Drug testing in public schools is an issue that the courts have had the main role in
regulating. The legislative and executive branches don’t give much direction on this
issue, which leaves it up to the courts to decide. The issue of public college drug testing
is one that has not received much attention because no public college has implemented a
drug testing program for students that were not athletes. Linn State Technical College
(LSTC), a small college in rural Missouri, broke this precedent and made headlines this
year when it implemented a mandatory drug testing program for all students. The
program was implimented to ensure the safety of students that will be working with
heavy machinery. With dangerous activities like aircraft maintenance, heavy engine
repair and nuclear technology, the students’ safety is at risk if they are using one of the
eight drugs tested for (Williams). However, this has caused concern in many that such a
widespread drug testing program is an unreasonable invasion of privacy. Specifically,
because the college is publicly funded and must uphold the constitution, some argue that
it is a violation of the fourth amendment right to be secure against unreasonable searches
and seizures (Salter). Though courts have allowed public school drug testing, blanket
suspicionless drug testing at a public college is unconstitutional because it violates the
Fourth Amendment and goes beyond the precedent set by previous drug testing cases.
The first reason that blanket drug testing at a public college is unconstitutional is
because it violates the Fourth Amendment. The Fourth Amendment protects against
“unreasonable” search and seizure. It states, “The right of the people ...
... middle of paper ...
Lawler, Jennifer. Drug Testing in Schools: a Pro/con Issue. Berkeley Heights, NJ:
Enslow, 2000. Print.
Salter, Jim. "Linn State Technical College Drug Tests Halted By Judge."
Huffingtonpost.com. The Huffington Post, 26 Oct. 2011. Web. 14 Nov. 2011.
"Student Drug Testing: Relevant Case Law." ACLU.com. American Civil LIberties
Union of Eastern Missouri, 21 Oct. 2002. Web. 14 Nov. 2011.
Tannahill v. Lockney Indep. Sch. Dist. United States District Court. 1 Mar. 2001. Print.
Vernonia School District 47J v. Acton. Supreme Court. 26 June 1995. Print.
Williams, Timothy. "At One College, a Fight Over Required Drug Tests." New York
Times 10 Oct. 2011. Print.
Mapp v. Ohio. Supreme Court. 19 June 1961. MAPP V. OHIO, 367 U. S. 643 (1961).
Web. 10 Dec. 2011.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- About 90 percent of NCAA colleges do random drug testing on their student-athletes. Through the years, more and more colleges are giving random drug tests to their student-athletes. The student-athletes are having very mixed feelings towards the random testing. I am in favor of the testing just because some of the athletes need to be showed playing sports in college is a privilege. I know that there are several student-athletes that do not act like it is a privilege and that bothers me with how many kids can not go play college sports that are very disserving of the opportunity.... [tags: Colleges, Drug Use]
2065 words (5.9 pages)
- Drugs in sports can cost a player his or her scholarship(s) and more seriously, their lives. Everyday athletes that you may not think are doing anabolic steroids or the human growth hormone are the athletes who are the big users. 1. There are three major performance enhancing drugs that are used by the super star athletes: anabolic steroids, amphetamine, and the human growth hormone pills. 2. These performance enhancing are found in just about all fifty states and the problem is rapidly growing.... [tags: Athelets Drug Use Sports]
2295 words (6.6 pages)
- A majority of people in the world take a drug test at least once in their life, why should welfare recipients be excluded. There are a total of 104.4 million people dependent upon government help, which comes to total of around $525 billion (Borowski, 2010). This money comes out of taxpayers’ pockets. Groups of people that do not support drug testing say that it costs too much, but the average drug test costs only around $30 (Hireright, 2012). Welfare recipients should have to take a mandatory drug test and should be more prerequisites to be eligible to receive benefits.... [tags: drug testing and people on welfare]
1515 words (4.3 pages)
- Why do consumers purchase specific drugs for various ailments, sicknesses or diseases they might have. Why do physicians prescribe certain drugs over competitive drugs that may be available to the public. Why is it that most of us can easily name specific drugs that fit the many ailments of today’s society. On the surface the answer might be as simple as good TV advertising or radio commercials or even internet adds. The truth of matter is the major pharmaceutical manufacturers own the patents on these drugs and this gives them all of the marketing budget and muscle they need to promote the drug and control the pricing.... [tags: Drugs ]
1902 words (5.4 pages)
- Introduction Random drug screening involves the experimental analysis that utilizes specimens such as saliva, hair, blood or urine in order to determine the presence of certain drugs or their metabolites. These tests are usually done to ascertain the presence or absence of prohibited drugs or steroids. On the other hand, the state welfare assistance/ government assistance is a government funded program that was started in 1930 during which period US citizens and the rest of the world were facing the great depression (Welfare Information, par.1).... [tags: Drug Testing Public Assistance]
1315 words (3.8 pages)
- Have you ever questioned the tax taken out of your hard-earned money. Questions similar to that are where the money is going and if it is being used properly. In the U.S. news recently those questions have been on a great deal of State’s minds; reaching back to 2003, this issue has been brought up time and time again. The main topic of tax money is the use of assistance money and are the recipients really using the money for the right reasons. There are many problems with the assistance program but the one that comes to mind the most is that many people abuse the money given to buy the essentials and provide, for their family for illegal drugs.... [tags: Mandatory Drug Testing ]
2059 words (5.9 pages)
- Drug testing should be mandatory in all states for those receiving or applying for government assistance, such as TANF (Transitional Assistance to Needy Families), SNAP, Unemployment Benefits and even those receiving Pell Grants to continue their education; or should it. This is a question everyone has an opinion on from the politicians to the general public. I will attempt to show arguments against and for the program of drug testing that has already been adopted in some states, such as Florida (Tarren Bragdon, Foundation for Government Accountability), Arizona and Missouri (Aileen, Suitcase Clinic).... [tags: Drug Testing Public Assistance]
1367 words (3.9 pages)
- Is public school drug testing really appropriate. Mandatory-Random Student Drug Testing (MRSDT) and school-based Suspicionless Random Drug Testing (SRDT) are two of many approaches that school districts could use to help prevent and lower the rates of drug and substance use (James-Burdumy 1). MRSDT was introduced in the late 1980’s when the United States Military created other programs to control substance use (James-Burdumy 1; Russell 169). The United States Department of Education’s Office of Safe and Drug-Free Schools (OSDFS) program sponsors and supports random drug testing in public schools as a way to fight the high rates of substance use of adolescents (James-Burdumy 2).... [tags: Drug Testing in Schools]
1512 words (4.3 pages)
- High schools in various school districts have conducted research to try and prove that mandatory drug testing can prevent drug use among student athletes. Mandatory drug testing already occurs at the college and professional level in almost all sports. Drug testing is required at the higher levels because steroids and other drugs are often used to gain a competitive advantage (Bouchard and Sprague 1). To ensure that students remain drug free and improve their performance not only in their sport, but also in the classroom, it is necessary for authorities to perform a mandatory drug test throughout each high school (Issit and Newton 1).... [tags: Essays on Drug Testing]
1418 words (4.1 pages)
- Drug testing is a laboratory procedure that looks for evidence of drug consumption by analyzing urine, blood, and hair samples. If tested, you must provide a sample in front of an observer to make sure that it is not tampered with. Samples are then sent to a laboratory for analysis, after which the employer is notified of the results (Wodell 1). Exactly who should be subject to the new trend of mandatory drug tests, is the big question being raised among businesses, schools, athletes and federal government employees.... [tags: Essays on Drug Testing]
2736 words (7.8 pages)