Confusion in Landscape for a Good Woman Essay

Confusion in Landscape for a Good Woman Essay

Length: 689 words (2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Confusion in Landscape for a Good Woman


I found Landscape for a Good Woman to be a confusing landscape, one whose contours are difficult to follow. I don't mean to imply that I did not find the book fascinating, but it was so rich and the stories and scholarly discussions were so intertwined that it was difficult to keep track of what Steedman was trying to convey. Why did she choose to write in this way? Instead of giving us a straight narrative about her childhood and allowing us to make our own inferences, I feel as if she's told a story and, at the same time, she's told us how to interpret that story and has given us a critique of her own and others' interpretations of her story.

Steedman does begin the section titled "Stories" by saying that "this book. . . is about interpretations." Of course, all stories, fiction or non-fiction, are interpretations of events and characters, told from the perspective of the author. I don't find the interpretations themselves to be problematic; maybe what I find confusing is that Steedman gives us interpretations from so many different...

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Free Essays - Alienation in Landscape for a Good Woman

- Alienation in Landscape for a Good Woman In her introduction to Landscape for a Good Woman, Carolyn Steedman claims that "this is a drama of class" (22); she blames her mother's working-class background -- where "fierce resentment against the unfairness of things, was carried through seventy years and three generations ... [and] dissolved into the figure of [her] mother" (30) -- for her own joyless childhood. The shocking portrait of Steedman's mother, who tells her children repeatedly both in her actions and words how unwanted they are, redefines the culturally normative nurturing role of motherhood....   [tags: Landscape for a Good Woman Essays]

Free Essays
448 words (1.3 pages)

Free Essays - Bitter Reality in Landscape for a Good Woman

- Bitter Reality in Landscape for a Good Woman "For my mother, the time of my childhood was the place where the fairly tales failed." (47) The loss of dreams for Edna has resulted in a loss of dreams and fantasy world for her children. The focus on the little mermaid is appropriate. Just as Edna makes the two girls into the tragic figure of the little mermaid by blaming their father for leaving/not leaving them, Edna continually makes her children into either the tragic figures or the villain by blaming them for her shattered dreams....   [tags: Landscape for a Good Woman Essays]

Free Essays
577 words (1.6 pages)

Free Essays - Memories and Motherhood in Landscape for a Good Woman

- Memories and Motherhood in Landscape for a Good Woman The relevance and subsequent interpretation of memories as they relate to one's desire to mother ". . . refusal to reproduce oneself is a refusal to perpetuate what one is, that is, the way one understands oneself to be in the social world." -- pg. 84 In reading Carolyn Kay Steedman's Landscape for a Good Woman, two themes took center stage: Memories and Motherhood. As the book unfolds Steedman repeatedly points out that childhood memories are used by individuals for various purposes; rather than objective recollections dominated by facts, she proposes that they are more subjective in nature, likely to alter with time or a...   [tags: Landscape for a Good Woman Essays]

Free Essays
512 words (1.5 pages)

Relationship between Good and Evil Essay

- "They (Indians) are not to blame, they have not a dog's chance--we should be like them if we settled here" (184) - Mr. McBryde, A Passage to India, 1912 During the early 1900s, the British people had been living among the Indian culture for an extended period of time. Several discrepancies had been established between these two groups due to stereotypes, prejudices, and ignorance. E.M. Forster implied his deepest aspirations for accord to ameliorate this quandary in his erudite novel, A Passage to India, written in 1912....   [tags: European Literature]

Better Essays
742 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about The Good Woman of Setzuan

- "As Shen Te stretches out her arms to them in desperation they disappear above, smiling and waving." (Pg. 106 "The Good Woman of Setzuan") The ending of "The Good Woman of Setzuan" leaves the readers a sensation that Shen Te was abandoned by the Gods eternally. Instead of the Gods leaving at the end of the play, they ought to stay in town for fairly longer just to assist Shen Te to resolve all the problems among her and her neighbors. It is reasonable that the Gods must teach the neighbors a lesson for using Shen Te....   [tags: The Good Woman of Setzuan]

Free Essays
289 words (0.8 pages)

Semiotics of the Landscape Essay

- The secrets that are held within our hearts always find a way to express themselves. This is true of every individual. Our secret desires and experiences show themselves little by little through our dreams, our personalities, and even through our hobbies. This is a partial description of Sigmund Freud's theory of the unconscious mind. What secrets are being expressed in Margaret Atwood's short story which is called Death by Landscape. How are these secrets manifesting themselves through the story....   [tags: Death By Landscape, Margaret Atwoon, Freud]

Better Essays
1021 words (2.9 pages)

Essay Gertrude Jekyll: An Influence Landscape Architect

- Introduction Gertrude Jekyll,a famous British landscape gardener and craftswoman that dote about thousand of articles.Jekyll is well-known for the wonderful gardens in the nineteenth century(Wallinger,2012).At that time she became one of the premier landscapers of her day.Her work are still preserved well in different cities in Britain and other countries. This essay will mainly analysis about her design works,her illustration life and her design skills from her inspirations.There are different opinions about her garden design are linked with different theories.Jekyll may be seen as playing a vital role in garden design and landscape architecture.Now she is recognized as the most influent...   [tags: British lanscape gardner and craftswoman]

Better Essays
1775 words (5.1 pages)

The Good Woman Of Setzuan Essay

- The Good woman of Setzuan is a play written by Bertolt Brecht which brings in sympathetic feeling to the audience and the readers of play by using low economic warm hearted woman Shan Te, who is treated differently because of her status in the society. In Shen Te’s society, a woman is a considered second class because of her gender and economic status and men are considered best option for her survival. For instance, a policeman admits that the only way Shen Te could get out of poverty is to get man....   [tags: Gender, Woman, Social status, Gender role]

Better Essays
1304 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about Confusion, Confusion And Heartache

- Confusion, that’s what I felt the most, confusion and heartache. I couldn’t believe that he was gone, that a lifelong friend, someone who I had grown up with, someone who I’d shared countless secrets with was just gone from this world. It was a typical February morning, my friends and I were spending every available minute out in the hallway catching up with each other until we had to go to history class. As we began to slowly make our way towards Mr. Karasek’s room, we saw one of our classmates run out of the school, that’s when we started to hear the rumors....   [tags: Tears, Crying, Aerosmith, Laughter]

Better Essays
1317 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Concusion

- Concusion " Ding , Ding, Ding." School had just ended. My butt had been just freed from the oppression of that chair for the rest of my life. Never again was I planning to sit down in Mr. Dicksons room again. But that was the least of my concerns. Because, today I couldn't wait to get riding on the Bike trails. These were old paths of a railroad track that had jumps built on them. By the time I got out to the bikeracks and met my friends, we were exhilerated. "To the bike trails?" I asked....   [tags: Personal Narrative Essays]

Free Essays
973 words (2.8 pages)