Scientists have shown that such mammals as chimpanzees, gorillas, and orangutans are capable of learning and using ASL (American Sign Language) and several artificial languages like, for example, «Yerkish.» However, there is a controversy in how far that ability of great apes spans. There are two different groups of researchers, experimenting with language and apes, those who are in favor of a «traditional» approach, and those who prefer a new, «modern» one. Most debates among them are about the questions:
Can great apes meaningfully relate words?
Can apes create sentences?
Having in mind these two questions, I tried to find the answer using the literature written by researchers belonging to both «traditional» and «modern» doctrines.
Can great apes meaningfully relate words?
«Traditional» researchers believe that great apes cannot meaningfully relate words. They believe that apes just use words which are mostly liked by their trainers in each concrete situation, but they can be meaningless to apes. For example, «only 12 percent of utterances were spontaneous-that is, 88 percent were preceded by a teacher’s utterance» (Herbert Terrace, 1979). In addition, a famous psychology professor at Columbia University, Herbert Terrace, argues that «even if an animal produced such a sequence» as «water bird,» «we could not conclude that it was a sentence» (1979). Moreover, «the words and word order may be meaningful to an English s...
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- One of the biggest questions asked by not only researchers, but everyday people as well, has been the question of what makes we as people human. Being human consists of a complexity of definitions and factors that coexist with one another to make up who we are as people, and through anthropology, being human is studied very carefully in order to provide an answer to this question. Aspects such as language and communication, self-conceptualism, and bipedalism all correlate to what consists of being human, and while some of these can relate to other species, human beings use them in uniquely different ways that enhance our functioning in the world.... [tags: Human, Human evolution, Hominidae, Primate]
1066 words (3 pages)
- According to Chomsky (1972), language acquisition is one of the exclusive characteristics of human beings and is known as the jewel in the crown of cognition (Pinker, 1994). It is well known that other species on earth have communication system also, but differ substantially in their qualities from human communication. Several attempts have been made to teach apes to speak (Allen & Gardner, 1969; Savage-Rumbaugh, Sevcik, & Hopkins, 1988), but language acquisition is a mystery of human beings, it starts before a child is born (DeCasper & Spence, 1986).... [tags: learning acquisition, skinner's theory, LAD]
1397 words (4 pages)
- Ulbaek discusses four commonly hypothesized areas to explain language origins that fall within the continuity and discontinuity approach. The continuity approach, or psychologically known as “Darwanism,” theorizes that language evolved from a distinct source or sources in a gradual process and that language learning is largely influential in this process. Discontinuity refutably argues that instead, this process of communication was solely a unique derivation, most notably accepted by Noam Chomsky as he references this idea’s relationship with biology as a “language organ.” One specific argument is culturalism, which blatantly opposes researchers’ centered focus on innateness and claims that... [tags: Linguistics, Noam Chomsky, Psychology, Human]
735 words (2.1 pages)
- Inferring Dentition and Diet in Extinct Great Apes by Looking at Extant Great Apes INTRODUCTION Knowing the diet of extant primate taxon opens up the possibility of predicting a good deal about its morphology and natural history. Morphology and natural history of extant primates is also important in making accurate inferences regarding their dentition and diet. However, when it comes to extinct primate taxon making dentition and dietary inferences are challenging and the evidence available is indirect (Cuozzo, 2008).... [tags: Inferring Dentition, Diet, Apes]
1914 words (5.5 pages)
- ... It did not matter that apes are considered genetically close to humans – modern gorilla DNA is 97.7 percent the same as that of humans and modern chimpanzee and bonobo DNA are about 98.7 percent identical to humans. Instead, as long as hunters were getting paid and the locals were supplied with food that was all that mattered. While I thought that Peterson’s descriptions sufficed to help the readers see how apes were treated – dead or alive, the pictures were more shocking. Originally, I skipped over the pictures, but they served to help bring Peterson’s words to life.... [tags: killing and eating apes, gorilla]
1724 words (4.9 pages)
- In counseling language is the main therapeutic tool used by clinicians. In order to correctly diagnose and treat a client the client needs to be able to communicate what they are feeling and what symptoms they are experiencing. Clients whose second language is English may require an interpreter because many social workers or counselors only speak English. Many of the populations that social workers or counselors work with in therapy, are either not fluent in English or do not speak English and therefore require the use of an interpreter.... [tags: Communication, Languages ]
2109 words (6 pages)
- Getting back to my interview The 2nd question I asked was do you ever find yourself using mock language yourself. To which interviewee number one replied “Not often” and interviewee number 2 replied, yes. And the 3rd interviewee replied “I have but not often” The next question I then asked was has mock Spanish ever been used against you. To which alias number 1 replied “Yes, unfortunately”. And alias number 2 replied no while alias number 3 said “no it hasn’t” The 3rd group of questions I then asked was related to English being spoken in an area where Spanish is dominate.... [tags: Spanish language, English language, Interview]
981 words (2.8 pages)
- Every few years, Hollywood releases a new Planet of the Ape movie, which is always a blockbuster hit. Moviegoers flock to see these movies of how apes rise together and how they are actually more intelligent than meets the eye. Most people do not know the premise behind these movies of how smart and closely related apes are to humans. This is because people probably have never taken a physical anthropology class and have not done research on apes –our closet kins. Known for his immense studies in the fields of apes and monkeys, his long term research in the behavior of chimpanzees and mountain gorillas, and his experience in the forests with the apes, the co-director of the Jane Goodall Rese... [tags: Chimpanzee, Hominidae, Gorilla, Primate]
2380 words (6.8 pages)
- Amy Tan talks of the English she grew up with. Tan describes an English her mother uses and an English she shares with her husband. Tan sprinkles in the emotional intricacies of a personalized language that is burdened by misconceptions and apprehensively describes this language as “broken,” but expression through the use of a “broken language doesn’t invalidate what is being said, it doesn’t devoid passion, intention or imagination it simply differs from a normality. Envisage expression as ubiquitous.... [tags: English language, Dialect, Chinese language]
1017 words (2.9 pages)
- Monkey see, monkey do. Apes have always been thought to have an increased level of intelligence. Over the years, researchers have attempted to understand the degree of intelligence these primates possess. However, it is essential to understand the definition of intelligence in order to determine the amount of intelligence primates have. Intelligence is the capability of obtaining knowledge and being able to utilize it in everyday situations. There are many hypotheses that focus on the evolution of intelligence in primates that view a number of factors including brain size and modernism.... [tags: Brain Size, Cognition, Food]
1577 words (4.5 pages)