Feminist Refutation of the Deconstruction of The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle

Feminist Refutation of the Deconstruction of The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle

Length: 1582 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Feminist Refutation of the Deconstruction of The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle  


As Captain Jaggery’s ostensibly moral imperative from Avi’s The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle implores, we the readers “protect the natural order of the world” through our disbelief in our heroine as reflected in our intuitive reflection upon and deconstructionalist critique of the book.    In fact, it is likely that our disbelief of Charlotte’s story is as much a comment on our attitudes towards gender roles as it is an educated and thoughtful response to its clues.  Even as we find ourselves believing along with the story, we, upon reflection, find valid ways to destroy that believability, in no small part because we define what she does as either “female” (believable) and “male” (not believable).

The preceding was provided so that the student could gain an understanding of the paper. The complete paper begins below:

So what we have here is a girl who admits she owns the weapon that murdered Mr. Hollybrass.  A girl who lied about where she got it.  A girl who was taught to use a blade, and learned to use it, as Mr. Grimes would have it, ‘uncommon’ well.  A girl who, all agree, is unnatural in every way she acts.  Gentlemen, do we not, as natural men, need to take heed?  Is it not our duty, our obligation, to protect the natural order of the world? (Avi, 178)

As Captain Jaggery’s ostensibly moral imperative from Avi’s The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle implores, we the readers “protect the natural order of the world” through our disbelief in our heroine as reflected in our intuitive reflection upon and deconstructionalist critique of the book.    In fact, it is likely that our disbelief of Charlotte’s story is a...


... middle of paper ...


...ive to males.  This in itself indicates a gender expectation on the part of the reader, one that predisposes the reader to disbelieve and should lead us all to re-examine our motivations in deconstructing the text.   Moreover, females and males alike colored Charlotte’s adaptation to her circumstances with a movement from a female role to a male role as if gender roles were intractable and binding from both the male and female points of view -- she wouldn’t be able to do it, despite the fact that quite possibly her own survival dictated she probably could have not done otherwise!  Once again, logic dictates that we at least acknowledge that our inability to accept Charlotte’s account could be more of a reflection of our gender expectations than her twisting of the truth.

 
Works Cited:

Avi. The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle. New York: Avon Books.1990.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

True Shakespeare or Not True shakespeare Essay

- Many historians and famous authors, such as Mark Twain and Sigmund Freud, have trouble believing that William Shakespeare truly wrote the plays published in his name. As TIME writer Jumanna Farousky wrote, “Doubters started questioning the true identity of the writer in the late 19th century. Ever since then, the theory of an alternate author has flirted with the mainstream as some scholars and researchers have tried to get the broader academic community to treat the question as a legitimate debate”....   [tags: Sir Francis Bacon was the true creator]

Powerful Essays
1450 words (4.1 pages)

Literary Analysis : ' The Yellow Wallpaper, By Arthur Conan Doyle

- In his Enigmas of Identity, Peter Brooks describes the “transactional nature of the self,” where individual identity is created through its relationship with others (Brooks 23). Identity is forged through “transpersonal networks”, moving beyond the individual or the personal (23). Identity is not static, but a continuous “project,” asking in what ways one stays the same, changes and grows (15). In Arthur Conan Doyle’ “A Scandal in Bohemia,” Wilkie Collins’ The Woman in White, and Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s “The Yellow Wallpaper,” identity and its transactional, malleable nature play a significant role....   [tags: Sherlock Holmes, Arthur Conan Doyle]

Powerful Essays
1281 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on The Is A Woman By Charlotte Perkins Gilman

- As Virginia Wolfe once stated, “For most of history, Anonymous was a woman” ( ). The word female has had countless meanings throughout its lifespan. Females can be seen as lowly and cheap, regal and sophisticated, or weak and underutilized. It has only been in the last 70 years that women have gained a foothold in society, to gain the rights they deserve. In the late 1800’s a new writer Charlotte Perkins Gilman questioned society’s views on the idea of being female and tried to make them understand that females are a force to be reckoned with and not a doormat for men to step on....   [tags: Charlotte Perkins Gilman, Woman]

Powerful Essays
1345 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Jane Eyre, by Charlotte Bronte

- Throughout history the idea of the hero or heroine has changed, but some common attributes remain. The hero claims Bill Butler: “is an archetypal figure, a paradigm who bears the possibilities of life, courage, love – the indefinable’s which themselves define our human lives” . In his seminal work The Hero with a Thousand Faces, Joseph Campbell states that the hero: “a personage of exceptional gifts” is “the man or woman who has been able to battle past his personal and local historical limitations to the generally valid, normally human forms” ....   [tags: Jane Eyre, Charlotte Bronte]

Powerful Essays
1749 words (5 pages)

Jane Eyre, by Charlotte Bronte Essay

- Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte not only traces Jane's development as an independent individual, but it can also be read as a description of her personal journey in finding a family through the five settings in the novel. From beginning to end Jane engages with an array of nurturing, maternal women whom model a family for her, but also encounters those who torment her and bring her great suffering. In reading this novel, we’re not only able to trace Jane’s development as an individual, but can also see the book as her journey in search for family, for a sense of belonging, and for a home....   [tags: Charlotte Bronte, Character Development]

Powerful Essays
1107 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The Hound Of The Baskervilles By Arthur Conan Doyle

- The aim of this article is to explore the tensions of English masculine identity in The Hound of the Baskervilles by Arthur Conan Doyle in which men often feel entrapped by emotional, social and psychological roles imposed upon them during times of economic depression, imperialism and foreign competition. In nineteenth-century England, masculinity embraced a variety of components, including race, class, and gender. The concept of “manliness,” essential to the Victorians, underwent some changes: “To the early Victorian it represented a concern with a successful transition from Christian immaturity to maturity, demonstrated by earnestness, selflessness and integrity; to the late Victorian it s...   [tags: Sherlock Holmes, Arthur Conan Doyle]

Powerful Essays
1025 words (2.9 pages)

The Yellow Wallpaper By Charlotte Gilman

- In The Yellow Wallpaper Charlotte Perkins Gilman uses setting as the basis for the resolution and actions of the narrator and main character. The Yellow Wallpaper is a short story of a sick woman, with details of the building, weather, smell, and objects in the story allowing for an effective vision of the story. Along with Charlotte Gilman’s advanced diction setting is used as an effective expression of the intended atmosphere. The expansion of setting can be seen in details about mansion the family moves to and the environment surrounding them....   [tags: Charlotte Perkins Gilman, The Yellow Wallpaper]

Powerful Essays
933 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Charlotte Barr and the Color of God

- Charlotte Barr and the Color of God In many of her poems, the contemporary poet Charlotte Barr provides insight into the relationship between God and man. "A Complaint to Her Lord in Her Loneliness," "Black and White," and "Color" all use the colors black, white, and red to explore the relationship between their speakers and God. The poems' speakers see these colors as indicators of their love for God. Through each of the poems, the use of color allows each speaker to come to a better understanding of her relationship with God....   [tags: Charlotte Barr Essays]

Powerful Essays
705 words (2 pages)

Reflections on Nagarjuna’s The Refutation of Criticism (Vigrahavyavartani)

- Reflections on Nagarjuna’s The Refutation of Criticism (Vigrahavyavartani) ABSTRACT: In verse nine of the Vigrahavyavartani, Nagarjuna gives a defense of his skepticism by insisting that he makes no proposition (pratijna) concerning the nature of reality. B. K. Matilal has argued that this position is not an untenable one for a skeptic to hold, using as an explanatory model Searle’s distinction between a propositional and an illocutionary negation. The argument runs that Nagarjuna does not refute rival philosophical positions by simply refuting whatever positive claims those positions might make, but rather he refuses the very act of making an assertion....   [tags: Nagarjuna Essays]

Free Essays
3795 words (10.8 pages)

Essay about Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre

- Charlotte Bronte's, Jane Eyre, a story of an unfortunate you who's morals and self-respect continue to fluctuate as she matures. Jane Eyre begins her life in the wrong place at the wrong time. During the novel, Jane endures love, hate and friendship, though maturity allows her to forgive. Settings surrounding Jane's life alter her own ideas of self-acceptance, her actions taken to release herself from certain settings have effect on her. In the first few chapters, Bronte establishes Jane's character as a young girl who is the object of hatred from her cousins and aunt....   [tags: Charlotte Bronte Jane Eyre]

Powerful Essays
1771 words (5.1 pages)