Barkovs Hamlet: A Tragedy of Errors Essay

Barkovs Hamlet: A Tragedy of Errors Essay

Length: 6765 words (19.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

William Shakespeare authorship:
The text of Hamlet contains indications
that Shakespeare portrayed himself as
an allegedly dead university graduate.

HAMLET: A TRAGEDY OF ERRORS,
OR THE TRAGICAL FATE OF WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE?
by
Alfred Barkov

To the contents

When the text of
William Shakespeare: a mask for Hamlet - Christopher Marlowe?
William Shakespeare
Hamlet is read attentively, and no details are disregarded, it becomes evident that William Shakespeare included in it something quite different from what has been traditionally interpreted. According to the text, prince Hamlet was not a son to king Hamlet, king Hamlet has never been poisoned, pregnant Ophelia was drowned by prince Hamlet's half-brother. Though that might sound odd, the facts Shakespeare included in the text suggest that the plot of Hamlet has been perceived erroneously.

In what we traditionally consider to be the plot of Hamlet, there exist multiple contradictions and discrepancies which cannot be explained within the established interpretation. Even the age of the hero is not known for sure: Hamlet of the Act I is around twenty while in the Act V he appears to be thirty years old.

If we really rate Shakespeare's talent that highly as we use to proclaim, we have to exercise a different approach to the contradictions in Hamlet. That is, they must be treated as composition means intended by Shakespeare as integral parts of the structure of Hamlet. Attentive reading suggests that the contradictions reflect a sophisticated structure with two plots both containing seemingly the same cast of characters factually possessing with different biographies.

Though the real plot of Hamlet as it was intended by Shakespeare can be comprehended without employment of any theory, there was necessary to develop a version of Literary Theory capable to address the problems of decoding and describing the inner structure of special class of fiction called menippeah. Despite that Hamlet belongs to that class, in my paper, I avoided plunging into the issues of literary theory because the hidden content of any menippeah can be perceived with just attentive reading, Shakespeare's Hamlet being no exception.

Menippeah is different from the three known classes of fiction: the epics, the lyrics, and the drama. It employs a specific way of narrating widely used even in everyday communication (when irony is intended.)...


... middle of paper ...


...lizabeth?..

The Shakespeare mystery was maintained at the state level as a top state secret. Queen Elizabeth personally tackled two cases threatening the fate of Christopher Marlowe.


Chapter VIII: The second Virgin in the history of human civilization?

Christopher Marlowe taught Arabella Stuart, a prospective queen. The parliament adopted a decision the throne should be succeeded by Queen Elizabeth's 'natural' rather than 'legitimate' issue.


Chapter IX: Is Christopher Marlowe The Swan of Avon?

Shakespeare-Hamlet: is Marlowe the Swan of Avon? The place Queen Elizabeth delivered a child in April 1564 is situated on river Avon. That might attribute Ben Jonson's definition to Marlowe.


Related pages:


Shakespeare Authorship. Hamlet and Marlowe's works: same structure

Hamlet by William Shakespeare, and Christopher Marlowe's dramas possess with identical very sophisticated structure.
Hamlet, a summary (The complete version, in Russian)
Roberta Ballantine's site dedicated to Christopher Marlowe
William Shakespeare Authorship Roundtable




Alfred Barkov ut5ab
alfred@barkov.kiev.ua
P.O. Box 36 Kiev 01103 Ukraine


Copyright © Alfred Barkov 2000, 2003
Last updated: Nov. 23, 2003

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Tragedy Of Hamlet By William Shakespeare Essay

- William Shakespeare shaped "The Tragedy of Hamlet" in such a captivating manner through strong character development. Shakespeare gave life to well-rounded characters of the play by giving them characteristics and traits that the audience can recognize and relate to. A strong memorable character in any play has to come to life in front of the audience with standout traits and plausible characteristics. Even though Gertrude does not voice her thoughts and stand quiet most of the play, she is developed as a strong character in the play that affects the tragic plot....   [tags: Hamlet, Tragedy, Marriage, Characters in Hamlet]

Powerful Essays
1018 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about The Tragedy Of Hamlet By William Shakespeare

- The “The Tragedy of Hamlet” by William Shakespeare is one of critical success and one of the most well discussed and analyzed plays in literature. Hamlet is set in the late medieval period in Denmark and was written between 1600-1602 in London, England. The protagonist Hamlet feels a responsibility to revenge the death of his father who was murdered by his Uncle Claudius who is now King of Denmark. Hamlet was made aware of who killed his father by a mysterious ghost. Throughout the play Hamlet struggles with whether he can trust the ghost and if killing Claudius is the right thing to do....   [tags: Hamlet, KILL, Tragedy, Mother]

Powerful Essays
1392 words (4 pages)

Essay about The Tragedy Of Hamlet By William Shakespeare

- Aristotle wrote “A tragedy is the imitation of an action that is serious and also, as having magnitude, complete in itself; in appropriate and pleasurable language;... in a dramatic rather than narrative form; with incidents arousing pity and fear, wherewith to accomplish a catharsis of these emotions.” (Poetics). Shakespeare 's “The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark,” is viewed by most as one of the greatest tragedies that was ever written. Hamlet, an ideal tragic hero in his right, as appealed to many people of different cultures since it was written all those years ago....   [tags: Hamlet, Tragedy, Poetics, Tragic hero]

Powerful Essays
1284 words (3.7 pages)

The Tragedy Of Hamlet By William Shakespeare Essays

- William Shakespeare’s play The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark and J.D. Salinger’s novel The Catcher in the Rye both follow a young male protagonist who is just out of school and attempting to come to terms with the ideas of death and mortality. In their respective stories, Hamlet and Holden inform the reader of the tragic death of a family member that they are still dealing with. While both of these deaths occurred before the stories began, they both shape the entirety of the plot. These deaths deeply affect both of the main characters and neither knows how to cope with it....   [tags: Hamlet, Tragedy, The Catcher in the Rye, Life]

Powerful Essays
1527 words (4.4 pages)

William Shakespeare 's Hamlet - Revenge Tragedy Essay

- A revenge tragedy is a style of drama, popular in England during the late 16th and 17th centuries, in which the basic plot was a quest for vengeance and which typically featured scenes of carnage and mutilation. The first, and perhaps most popular of the revenge tragedies, is Shakespeare’s Hamlet, in which two characters, Hamlet and Claudius, take revenge on each other, each having different motivations to do so. Hamlet defined the outline that every proceeding revenge tragedy would follow which included the development of major characters as avengers and the avenged, the structure of the play, and the question of morality in every aspect of the play create a thrilling story for the audien...   [tags: Hamlet, Gertrude, Tragedy, Characters in Hamlet]

Powerful Essays
1111 words (3.2 pages)

The Tragedy of Ophelia in Hamlet Essay

- The Tragedy of Ophelia in Hamlet   Sweet and innocent, faithful and obedient, Ophelia is the truly tragic figure in William Shakespeare's Hamlet. "Her nature invites us to pity her misfortune caused not by any of her own self-initiated deeds or strategies"(Lidz 138). Laertes tells us convincingly how young and vulnerable Ophelia is, (act I. iii.10) likening her budding womanhood's destruction from Hamlet to a process as "the canker galls the infants of the spring,/ Too oft before their buttons be disclosed, /And in the morn and liquid dew of youth / Contagious blastments are most imminent"....   [tags: The Tragedy of Hamlet]

Powerful Essays
946 words (2.7 pages)

The Tragedy of William Shakespeare's Hamlet Essay

- The Tragedy of William Shakespeare's Hamlet It seems that in this merciless mourning, I have opened a tomb. And though my sight be of seeing, it is not as it once was. For what I see is not with thine own eyes. It is as death appears to those awake. A coldness, an emptiness, that I cannot forsake. Hope Saphos DeVenuto A melody in literature is a language that Shakespeare uses freely in Hamlet with infinite variety. The imagery relates to us to create to the senses a realization of what is occurring as well as to kindle our responses....   [tags: Tragedy William Shakespeare's Hamlet]

Powerful Essays
574 words (1.6 pages)

Essay about The Role of Madness in The Spanish Tragedy and Hamlet

- The role that madness plays in The Spanish Tragedy and in Hamlet, indeed in all revenge tragedies, is a vital one; it provides an opportunity for the malcontent to be converted by the environment into the avenger. In almost all revenge tragedies, the malcontent takes the form of a renaissance man or woman who is confronted with a problem - the deed to be avenged. This crime, and the criminals that perpetrated it, effect that surroundings to such an extent that it is impossible to remain unchanged by them....   [tags: The Tragedy of Hamlet Essays]

Powerful Essays
1991 words (5.7 pages)

Essay about Ophelia and Hamlet in The Tragedy of Hamlet

- Ophelia and Hamlet In 1600, William Shakespeare composed what is considered the greatest tragedy of all time, Hamlet, the tragedy of the Prince of Denmark. His masterpiece forever redefined what tragedy should be. Critics have analyzed it word for word for nearly four hundred years, with each generation appreciating Hamlet in its own way. While Hamlet conforms, without a doubt, to Aristotle's definition of a tragedy, one question still lingers. Did Shakespeare intend for the reader or viewer of Hamlet to feel greater sympathy for Hamlet, or for Ophelia, Hamlet's lover....   [tags: GCSE Coursework Shakespeare Hamlet]

Powerful Essays
1557 words (4.4 pages)

The Tragedy Of Hamlet Essay

- The Tragedy Of Hamlet Hardship, unfortunately, is a part of everyone's life. It is unavoidable, and in Hamlets case he found out that bad luck comes in colossal amounts at a time. Most people see bad luck as getting splashed by a car in the rain, or finding out that the idiots at McDonald's forgot the fries in your order. But Hamlet got a quadruple dose of bad luck. First his father was unjustly murdered. Then the ghost of his father comes back and tells him that he is to avenge his death....   [tags: Shakespeare Hamlet Essays]

Free Essays
556 words (1.6 pages)