A Feminist Analysis of Perceval, Tristan and Isolt, and Aucassin and Nicolette

A Feminist Analysis of Perceval, Tristan and Isolt, and Aucassin and Nicolette

Length: 1173 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Feminist Analysis of Perceval, Tristan and Isolt, and Aucassin and Nicolette  

Currently, there is a debate among feminists as to whether the demeaning portrayal of women in popular media causes or is caused by negative attitudes in modern culture. A similar debate exists among historians of the late middle ages as to whether the rise in popularity of the cult of the Virgin, her portrayal in art, and the code of chivalry caused or was caused by changing attitudes towards women.

Many factors in the late middle ages coincided to create an entirely new role for women: contact with the Muslim world in Spain, the rising popularity of religious life, and the aforementioned cultural changes. All of these factors are intertwined with the new attitudes that arose around women. Virginity became exalted, femininity was lauded, courtly love turned women into objects of devotion rather than objects of desire. In short, women were placed on a pedestal. The cultural paradox of this shift in attitudes is that by being placed on that pedestal, women became objects rather than individuals. This dichotomy between respect for women as a group and respect for individual women is clearly shown in three Medieval Romances. Perceval, Tristan and Isolt, and Aucassin and Nicolette may vary greatly in plot, tone and style, but the underlying assumption is the same. In the Medieval Romance, women may be objects of devotion, but they are still merely objects to earned, won, owned and dominated.

The first example of this attitude is the saga of the damsel whom Perceval boorishly assaults. This woman, never named, is utterly enslaved and abused by men. Perceval, not heeding her protests, forces her into a compromising situation and then robs he...

... middle of paper ...

...band is a Muslim. The Christian king of Biaucaire, by contrast, does not honor her right to self-determination. The Muslim roots of Nicolette's relative freedom serve as one answer to the question of whether this literature is derivative of the culture or whether it shaped the culture. From this evidence, it seems that the former is true.

The pervasiveness of the oppressive attitudes demonstrated in these texts show clearly the dichotomous view of women in the late middle ages. The respect of womanhood which was so central to the chivalric code did not translate into greater freedom for women themselves. Modern opponents of feminism claim that the Women’s Movement has reversed this dichotomy, namely that individual freedoms have devalued women as a group. Perhaps we should ask why our culture has a problem with valuing womanhood and valuing women concurrently.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Romance Of Tristan And Iseult Character Analysis

- In The Romance of Tristan and Iseult, our characters face many challenges but must follow a different code for how to deal with them. Tristan is an ideal representative of the chivalric knight that faces a large number of situations where many people would be incapable of maintaining morals. We see the feudal structure of this medieval time in place and its importance to maintaining the structure. The Romance of Tristan and Iseult displays the chivalric roles required in this society through Tristan and his many interactions....   [tags: Feudalism, Tristan and Iseult, Prose Tristan]

Strong Essays
955 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Consequences of Passion Exposed in The Romance of Tristan and Iseult

- Consequences of Passion Exposed in The Romance of Tristan and Iseult The story of Tristan and Iseult celebrates the triumph of adultery. When looking vaguely at this romance, readers may think the potion of love that they both drink is the one that makes them to commit adultery. However, this is only a representation of the power of passion and lust Tristan and Iseult have for each other. To better understand this love story, one must realize that Tristan is a marshal hero who volunteers to take a battle against the King of Ireland, in order to redeem the people and the monarch of King Mark....   [tags: The Romance of Tristan and Iseult]

Strong Essays
918 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about The Carnivores Dilemma, by Nicolette Hahn Niman

- Millions of animals are consumed everyday; humans are creating a mass animal holocaust, but is this animal holocaust changing the climate. In the essay “ The Carnivores Dilemma,” written by Nicolette Hahn Niman, a lawyer and livestock rancher, asserts that food production, most importantly beef production, is a global contributor to climate change. Nicolette Niman has reports by United Nations and the University of Chicago and the reports “condemn meat-eating,” and the reports also say that beef production is closely related to global warming....   [tags: Climate Change and Food Production]

Strong Essays
1020 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of The Movie ' Tristan '

- He stared at me for a minute and then his head dropped. He leaned back against the door and kicked it with his boot as he let a few obscenities fly. When he raised his head, his eyes glowed. I flinched and almost turned away, my earlier fear that he might put some spell on me, rearing its ugly head. But I knew him better than that. I reached for his hand. “Tristan, I want nothing more than to go with you, to help Pikipsi and your people. I would love to never see Eva again, for as long as I live, but not like this....   [tags: 2007 singles, 2006 singles, Debut albums]

Strong Essays
1366 words (3.9 pages)

The Novel Tristan by Thomas Mann Essay

- Mann’s novella “Tristan” (1902) demonstrates how the reader’s emotional attitude towards death diminishes when juxtaposed to beauty and presented aesthetically, while Aichinger’s “Story in a Mirror” (1954) illustrates how death is accentuated through the presentation of the antithesis. Both stories revolve around death – Aichinger’s is more explicit while Mann’s more implicit. A significant factor in how death played a role in the two stories is based on how the authors set the story as well as the imagery used to convey the finer descriptors....   [tags: death, sanatorium]

Strong Essays
1277 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of Death In Tristan and Story In A Mirror

- Both Thomas Mann’s novella “Tristan” (1902) and Ilse Aichinger’s much more abbreviated “Story in a Mirror” (1952) revolve around the topic of death; moreover, both treat their subjects in an aestheticized manner. However, they do so for the sake of achieving different effects. Mann’s purpose is to demonstrate that – for some characters at least – death can lose its emotional impact when it is juxtaposed with beauty and presented in an aesthetic manner; Aichinger’s, in contrast, accentuates the disturbing nature of death by juxtaposing it with the seemingly beautiful, yet ultimately dark imagery....   [tags: Literary Aesthetics, Contrasting Imagery]

Strong Essays
2024 words (5.8 pages)

Renaissance Love in Tristan and Iseult Essay

- Renaissance Love in Tristan and Iseult The modern concept of love owes a great deal to the Humanist tradition of the Renaissance. The humanists focused on perfection and exaltation of this life as opposed to the afterlife. In Tristan and Iseult the seeds of Renaissance love are present in the Middle Ages. To the modern eye, it is a mystery how the period of the Middle Ages produced the seeds of the diametrically opposite Renaissance. Yet it is necessary to understand this transformation if one is to fully comprehend the forces that helped produce the modern consciousness....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
614 words (1.8 pages)

Movie Review of Tristan and Isolde Essay

- In Medieval times during King Arthur’s reign beholds the legend of Tristan and Isolde, which is retold in this film packed full of daring action and romance. Director, Kevin Reynolds, and writer, Dean Georgaris put the classic legend up on the screen. It is rated PG-13 for the many battle sequences and some brief sexuality, but is still suitable for most audiences. In 125 minutes, you may enjoy many deadly battles and enticing romantic scenes as well. Reynolds did a stupendous job on recreating the love story of the Irish King’s daughter, Isolde, played by Sophia Myles, and Tristan, played by James Franco, who is from an English tribe and the Irish’s enemy....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
576 words (1.6 pages)

Essay about A Comparison of Tristan and Yselt with Theseus and the Minotaur

- A Comparison of Tristan and Yselt with Theseus and the Minotaur In my comparison coursework I will be comparing the play that I performed, this play was Tristan and Yselt. I will be comparing it to the well-known Greek tale of Theseus and the Minotaur. There is one thing these have in common; this is that they are both myths. On is a Cornish legend and the other is a Greek myth, this is why I am comparing them. First I will give a brief description of both of the plays. Tristan and Yselt is a not so well known legend it roots I will go into more detail later....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1138 words (3.3 pages)

tristans Tragedy Essay

- "Tristan's Tragedy" As told to (author's name) By Tristan "What an unusual Christian name, '(author's name)'. And you say you know but two languages. You must jest to render the title of 'scholar' upon yourself. During my training, I have learned seven, all the while being taught horsemanship and swordsmanship. Alas, all of my accolades serve me not here. True nobility never makes excuses for shortcomings; however, in this despair I can know no greater loss. After being wounded in battle with the giant Morolt (who was subsequently slain by my steel) I journeyed to Ireland in search of Queen Isolt and her medicinal power....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
438 words (1.3 pages)