Compensating the affairs of economic efficiency with the demands of sociopolitical rights is a constant source of tension in Canada and the United States alike. In no other element is this tension more apparent than in the group of complex markets we call the health care system.
Canadians have been fortunate enough to receive a universal health care system for nearly forty years. This is a single-payer system funded by the governments, both provincial and federal, but at what costs? Is health care not unlike any other commodity, or is it the privilege of every citizen? Health care has elements of common economic behavior, however, there are also certain social values associated with it. It is this struggle of defining what health care is that causes such anxiety among economists. The Canadian health care system is slowly crippling the economy, and reforms must be devised to preserve the pride of Canada; our health care system itself.
The pluralistic health care scheme of the United States, as well, has serious socioeconomic implications, and American policy makers are looking toward the model of the Canadian system for answers. Both the United States and Canada must reform health care policy, but to what extent? Obviously these questions cannot necessarily yield clear, concise answers, however they will provide insight into analyzing the current and proposed systems of health care.
Certainly if Canada is to maintain a high standard of care it must adopt an economically efficient, revenue generating system. Moreover the United States must adopt the single-payer system of Canada while still retaining a strong revenue base. This paper will discuss the strengths and shortcomings of the Canadian health care system, and how health care is a sociopolitical enigma. Furthermore, how the single-payer system is the only realistic response to the growing inadequacies within the American socioeconomic status.
CANADIAN HEALTH CARE STRUCTURE
Serving as a general background in its appraisal, it is necessary to outline the history and the ambient factors of the Canada health care that is so sought after by the United States. The Canadian health-insurance program, called Medicare, is administered by provincial ...
... middle of paper ...
... and this tension is prevalent in the health care system. A basic economic concern is whether health care is like any other commodity. The health care industry can be analyzed with economic frames of reference: wealth, risk aversion, efficient transfers, and utility. However, there are certain symbolic elements of health care that cannot be easily measured. Cultures have fundamental beliefs that encompass the valuation of life and health. Bearing this in mind, it would only seem realistic that there is some sort of right to health care. Nowhere in the American Constitution is it stated that an individual has the right to some basic set of health care services, however, there are certain undefined responsibilities the government has. It can be argued that the Declaration of Independence supports the right for each and every citizen to have the basic care needed to sustain life so as to exercise one’s liberty and to allow the pursuit of happiness. It has been argued that there is a common-law right to equal services, a right of equal access to basic services: such as drinking water. Furthermore this right extends to all citizens and is beyond the reac
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Health is intrinsically linked to gains created in schooling for to attend school and be able to learn in an effective manner. Thus, Bolsa Alimentação (BA) (food grant), gives mothers R$25 (US $15) which is conditional on regular attendance to healthcare clinics (Hall: 2008). The grant is intended to be reinvested in food and family needs, aiding families in reducing child and infant mortality (need a more in depth survey here). Assessing data on health outcomes is integral to understand the improvements made, and limits of the programme.... [tags: Health, Public health, Poverty, Nutrition]
947 words (2.7 pages)
- The North Shore-LIJ Health System strives to improve the health of the communities it serves and is committed to providing the highest quality clinical care; educating the current and future generations of health care professionals; searching for new advances in medicine through the conduct of bio-medical research; promoting health education; and caring for the entire community regardless of the ability to pay (North Shore LIJ health care, 2014). In 2007, as part of their commitment to quality clinical care, North Shore LIJ began implementing health information technology and electronic medical records in the hospital system.... [tags: Health care, Medicine, Health care provider]
1246 words (3.6 pages)
- A Health Information System, (HIS), is defined as a “set of components and procedures organized with the objective of generating information which will improve” financial and clinical management for hospitals and medical practices. (Lippeveld, Sauerborn, and Bodart 2000). The HIS is crucial to the development of hospital and medical practices for the purposes of strategic planning, problem-solving, decision support, and executive information systems with which health service managers and clinicians are deeply involved.... [tags: Health Information Systems]
693 words (2 pages)
- ... A project manager is a professional in the field of project management. Project directors are good with planning and executing so they would easily be able to induce chance because they work in team formation. Weakness is not everyone is a team player and some plans cannot go along as planned. 3. What is the implication of focusing on a target population for community health centers then organized along the 1970s model. What are the implications of that change for the existing systems. Mental health policymakers overlooked the difficulty of finding resources to meet the needs of a marginalized group of people living in scattered sites in the community.... [tags: policy, stakeholders, resources]
846 words (2.4 pages)
- The theorist Avedis Donabedian proposed a theory of quality health care and a process for evaluating it. Although, Donabedian’s theory still dominates outcomes research, other theories of outcomes have since been developed (Grove, Gray & Burns 2015). Donabedian represented the key concepts and relationships in his theory using a cube, with the elements explaining the quality of health care. The three dimensions of the cube health, care received, and the care providers. The cube also incorporates the three aspects of health—physical-psychological function, psychological function, and social function.... [tags: Health care, Patient, Health care provider]
929 words (2.7 pages)
- Introduction This appraisal is going to examine a health promotion topic (do you need to examine one rather than just identify?)and further more evaluate a website that has been used to promote the chosen topic. The topic that has been identified is “Healthy Eating”. This was selected as it as been shown to attribute to an increased risk of Type 2 diabetes, heart disease, high blood pressure, some cancers (especially breast, colon and kidney cancers). Likewise, osteoarthritis, back problems, respiratory and sleep disorders, and even infertility.... [tags: Diseases, Healthy Eating]
2038 words (5.8 pages)
- Encouraging results in improving the quality of patient care, reducing hospitalization and ED visits were presented in some PCMH pilot projects mainly from integrated delivery systems and multi-payer sponsored PCMH initiatives (Friedberg, Lai, Hussey, & Schneider, 2009; Gilfillan et al., 2010; Grumbach & Grundy, 2010; Reid et al., 2010; M. Takach, 2011). Results have been promising in Medicaid as well. Medicaid provides insurance to underserved, minority, and low-income patients, a population most susceptible to fragmented and uncoordinated care.... [tags: Health care, Medicine, Health insurance]
1111 words (3.2 pages)
- Public health is a priority around the world, and health care systems were created to help take care of the public. The United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom are industrialized countries that have different health care systems and approach public health differently. It is important to compare global health care systems to discover best practices, attempt to lower costs, and improve outcomes. Predicting future trends in public health is difficult, but to improve health care and one can look to the past to improve the future.... [tags: Universal health care, Health economics]
1175 words (3.4 pages)
- Without information systems such as immune registries, we lack sufficient data systems to evaluate how well we are getting along in an improved framework regarding access, quality, and results. Notwithstanding the populace base, public health data systems can give imperative data, including ecological impacts on health or pathology patterns and flare-ups. They can give data about geographic territories that are underserved or that have amassing of unfavorable health markers. By giving exact data around a whole populace these frameworks additionally permit evaluation of incongruities of health status in diverse populace subgroups as indicated by age, sex, race or ethnicity, and different com... [tags: Vaccination, Immune system, Public health]
1225 words (3.5 pages)
- Systems of Health Care for OEF/OIF Veterans DoD The DoD’s health care system offers an array of services to active-duty military and their family members, along with veteran’s who meet a criterion in order to qualify and their families, along with some reserve-component members and their families. Active duty members receive health care services from DoD in military treatment facilities/clinics. These services are provided to veterans and their family members through contracts with civilian network providers.... [tags: Health care, Health insurance, Health economics]
1056 words (3 pages)