In tackling the problem of urban poverty, William Julius Wilson calls for a
revitalization of the liberal perspective in the ghetto underclass debate. He claims that
liberals dominated the discussions with compelling and intelligent arguments until the
advent of the controversial Moynihan report in 1965, which claimed that “at the heart of
the deterioration of the Negro society is the deterioration of the Negro family”
(Moynihan), After that, liberals avoided any research that might result in stigmatization
of particular racial minorities. During the 1970s, a period of liberal silence, the
conservative argument emerged as the new dominant theory of the underclass debate.
Thus, by the 1980s, the traditional liberal analysis of ghetto behavior as a symptom of
structural inequality was replaced with the conservative view that ghetto-specific
behavior is linked to ingrained cultural characteristics—“culture of poverty.” Based on
this theory, conservatives claimed that federal programs guided by liberal policy only
served to exacerbate the so-called cultural tendencies of the ghetto underclass, creating
further problems. For example, they argued that welfare incentives encouraged
demarriage and black unemployment. However, claims Wilson, Charles Murray’s
scathing criticism of federal social-welfare programs in Losing Ground provoked a
liberal revival in the underclass debate. He declares that liberals can no longer be shy
about accurately describing the urban ghetto, which is necessary in order to identify
causes and remedies. In this paper, I will not further discuss or address the
inconsistencies in Wilson’s claims about the vicissitudinary nature of the dominant
theory of the underclass debate in terms of liberal views vs. conservative views. Instead,
I will focus on his definition of the underclass, what he believes to be causes of the
underclass, and how to remedy the situation. Then I will compare his empirical claims to
the challenges presented by works of Elijah Anderson, Katherine Newman, and David
Ellwood and Christopher Jencks. Finally I will present my own thoughts on the concept
of the underclass. William Julius Wilson claims that the behavior of the underclass is a
reaction to the lack of economic opportunities caused by isolation from mainstream
society. He points to the rapid decline o...
... middle of paper ...
... must deal with all of America’s poor,
which includes the rural poor and other races.
Anderson, Elijah. “Street Life Interview.” The Atlantic Online. 18 August 1999.
Internet. Nov. 2003.
Ellwood, Daniel and Christopher Jencks. The Growing Differences in Family
Structure: What Do We Know? Where Do We Look for Answers? JFK
School of Government, Harvard. August 2001. Internet. Nov. 2003.
Moynihan, Daniel P. “The Negro Family: The Case for National Action (1965).”
“African American Male Research.” June 1997. Internet. Nov. 2003.
Newman, Katherine. “No Shame: The View from the Left Bank.” Responses to
Loic Wacquant by Mitchell Duneier, Katherine Newman, and Elijah
Anderson. (From American Journal of Sociology). May 2002. Internet.
Nov. 2003. http://www.duneier.net.
Wilson, William Julius. The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, the Underclass,
and Public Policy. The University of Chicago Press: Chicago. 1987.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Alex Kotiowitz’s book, There are no Children Here, deals with the subject of race, values, community responsibility of the urban underclass. The American inner city deals with the issues such as violent crime and drug wars. With these two explosive issues, the neighborhood experiences the downward spiral of spiral of social seperation, unemployment and welfare dependence. The lives of two black boys, Lafeyette, 10 and Pharach,7 are followed as they struggle to grow up in one of Chicago’s worst housing projects.... [tags: race, poverty]
604 words (1.7 pages)
- The Culture of Poverty and the Underclass. Poverty is defined as the state in which income of an individual is insufficient to provide basic necessities, such as food, shelter, or clothing. On the basis of insufficiency, poverty is broadly classified into two types, namely, absolute poverty and relative poverty (Steinour, 2016). Absolute poverty occurs when the insufficiency is so severe that it is life threatening. For example, cases where an individual is unable to afford basic amenities like medicines, a safe home, food, that could lead to the death of that individual is said to be absolute poverty.... [tags: Poverty, Sociology, Poverty threshold]
1010 words (2.9 pages)
- What does the concept of the underclass refer to. Pay particular attention to the work of W. J. Wilson or similar contributions to urban sociology. The following essay will examine various analyses on the concept of underclass, particularly in relation to American society. It will put forward the main definitions and characteristics of the theories that are attempting to define and understand underclass. A historical definition will be given introducing the concept, followed by factors that help identify underclass.... [tags: Sociology Essays]
2168 words (6.2 pages)
Inequities in Access to Quality Programs: A Detrimental Factor in Continued Strife Within the Urban Underclass
- The socioeconomic status for those who are impoverished in the United States is inherently poor and has not seen marked improvements over the last 30 years. Rather the situation has grown increasingly dire with continued and extreme inequities. Communities within the urban setting suffer from poverty levels much greater than those in rural communities. Mona Scott (2012), explains that minority groups suffer from the effects of the inequity of poverty. African American communities experience an unemployment rate of 15 percent, whereas white communities have an unemployment rate of 10 percent (p.... [tags: socioeconomics, unemployment, wealth]
2015 words (5.8 pages)
- Soc. 456 The Two Major Causes of the Urban Underclass Today in the United States, as well as in many other affluent, industrialized nations, there exists an urban underclass, which is defined as a class of people that comprises members of low-income households who have little or no participation in the workforce (Gilbert 2003, p. 274). Currently there are predominantly two distinct, conflicting views of why the underclass exists. On one hand, there is the notion that the underclass is simply the result of its members, who lack values and morals, and advocate unemployment (Whitman and Thornton 1986).... [tags: essays research papers]
1881 words (5.4 pages)
- In the United States of America, the general path to becoming a successful adult begins at an early stage in life and continues, typically, until the age of 18 when one is able to positively contribute to society. During this period, we are constantly molding our future through the cultural influences of the environment surrounding us, obtaining an education provided through grade school, and expanding upon our socialization skills. Therefore, a productive culture, adequate education, and the ability to adapt socially are all vital building blocks needed to finish our path to success.... [tags: African American, Racial segregation]
2080 words (5.9 pages)
- Parsing out the influences of cultural and structural factors leading to differential behaviors among the poor and nonpoor is a difficult challenge for sociologists concerned with stratification and inequality. This is largely due to the fact that they appear to be so heavily intertwined. Structural and cultural factors reinforce each other in complex ways. Pervasive cultural elements such as ideologies and values are used to frame and interpret existing socio-economic structures and their effects on individuals.... [tags: Sociology of Poverty]
2600 words (7.4 pages)
- William Julius Wilson, a sociologist, refers to the urban poor as the "underclass". The primary issue facing members of the underclass is "joblessness reinforced by an increasing social isolation in an impoverished neighborhood". (1) They not only suffer from lower socioeconomic status, minimal education, and lack of opportunities, but they are further victimized by a lack of community safeguards and resources. The underclass’s defining characteristic is the absence of job opportunities coupled with the absence of societal supports.... [tags: Sociology Essays 2014]
580 words (1.7 pages)
- The working underclass is what many Americans fall into today when they talk about Socioeconomic Status. SES is socioeconomic status; this is often measured as a combination of education, income, and job status. When viewed through a bias of how class plays a role in society, privilege, power and control are often emphasized in measuring what class people are in. The underclass is the segment of the population that occupies the lowest possible class in a hierarchical status is the underclass. Ever since the we can read back into history there has been the classification of people.... [tags: bias, underclass, community]
1229 words (3.5 pages)
- Compared to the rest of the world the United States is economically prosperous however, many citizens are plagued with poverty and destitution. Poverty has become such a problem that one in six Americans are living below the poverty line (Yen). Despite the significant number of Americans living in poverty, most Americans are unaware of its vast scope and scale. The public’s apathy towards poverty has caused it to become an invisible epidemic. The middle -class’s flight from the cities has created de facto segregation between the impoverished and the financially comfortable.... [tags: visible economic and social issues]
890 words (2.5 pages)