Comparison of US Bill of Rights and The Canadian Charter of Rights Essay

Comparison of US Bill of Rights and The Canadian Charter of Rights Essay

Length: 1400 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


BACKGROUND OF THE BILL OF RIGHTS

The United States Bill of Rights came into being as a result of a promise made by the Fathers of Confederation to the states during the struggle for ratification of the Constitution in 1787-88. A great number of the states made as a condition for their ratification, the addition of amendments, which would guarantee citizens protection of their rights against the central government. Thus, we have a rather interesting situation in which the entrenchment of a bill of rights in the American Constitution was done by the virtual demand of the states, they themselves fearing a central government which was not legally constrained and restricted as far as its powers were concerned.
The resulting Bill of Rights is appended to the American Constitution as the first ten amendments. These amendments automatically became an integral part of the original document, making them part of ‘The Supreme Law of the Land.’ It was then actually ‘entrenched,’ as the phrase is used in Canadian terminology.

The American Civil War had a very profound effect upon the American Constitution and upon American constitutionalism generally. The Civil war had indeed been fought over a question of states’ rights, among other things, and the states’ rights interpretation had actually lost and was, to a degree, a casualty of the wartime period. Further, that casualty was swiftly hammered into its coffin by three amendments which were enacted in 1865, 1868 and 1870 – the Thirteenth, Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments. The Fourteenth Amendment ultimately became the heart and soul of the modern American Constitution. Most of the legal battle’s surrounding the United States Bill of Rights have been to make it a truly national document – such that states may not violate its provisions. The Fourteenth Amendment finally made this possible.

A more sudden, but perhaps equally profound event is the adoption in 1982 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Whereas before the adoption of the Charter Canadian legislatures were supreme, having power without limit within their jurisdictions, they now have debatable supremacy within altered jurisdictions. Moreover, although no powers or rights have been explicitly ‘reserved’ to the people, supporters of the charter nevertheless appear to give Canadians hope that the possibility may exist.

COMPARISON OF B...


... middle of paper ...


...wo constitutional documents may be similar in respect to their provisions respecting rights, it would not necessarily follow that claims of violation of rights would receive the same response from the courts of both nations. A proper analysis of why this is so would require a book-length account of the constitutional and political history of Canada and the United States. It would include but would not be limited to the selection and role of judges, the role of legislatures and political leadership, the attitudes and practices of the police and administrative agencies, and, not least, popular attitudes towards rights, minorities, and government. In short, the whole of a people’s way of life.

Bibliography

McKercher, William R., ed. The U.S. Bill of Rights and the Canadian Charter of Rights
and Freedoms. Toronto: Ontario Economic Council, 1983


Dumbauld, Edward. The Bill of Rights and What it Means Today Norman: University
Of Oklahoma Press, 1977.

Steven Talos, Michael Liepner and Gregory Dickinson. Understanding The Law
Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson Ltd, 1990.

Black, Charles L. The People and the Court: Judicial Review in a Democracy
New York: Macmillan, 1960.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Freedom Of Speech By The Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedom

- It has been speculative talk for months if Trump is elected the Americans will be considering moving to Canada. The clear indication with the Trudeau government Canada is further plunging into the communism model. The censorship of the news sources, taking away parental rights to raise their children, the attack on Christianity by mandating closure of the Christian faith based educational facilities. The attack on freedom of speech by violating Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedom. The clear sense for the American communist sympathers to move to Canada....   [tags: Canada, Pierre Trudeau]

Strong Essays
772 words (2.2 pages)

The Journey Before Prime Minister Trudeau’s 1982 Charter of Rights and Freedoms

- Throughout Canada’s moderately short history, there have been many acts and treaties made by the residing government, or monarch. Some, more than others, were demonstrated examples of positive rights, where more power was given to Parliament rather than the communities the agreement, or law, was made for. The evolution of rights and freedoms in Canada was a long process that included many stages. Three specific instances that will be mentioned later in this paper include the Numbered Treaties and the Indian Act 1876, which were negotiations made between the government and the residing Native chiefs from across Canada with regard to land and status....   [tags: politics, parliament, communities]

Strong Essays
1617 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on Impact of Prime Minister Trudeau’s 1982 Charter of Rights and Freedoms

- Throughout Canada’s moderately short history, there have been many acts and treaties made by the residing government, or monarch. Some, more than others, were demonstrated examples of positive rights, where more power was given to Parliament rather than the communities the agreement, or law, was made for. The evolution of rights and freedoms in Canada was a long process that included many stages. Three specific instances that will be mentioned later in this paper include the Numbered Treaties and the Indian Act (year), which were negotiations made between the government and the residing Native chiefs from across Canada with regard to land and status....   [tags: canada, aboriginal, freedom]

Strong Essays
658 words (1.9 pages)

A Comparison and contrast of Canadian Prime Ministers Essay

- The Prime Minister in Canada is the head of government and is appointed by the Governor General. Canada is the northern neighbor to the United States, and the Queen of England is its head of state. These powerful countries being so closely tied to Canada makes it a major player on the world stage, and gives considerable power to its Prime Ministers.There have been twenty-two Prime Ministers, with John Diefenbaker being the thirteenth, serving from 1957-1963, and Pierre Trudeau the fifteenth, who served 1968-1979 and again 1980-1984....   [tags: Political Science]

Strong Essays
1212 words (3.5 pages)

Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedoms Essay

- The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms The repatriation of the Constitution and the addition of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in 1982 have had a tremendous influence on federalism in Canada. While this was created by the Canadian government, enforcing it and holding people accountable to it is the role of the judicial system. Of course, this means that much like the rest of the Constitution, the Charter is able to be interpreted by judges. Going back to the living tree doctrine of judicial decision making mentioned earlier, judges are given the leeway to make their own decisions based on numerous factors instead of just on the laws themselves and what the authors initiall...   [tags: Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, Canada]

Strong Essays
873 words (2.5 pages)

The Issue Of The Canadian Civil Code Essay

- How are Canadian values to be defined. Given that Canada is a multicultural society with religious freedom enshrined in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, how is it reconciled with cultural norms that deviate from Canadian values. Honour killings are a headline feature on the news in Canada even today, where murder is a clear violation of both the Canadian criminal code as well as the fundamental values Canadians hold dear. In this paper, I will argue that while religious freedom is a feature of the Charter and honour killings may be tolerated under certain foreign cultures, not only is murder an offence under Canadian law; there is a categorical imperative that murder is wrong....   [tags: Murder, Homicide, Crime of passion, Manslaughter]

Strong Essays
2247 words (6.4 pages)

Injustices Inflicted on the First Nation People of Canada Essay examples

- Although the Canadian government has done a great deal to repair the injustices inflicted on the First Nations people of Canada, legislation is no where near where it needs to be to ensure future protection of aboriginal rights in the nation. An examination of the documents that comprise the Canadian Constitution and the Charter of Rights and Freedoms reveal that there is very little in the supreme legal documents of the nation that protect aboriginal rights. When compared with the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples it is clear that the Canadian Constitution does not acknowledge numerous provisions regarding indigenous people that the UN resolution has included....   [tags: Canadian politics, aboriginal rights]

Strong Essays
2727 words (7.8 pages)

The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms Essay example

- The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms was signed into law by Queen Elizabeth II April 17, 1982. Often referred to as the Charter, it affirms the rights and freedoms of Canadians in the Constitution of Canada. The Charter encompasses fundamental freedoms, democratic rights, mobility rights, legal rights, language rights and equality rights. The primary function of the Charter is to act as a regulatory check between Federal, Provincial and Territorial governments and the Canadian people. Being a successor of the Canadian Bill of Rights that was a federal statute, amendable by Parliament, the Charter is a more detailed and explicit constitutional document that has empowered the judiciary...   [tags: Canadian Bill of Rights, Politics]

Strong Essays
2464 words (7 pages)

Essay on Does the Canadian Charter Effectively Protect our Human Rights?

- Apart from the other laws in Canada’s constitution, the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is an important law that affects every Canadian’s rights and freedoms. It was created in 1981 by former Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau to provide legal protection for the most important rights and freedoms. These rights include fundamental freedoms, democratic rights, mobility rights, and legal rights. Most but not all articles included in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights are protected in the constitution....   [tags: Canadian Charter, Canada, human rights,]

Strong Essays
649 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Comparing The Canadian Court System With Italy

- Within this essay I will provide you with a brief comparison of the Canadian court system with Italy. This will include the roles of their judges, the roles of their prosecutors. The hierarchy of courts, weather it is a common law ground or civil law or some other law. Finally, I will discuss the position and role of the lawyers in the courts in both places. First of all, the hierarchy courts in Italy have four jurisdictions: Civil jurisdiction, Criminal, Juvenile and Penal jurisdictions. Within these for “first instance the courts are set up as follows: Justices of the peace who are honorary judges....   [tags: Judge, Law, Jury, Lawyer]

Strong Essays
979 words (2.8 pages)