Essay on Psychoanalytical Analysis of Flowering Judas

Essay on Psychoanalytical Analysis of Flowering Judas

Length: 1243 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Psychoanalytical Analysis of Flowering Judas  


The two main characters of Katherine Anne Porter's "Flowering Judas," Laura and Braggioni, attempt to fulfill an ideal: they want to have self-fulfillment but also to be integrated into a social society. Neither of the two, however, succeeds in meeting this ideal. While Braggioni appears to be a man who is self-fulfilled, he is not completely accepted or integrated into society. Laura, on the other hand, is Braggioni's opposite. Although she is completely embraced by the society in which she lives, she personally feels alienated from it and unfulfilled as an individual. In their incomplete and dysfunctional personalities, Braggioni and Laura are seen as embodiments of two psychic forces: the id and the superigo.

Braggioni, as the embodiment of the id, is concerned primarily with pleasure. Even just a physical description shows his extravagant self-indulgence. His "expensive garments" consist of a "lavender collar," a "purple necktie, held by a diamond hoop," a leather belt "worked in silver, [. . .] glassy yellow shoes [. . . and] mauve silk hose" (374). Braggioni's extravagant clothing projects how he "loves himself with such tenderness and amplitude and eternal charity" (372). Material possessions both confirm and enhance Braggioni's self-fulfillment and self-worth. Being a vain man, he demands the best for himself; gratifying himself gives him pleasure.

Braggioni's "love of small luxuries" is not the only source of his pleasure (374). He also takes pleasure in being a controlling force. He tells Laura that he "is rich, not in money [. . .] but in power" (374). Men come to him when they are in trouble, and Braggioni takes pleasure in deciding if he will help them or...


... middle of paper ...


...As a result, Laura is consuming herself. In her superego-dominated psyche even her suppressed desire for emotional pleasure and self-fulfillment can only find expression as a form of self-destruction.

This image in her dream of self-destruction causes Laura to cry "No!" once again. She will not allow herself to fall victim to self-fulfillment, just as Braggioni will not give up his pleasure. Consequently, they both remain characters who are imbalanced in their motivations and drives, thus making them dysfunctional. Until they can negotiate a compromise and partnership of the pleasure principle and the morality principle, Laura and Braggioni will fail to be healthy, fulfilled human beings.

Works Cited

Porter, Katherine Anne.  "Flowering Judas."   1930.  Short Story Masterpieces.  Ed. Robert Penn Warren and Albert Erskine.  New York: Dell, 1958.  371-85.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Theme Betrayal on “Flowering Judas”

- Judas Iscariot, the disciple, hanged himself from a tree after betraying Jesus Christ and giving him a kiss. The tree in which Judas hanged himself is known as “Judas Tree,” mainly found in Southern Europe and Western Asia. In the short story “Flowering Judas” written by Katherine Anne Porter the title is related to this religious event of betrayal, murder, and denial. The two main characters in this short story are Braggioni and Laura. Braggioni is a cruel, powerful leader of Marxist revolutionaries in and around Mexico City....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Strong Essays
1566 words (4.5 pages)

Theme Betrayal for Flowering Judas Essay example

- Judas Iscariot, the disciple, hanged himself from a tree after betraying Jesus Christ and giving him a kiss. The tree in which Judas hanged himself is known as “Judas Tree” mainly found in Southern Europe and Western Asia. In the short story “Flowering Judas” written by Katherine Anne Porter the title is related to this religious event of betrayal, murder, and denial. “‘Flowering Judas’ is possibly her most remarkable story of tension, sustained, threatened, and reestablished” (Gottfried 134). The two main characters in this short story are Braggioni and Laura....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Katherine Anne Porter ]

Strong Essays
1459 words (4.2 pages)

Flowering Judas Essay

- Judas Iscariot, the disciple, hanged himself from a tree after betraying Jesus Christ and giving him a kiss. The tree in which Judas hanged himself is known as “Judas Tree” mainly found in Southern Europe and Western Asia. In the short story “Flowering Judas” written by Katherine Anne Porter the title is related to this religious event of betrayal, murder, and denial. The two main characters in this short story are Braggioni and Laura. Braggoni is a cruel, powerful leader of Marxist revolutionaries in and around Mexico City....   [tags: Analysis, Katherine Anne Porter]

Strong Essays
1359 words (3.9 pages)

Flowering Judas by Katherine Anne Porter Essay

- This essay focuses on the theme of love, faith and mainly betrayal. It also aims to analyse the symbolism of the short story "Flowering Judas" written by an American fiction writer Katherine Anne Porter. The story is told in a third-person point of view describing Laura´s internal conflict, the difficulty to stay faithful to her moral as well as political beliefs. The scene is set in Mexico City after the Obregon Revolution. The main protagonist, a young American teacher, comes to the town not only to educate Indian children, but also in support of the revolution, as a helper of the movement members and of the local leader Braggioni who would like to seduce her through singing songs....   [tags: love, faith, betrayal, symbolism in short story]

Strong Essays
550 words (1.6 pages)

An Analysis of Wright’s Poem Saint Judas Essay

- An Analysis of Wright’s Poem Saint Judas       Upon reading the poem "Saint Judas" by James Wright, the reader quickly realizes that the poem deals with Judas Iscariot, one of Jesus' twelve apostles.  The author describes Judas as "going out to kill himself,"(line 1) when he sees a man being beaten by "a pack of hoodlums"(2).  Judas quickly runs to help the man, forgetting "how [his] day began"(4).  He leaves his rope behind and, ignoring the soldiers around him, runs to help.  Finally, he remembers the circumstances that surround his suicidal intentions and realizes that he is "banished from heaven"(9) and "without hope"(13)  He runs to the man anyway and holds him "for nothing in [his]...   [tags: Saint Judas]

Strong Essays
740 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Meeting Judas Iscariot

- I awoke in the forest. It was evening, the sun had long set. The smell of the woods surrounded me, almost suffocating me with the musk. I gazed before me as I stood, no lights, no way to see the path. I was lost, the thick trees blocking any light that might guide me. I began to walk slowly, watching each step carefully. The silence pressed against my ears, it was deafening. My eyes began to adjust to the pressing darkness with each step, and I noticed I was in a large clearing. Fear gripped me, how I gotten here or, why, I did not know....   [tags: Judas Iscariot]

Strong Essays
1596 words (4.6 pages)

Review Of ' An Historian 's View Of The ' Gospel Of Judas ' Essay

- Eun Jin Koh Paul Tchir MMW 12, Section C11 Writing Assignment 1 27 January 2015 Christianity and Gnosticism Early Christianity was threat to Roman Empire (Bentley and Ziegler 228). The unique characteristics, such as all human beings are equal, or concept of heaven attracted numbers of poor people in Rome (Bentley and Ziegler 228). Due to the massive popularity, Roman Empire was fearful of losing control and persecuted Christianity (Bentley and Ziegler 229). David Frankfurter’s article, “An Historian’s View of the ‘Gospel of Judas’,” gives an emphasis the various accounts of Jesus’ relationship with individual disciples (Frankfurter 174)....   [tags: Jesus, New Testament, Judas Iscariot]

Strong Essays
1469 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on The Tragic Story of Judas Iscariot

- The Tragic Story of Judas Iscariot Judas Iscariot. A man who usually strikes fear into the hearts of Christians and Jews alike. But who is this praised man of Kerioth, really. He betrayed our LORD for 30 silver shekels. Yet, there HAS to be SOME good in him, or else, why on earth would Jesus pick him. I'll inform you on Judas' possible motives, thoughts that may have been running through his head before and after the fact, his culpability, and the status of his soul. Most people believe Judas' only motive for betraying Jesus to the Sanhedrin was greed....   [tags: Judas Christ Christianity Bible]

Strong Essays
977 words (2.8 pages)

Psychoanalytical Criticism Essay

- Psychoanalytical criticism is a form of literary critique, which uses some of the techniques of psychoanalysis in the interpretation of literature. Lacanian critics examine psychoanalytic phases such as the Symbolic and apply this phase while interpreting literary texts. Lacanian critics also associate the literary work’s content to broader Lacanian concepts, such as the Phallic and the Other. The focus of this essay is to apply these psychoanalytical techniques while interpreting Lady Macbeth’s character in William Shakespeare’s play Macbeth....   [tags: Psychology, Freud, Lacan]

Strong Essays
2761 words (7.9 pages)

Essay about Judas

- Ever since you told me what your YL leader said, I have been studying it. Once I got into the word, I realized that I had dealt with this topic before, when our leader was “testing” our response to “questions of contradiction.” This is what I have concluded. First of all, notice that the text does not say that Judas died as a result of hanging. All it says is that he "went and hanged himself." Luke however, in Acts, tells us that "and falling headlong, he burst open in the middle and all his entrails gushed out." This is a pretty clear indication (along with the other details given in Acts - Peter's speech, the need to pick a new apostle, etc.) that at least after Judas'...   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
995 words (2.8 pages)