychological
                double for the story’s nameless lawyer-narrator, and that
                the story’s criticism of a sterile and impersonal society
can best be clarified by investigation of this role.” -
“Bartelby appears to be the lawyer chiefly to remind him
of the inadequacies, the sterile routine, of his world.”
                                   (College English, pg. 68)

     Marcus is trying to say that Bartelby and the narrator have a sort of inter-connection. Not as two separate entities, but as two separate personalities residing in one, viewing life from separate standpoints. ...

... middle of paper ...

...s audience, I cannot limit myself to just these theories. Countless other theories can be formed on the actual theme of the story. I truly believe that Melville had those intentions, not only for this story, but also for all the stories that he has written. Literary works are meant to be examined and interpreted by the individual reading it. Authors produce the material. All we are required to do is produce the imagination and personal understanding of what has been presented before us.


1.) College English, Vol. 23, No.5, February, 1962, pp.365‐68

2.) Indian Journal of American Studies, Vol.4, Nos. 1-2, June and December, 1974. Pp.66-71.

3.) Meyer, Michael The Bedford Introduction to Literature, Library of Congress Catalog
Number: 98-85194, copyright 1999 by Bedford/St. Martin.

3.) Reference Guide to Short Fiction, 1st ed., edited by Noelle Watson, St. James Press,

4.) Short Stories for Students, Gale Research, 1997

Key: (as cited in the paper)

(IJ of AS) – Indian Journal of American Studies
(BI to L) – The Bedford Introduction to Literature
(RG to SF) – Reference Guide to Short Fiction
(SS for S) – Short Stories for Students

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Lawyer and the Pandhandler in "Bartleby the Scrivener" by Herman Melville

- In the story of Bartleby the Scrivener by Herman Melville, there is a lawyer who narrates the entire story. He owns his own law practice and also has an assortment of scribes who work for him. The first scrivener, named Turkey, was a hard worker until 12 o’ clock noon daily. Following that time, his work begins to diminish. The second, who they called Nippers, was the complete opposite. He worked best during the afternoon and evening hours. Lastly, Bartleby didn’t do much work at all. He was lazy, he had nothing to lose, and he understood how to take advantage of someone else’s kindness....   [tags: Bartleby the Scrivener. Herman Melville, employees]

Research Papers
528 words (1.5 pages)

Essay on Herman Melville's Bartleby, the Scrivener

- Herman Melville's "Bartleby, the Scrivener" The narrator states fairly early on in Herman Melville's "Bartleby, the Scrivener" that both he and Bartleby are "sons of Adam" (55). The phrase plays on a double entendre, referring to both the Calvinist Biblical Eden and to the view of America as the "new Eden." Many recent critics have traced the biblical aspects of this and other elemen ts of the story, claiming the character of Bartleby as a Christ-figure, and as such carries out the role of a redeemer.1 The story, however, is not Bartleby's, but rather the narrator's....   [tags: Herman Melville Bartleby Scrivener Essays]

Research Papers
3535 words (10.1 pages)

Herman Melville's Story, Bartleby, the Scrivener Essay

- In Herman Melville's short story, Bartleby, the Scrivener, the narrator's attitude towards Bartleby is constantly changing, the narrator's attitude is conveyed through the author's use of literary elements such as; diction-descriptive and comical, point of view-first person, and tone-confusion and sadness. One of the literary elements that Melville uses that convey the narrator's attitude towards Bartleby is diction. The author's diction in this short story is very descriptive and is also slightly comical....   [tags: Bartleby the Scrivener]

Research Papers
839 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Bartelby the Scrivener

- Bartelby the Scrivener Herman Melville, an American novelist and major literary figure explored psychological themes in many of his works. Through his writing, Melville recreated a part of life that existed then, and is prevalent in our society today. Low self esteem along with self-perception and how others perceive us can be a factor leading to depression. Depression, if left untreated can become so severe that it is possible to cause someone to lose the will to live. I will clarify this illness and it’s ill effects in the story “Bartleby the Scrivener”, by Herman Melville....   [tags: essays papers]

Research Papers
662 words (1.9 pages)

Bartleby The Scrivener And The Hunger Artist Essay example

- Alienation, the state of being isolated from a group or category that one should be apart of, exists in three forms; man’s alienation from man, man’s alienation from fellow men, and man’s alienation from the world itself. These three classes of alienation are fluid phases of the same process that exists to some extent within every member of society. The intriguing and complex nature of alienation has sparked the interest of many philosophers, artists, and authors around the world, resulting in works of art and literature that attempt to give insight into living life alone....   [tags: Short story, Fiction, Herman Melville, Scrivener]

Research Papers
980 words (2.8 pages)

Themes of Hopelessness in Herman Melville’s Bartleby the Scrivener Essay

- We can never be one hundred percent certain of the validity of our literary analyses. This is especially the case with Herman Melville’s “Bartleby the Scrivener”. Critics have been trying for decades to make sense of the text and most will describe it as “inscrutable”. I don’t claim to know better than the critics, but instead offer my own interpretation of the work. Based on my observations and analysis, Melville’s use of many elements in his story—first and foremost the character of Bartleby, but also the dead letters, the many walls of Wall Street, and the state of Wall Street itself—works well to develop a sense of hopelessness, whether intentional or not, in the story as well as the nar...   [tags: Bartleby the Scrivener Essays]

Research Papers
1228 words (3.5 pages)

Bartelby the Scrivener: A Story of Wall Street Essay

- Bartelby To eat or not to eat is the dilemma which is reiterated throughout "Bartleby the Scrivener: A Story of Wall-Street". This same dilemma presents itself within the minds of the story’s characters as well. Settings and characters reinforce the theme of food and feasting. Character’s nicknames such as Turkey, Nippers, Mr. Cutlets, and Ginger-nut introduce this theme of food and nurishment. "Smell[ing] of eating-houses" and having "gentleness [from the] effects of beer"(p.1118), Turkey is descibed with metaphors of food....   [tags: essays papers]

Free Essays
895 words (2.6 pages)

Individual Freedom in Melville's Bartleby, the Scrivener Essay

- Individual Freedom in Melville's Bartleby, the Scrivener What motivates you to go to work everyday. What motivates you to dress the way you do. What motivates you to be reasonable when it comes to normal requests. Ah, the ultimate question in need of an answer: Who determines what is reasonable and normal, and should we not determine these matters for ourselves. Chaos would result, you say, if every individual were granted that freedom. Yet, we all do have that freedom, and Herman Melville (1819-1891) through the interpretation of a man who prefers to follow his own path in "Bartleby, the Scrivener", subjectively conveys the mental anguish he experienced as a writer and man when the lite...   [tags: Bartleby Scrivener Essays]

Research Papers
854 words (2.4 pages)

The Plight of the Common Man in Herman Melville's Bartleby, the Scrivener

- George Edward Woodberry, author of the Heart of Man, published in 1899, emphasized the significance of the role of the individual as an active and equal partner in American democratic rule: The doctrine of the equality of mankind by virtue of their birth as men, with its consequent right to equality of opportunity for self-development as a part of social justice, establishes a common basis of conviction, in respect to man, and a definite end as one main object of the State; and these elements are primary in the democratic scheme....   [tags: Bartleby the Scrivener Essays]

Research Papers
4254 words (12.2 pages)

Essay about Herman Melville's Bartleby the Scrivener

- Since he will not quit me, I must quit him. "Ah Bartleby, Ah Humanity." (Page 140, Herman Melville) This is the key to Bartleby, written by Herman Melville, for it indicates that Bartleby stands as a symbol for humanity. This in turn functions as a commentary on society and the working world, for Bartleby is a seemingly homeless, mentally disturbed scrivener who gives up on the prospect of living life. However, by doing so Bartleby is attempting to exercise his freewill, for he would "prefer not to" work....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
1089 words (3.1 pages)