Guilt and Shame in Some Thoughts Concerning Education and Robinson Crusoe

Guilt and Shame in Some Thoughts Concerning Education and Robinson Crusoe

Length: 2255 words (6.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Guilt and Shame in Some Thoughts Concerning Education and Robinson Crusoe        

    In Seventeenth and Eighteenth Century England, a major transition was occurring; attitudes were shifting towards a more sensibility-based perspective, in which the "warrior" mentality of earlier times was falling out of fashion, in favor of sensitive "gentlemen." Such gentlemen were expected to be morally sound, well-educated, "enlightened." Yet, despite all this, men were still expected to be masculine to be able to take control of a situation or solve a particular problem. John Locke postulated that all of this could be encouraged in young men via their education. Sadly, he found that no educational program at the time was up to the task. He argued that one of the foremost goals of education should be responsible self-government, or the ability to determine properly what to do and what not to do without an external authority commanding it. This ideal became very en vogue among sensible folk at this time many Englishmen (as well as other Europeans) wanted to be so morally upright that they need only answer to themselves. Locke, of course, had some thoughts on this, and those thoughts revolved chiefly around (of all things) shame.

Some Thoughts Concerning Education was first published by Locke in 1693. The ideas it advocated were progressive, even by today's standards. One point he makes very clear is that physical rewards and punishments (as a system of encouraging morally-correct behavior) are ineffective in raising children to be responsible, moral adults (38 - 39). As an alternative, he suggested the following:

Esteem and disgrace are, of all others, the most powerful incentives to the mind, when once it is brought to relish ...

... middle of paper ...

...other is standing nearby with a scornful eye, but true self-governance is about much more than that. Locke knew this to be true, and I think it's obvious that Defoe agreed emphatically enough to base one of the most successful novels in history on very similar views.


Works Cited

Bredvold, Louis I. The Natural History of Sensibility. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1962

Defoe, Daniel. Robinson Crusoe. New York: Bantam Books, 1991 ("Defoe")

Defoe, Daniel. Robinson Crusoe, Norton Critical Edition. New York: W. W. Norton and Company, Inc., 1975 ("Norton")

Locke, John. Some Thoughts Concerning Education, The Works of John Locke, vol. 9. London: 1823

Moore, C. Backgrounds of English Literature 1700-1760. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1953

Yolton, John W. John Locke and Education. New York: Random House, Inc., 1971


Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Correlation Between Shame Vs. Guilt, And The Self Conscious Emotions Of Guilt And Shame

- In the empirical article Bound to Feel Bad About Oneself: Relations Between Attachment and the Self-conscious Emotions of Guilt and Shame in Children and Adolescents by Peter Muris, Cor Meesters et. al. (2014) discusses the correlation between shame vs. guilt and the affects it has on children and adolescents. Some of the affected areas that were present in the study are defensive and avoidance behavior, psychopathological behaviors including: anger and aggression, depression, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), anxiety disorders, eating problems, personality pathology, suicidal and self-injurious thoughts, and substance abuse....   [tags: Attachment theory, Attachment in adults]

Term Papers
1580 words (4.5 pages)

Arthur Dimmesdale and John Proctor's Guilt and Sin Essay

- Arthur Dimmesdale and John Proctor's Guilt and Sin Guilt is something that weighs heavily on the human soul. It incorporates itself in our dreams, our thoughts, and our actions. Everywhere we turn, it stares us blankly in the face. While it is unbearable to suffer, guilt is an emotion that reaffirms our humanity. Repentance of a particular guilt, being spiritual, physical or both, is evidence that we are beyond the baseness of our animal tendencies. This fact has not gone unnoticed to the many great figures of literature....   [tags: The Crucible Adultery Martyrs Guilt Essays]

Term Papers
1292 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about Breaking the Habit of Self-Harm

- Eighty nine percent of people in the world are self-injurers. Seventy nine percent of these people are under eighteen, ten percent are young adults, and sixty seven percent are females aged eighteen and under. (“Facts and Statistics.”) A person who self-harms is likely to have gone through difficult or painful experiences as a child, or as a young adult. They probably felt as if they had no one to confide in, so they didn’t receive the support and the emotional outlet that they needed. Most cases are related to past negligence, separation, bullying, harassment, being abused, isolated, or even being sent to a hospital or another institution where they did not feel comfortable....   [tags: Swear Jar, Suicidal Thoughts]

Term Papers
1312 words (3.7 pages)

The And Universal Observation Of The Scarlet Letter Essay

- The object of severe and universal observation, the wearer of the scarlet letter was at length relieved by discerning (1) a figure which took possession of her thoughts. By an Indian 's side stood a white man. He was small in stature, but with remarkable intelligence in his features. Although he had endeavoured (2) to conceal the peculiarity, it was evident to Hester that one of his shoulders rose higher than the other. At the first instant of perceiving that visage, she pressed her infant to her bosom, with such force the poor babe uttered another cry of pain....   [tags: The Scarlet Letter, Hester Prynne, Shame]

Term Papers
1491 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on The Death Of Suicide Victims

- In 2014, there were 42,773 deaths by suicide in the United States, making suicide the 10th leading cause of death according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Grief and pain come with any death natural or otherwise. There are always things to clean up after someone dies, but there are many nuisances unique to dealing with the loss of someone to suicide. Suicide survivors often face unique challenges that differ from those who have been bereaved by other types of death. In addition to the inevitable grief, sadness, and disbelief typical of all grief, overwhelming guilt, confusion, rejection, shame, and anger are also often prominent....   [tags: Suicide, Mental disorder, Death, Shame]

Term Papers
1299 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on Revenage in William Shakespeare´s Hamlet

- Throughout the play Hamlet by William Shakespeare, themes make up very important ingredients for the entire play. The most prominent and important theme is Revenge. Some Shakespeare critics may argue that guilt is the most important theme. However revenge is the most important theme and the reader sees this through revenge advancing the plot, the idea of seeking vengeance allows the reader to learn more about characters, foreshadowing of characters deaths and in the end seeking vengeance causes the majority of main characters deaths.   Some Shakespeare critics may argue that guilt is the most important theme in the play Hamlet....   [tags: guilt, vengeance, foreshadowing, characters]

Term Papers
854 words (2.4 pages)

Sex Offender Specific Treatment And Mr. Webber Essay

- This provider began seeing Mr. Webber on 9/9/2015 for sex offender specific treatment and Mr. Webber’s progress, at the time of this report, is considered satisfactory. Mr. Webber states that he currently resides with his grandparents, Linda and Peter Hrebeniuk, at 12323 39th Ave SE Everett, WA 98208. Mr. Webber states that he has his own room and he has no complaints about his living arrangements at this time. It should be noted that this provider was not aware that the Superior Court of Washington State in Snohomish County required monthly reports until 10/20/2015....   [tags: Human sexual behavior, Sex offender, Shame]

Term Papers
1107 words (3.2 pages)

Shakespeare's Novel Macbeth Essay

- What would the world be like if no one felt guilt. If no one ever caught caught for their crimes. In Shakespeare's novel, Macbeth, the main characters commit crimes driven by their ambition. After committing the first crime Macbeth, the main antagonist is overwhelmed with guilt. His wife, Lady Macbeth plotted the first crime and was the main force pushing Macbeth to kill. In the end Macbeth is charged with the truth and Lady Macbeth kills herself both brought down equally from guilt. Guilt and fear of being found out causes anxiety and slow disintegration of the subconscious which leads to psychosis and therefore, because of insanity causes confession of crimes or suicidal thoughts....   [tags: literature, literary analysis, guilt, crime]

Term Papers
1561 words (4.5 pages)

Thoughts on Ethan Frome Essay

- When I first knew I had to read a novel named Ethan Frome, I, without reading the back cover, suspected that it would be a boring biography of some historical and adventurous man of whom I would never head about outside of literature class. I was worried that I would have my usually difficult time getting involved with this book. However, I was pleasantly surprised that my interest began to grow as soon as page five. The first feeling I get from Ethan Frome is a sense of cold isolation. The cover of my version of the book is a blurred picture of a dark house surrounded with twig-like trees, cold and empty snow and a burnt sandy colored sky....   [tags: essays research papers]

Term Papers
992 words (2.8 pages)

The Power of Guilt and Shame in Phaedra Essay

- The Power of Guilt and Shame in Phaedra In neo-classical works of literature, the themes are often based on reason and passion. The two factors of influence collide in a struggle that an individual character or group of characters must overcome and decide which to follow, and this conflict usually leads to suffering, guilt, and shame. In Racine's classic, Phaedra, the title character is influenced by her overwhelming passion, which leads to her commit her crimes by the power of guilt and shame....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
380 words (1.1 pages)