Essay on Methodological Eclecticism in Teaching English as a Foreign Language

Essay on Methodological Eclecticism in Teaching English as a Foreign Language

Length: 4164 words (11.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Methodological Eclecticism in Teaching English as a Foreign Language

"Eclectic", remarks Atkinson (1988, p. 42), "is one of the buzz words in TEFL at present, in part due to the realization that for the foreseeable future good language teaching is likely to continue to be based more on common sense, insights drawn from classroom experience, informed discussion among teachers, etc., than on any monolithic model of second language acquisition or all-embracing theory of learning . . . ". One problem with this position is that your "common sense" and your "insights" are apt to be different from mine. Another is that "discussion among teachers", though valuable, is often a futile exercise in the blind leading the blind. No one with some knowledge of pedagogy and psychology would advocate a "monolithic model" of anything in teaching today. However, unless one has some theoretical foundation to one's knowledge, one cannot construct a methodology of anything--including of foreign language teaching. The aim of this paper is to examine rudimentarily such foundation, and to propose an eclectic approach to teaching English to speakers of other languages.
Learning theories and TEFL
     "It appears counterproductive to dissect language in the same way that biology students might dissect a frog" (Maurice 1987, p. 9). Learners do not expect curriculum designers and teachers to dissect language on the basis of pure linguistic science, but they do expect them to dissect language on the basis of applied linguistics and psycholinguistics to the extent that such analyses throw light on how language is applied and on who will do the applying. The foci, then, are on teaching methodology and learning capacity, rather than on the intricate works of linguisticians. Notes that teachers, moreover, need a functional dose of anthropology, sociology, and cybernetics if they are to grow as professionals. It does not hurt, of course, if they know more than one language and have been in close contact with other cultures.
     Now "discussions on teaching methods tend to be plagued by overgeneralizations both with respect to the way they are classified and with respect to the way they are evaluated" (MacKenzie, Eraut, & Jones 1972, p. 124). When one compares pedagogical methods, some startling facts come to light. One, for example, is that methods vacillate between a behavioral approac...


... middle of paper ...


...New York, N.Y.: Regents Publishing Company, Inc.
     Larsen-Freeman, D. (1986). Techniques and Principles in Language Teaching. Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press.
     MacKenzie, N., Eraut, M., & Jones, H. C. (1972). Teaching and Learning: An Introduction to New Methods and Resources in Higher Education. Paris, France: UNESCO and the International Association of universities.
     Maurice, K. (1987). The communicative approach and EST: Methodological problems and potential. English Teaching Forum, XXV(2), pp. 7-12.
     Phillips, M. K. (1981). Toward a Theory of LSP Methodology. In R. Mackay & J. D. Palmer (Eds.), Language for specific purposes. Rowley, Mass.: Newbury House Publishers.
     Prabhu, N. (1990, Summer). There is no best method--Why? TESOL Quarterly, pp. 175.
     Rogers, C. (1983). Freedom to Learn. London, U.K.: Merrill.
     Savignon, S. J. (1987). What's What in Communicative Language - Teaching. English Teaching Forum, XXV(4), pp. 16-21.
     Taylor, B. P. (1987). Teaching ESL: Incorporating a Communicative Student-Centered Component. In M. Long & J. C. Richards (Eds.), Methodology of TESOL. Rowley, Mass.: Newbury House Publishers, pp. 45-58.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Usefulness of Methods in Language Teaching Essay

- Introduction: Recently a big debate has been aroused on the issue of teaching methods and their usefulness to the actual practice in classroom. Some writers start to claim that methods are dead and are no longer considered in the teaching/learning process such as Brown(2002) . Whereas some others like Bell (2007) think that method still play a vital role in the teaching learning process. This essay will examine both views with relation to my own experience as a teacher and teacher trainer. First I will give a summary of both points of view then will review the usefulness of methods in relation to my profession and context....   [tags: Education, Teaching Methods]

Term Papers
1482 words (4.2 pages)

Teaching English As Second Language Essay

- Teaching English as second language is an incredible act of balancing multiple aspects of language at one time – syntax, morphology, phonology, and much more. L2 teachers must utilize each of these if they are to effectively teach the L2 to students in their classrooms in a way that produces the most improvement across facets such as grammar, pronunciation, and comprehension of the language. SLA research shows that there are multiple, often controversial ways of teaching an L2 – none of which seem to be completely solidified as being the best....   [tags: English language, Language]

Term Papers
1907 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on The Field Of Teaching English Language Learners

- After reading the chapter 2, the most important idea captured my attention is to decide which program is beneficial for LEP students. One of the most important decisions in the field of teaching English Language Learners is which program of instruction to use. These programs range from bilingual education to English only immersion. "According to the Center for Research on Education, Diversity and Excellence(CREDE), such choices should ideally be based on careful consideration of a district 's goals, resources, and the needs and characteristics of its students." (page-50) When thinking about which program will be the best for English Language Learners, it is important to note that a program t...   [tags: English language, Second language]

Term Papers
1047 words (3 pages)

Essay on Teaching English As A Second Language Learner

- Introduction There are many issues teachers and students encounter in educational contexts centering on teaching English to speakers of other languages (TESOL). Many of the major issues addressed here are also relevant to teaching students American Sign Language (ASL), as well as other signed and spoken languages. The goal of this paper is to conduct a review of current research and literature of ELL/EFL/ESL/TESOL/TEFL/ESP/TOEFL/IELTS peer-reviewed publications that address these teaching-learning contexts and the key focus areas of culture diversity, sociolinguistic variation, the use of innovative technologies for language teaching and learning, language assessment, and language modalitie...   [tags: English language, Lingua franca, Second language]

Term Papers
1723 words (4.9 pages)

Teaching English As A Foreign Language Essay examples

- ... An instructor must establish a circular curriculum to cover the same topic several times to give students time to absorb the language. When creating a lesson plan, it is essential that instructors create a unique lesson to appeal to all learning styles such as visual, auditory, oral, and tactile. To keep students engaged, instructors must vary their approach and make lessons relevant to students. Educators set reasonable time limits on activities and topics in their lesson plans to cover material as efficiently as possible....   [tags: Education, Second language]

Term Papers
866 words (2.5 pages)

Language Intuition in English Language Teaching Essay example

- 1. Introduction English language study requires learners mastering several parts including phonology, grammar, vocabulary etc. Among them, grammar studying plays an increasingly vital role in English language learning in secondary school. Generally, the traditional way of teaching involves a teacher-commanding class which teacher spent half class on the certain grammar points and using exercises to evaluate whether students fully master them. However, the old approach usually results in a class s filled with bored and exhausted students who may give wonderful result in tests but failed in communicating events....   [tags: teaching method, efficiency, secondary school]

Term Papers
1219 words (3.5 pages)

The Language Of The English Language Essay

- ... This with the idea of many other complex languages that won’t be able to surpass English as the main language because of those same reasons. In order for someone to learn Mandarin or other complex dialect they need to be born into it, the more people get old the harder it gets for them to transition from their native tongue to Mandarin or vice versa. Some dialects will by approaching extinction for the world in the future because they are forbidden or they have very little use. In many countries, native speakers have been punished for not using the dominant language of the country....   [tags: English language, Dialect, Lingua franca]

Term Papers
1118 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The Language Of The English Language

- ... There have been many opinions about the use of Ebonics as it vaguely different from Standard English. John Baugh argues that Ebonics is not “proper English”. When he was about four years old the eldest sister of his church told him ‘‘you sho’ is a fine young man.’’ To which he replied, ‘‘are. You are a fine young man.’’ (Baugh 4-5) This can only conclude that Ebonics is not an instinctive language to non-African Americans. Standard English has been practiced by many immigrants by the way, yet the African Americans wish not to speak it....   [tags: English language, United States, Dialect]

Term Papers
1130 words (3.2 pages)

Issues in Teaching the English Language Essay

- Struggle as I may, I cannot avoid James Berlin’s statement: “To teach writing is to argue for a version of reality” (234). If I’m going to be successful in any academic field, in any language, there are certain conventions that I must follow, but what I say and how I think is inexorably linked to the available resources of any particular convention. For my part, I just can’t escape the confines of the English language. I see this most poignantly when I try to teach a Chinese writer how to cite sources or when I attempt to read a text in translation....   [tags: English Writing Teacher Student]

Term Papers
2528 words (7.2 pages)

Essay on Principled Eclecticism

- In everyday life related activities; individuals tend to look for the best technique and process to execute and successfully achieve a task. This can be seen as an innate nature of human beings who are skilled with the capability and capacity of thinking and distinguishing things in advance in relation to how a task or a sequence of tasks need to be completed using the most effective and viable way with the obtainable resources. When looking at how a teacher teaches another language, the teacher is usually inclined to pursue an effective and result-oriented method with the assumptions that the methods he or she utilises will ultimately lead to the learners mastery of a language....   [tags: ESL, Teaching Methods]

Term Papers
2462 words (7 pages)