Compare and Contrast A Description of New England and A Model of Christian Charity

Compare and Contrast A Description of New England and A Model of Christian Charity

Length: 744 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Compare and Contrast A Description of New England and A Model of Christian Charity

Mankind can be conceived in interesting ways by analyzing the writings of John Smith and John Winthrop.  As I read through John Smith‘s “A Description of New England” and John Winthrop’s “A Model of Christian Charity,” it became evident to me that the two readings had similar and different viewpoints of the essential nature of man.  Throughout my paper, I will compare their similar beliefs of community and diversity of people and completely contrast their ideas of emphasis on religion and relationships with enemies.

        Both authors stress a sense of community and diversity in order to survive in America.  Smith could not think of anything to “be more pleasant, than planting and building a foundation for his posterity, got from the rude earth, by God’s blessing and his own industry, without prejudice to any” (Smith 114).  This proves Smith believes everyone in the community should join together without showing any type of discrimination.  Likewise, Winthrop declares we must have “before our eyes commission and community in the work, our community as members of the same body” (Winthrop 225).  He basically wants the settlers to live and share their wealth as one joined community.  Smith and Winthrop also agree that diversity needs to exist in each community.  “Carpenters, masons, fishers, fowlers, gardeners, husbandmen, sawyers, smiths, spinsters, tailors, weavers, and such like” are the variety of men Smith found in America (Smith 117).  All of these types of men contribute a part of their lives to their community.  In the same way, Winthrop assumes God ordered “all these differences for the preservation and good of the whole” (Winthrop 21...


... middle of paper ...


...ospel.  Both authors have totally opposing opinions on how an enemy should be treated in America.

        Ideas of community and diversity of people are similar for Smith and Winthrop, but their emphasis on religion and relationships with enemies greatly differ.  In other words, both authors feel a need for togetherness among various groups of people in order to start a successful life in America.  But while Winthrop places more emphasis on God, Smith places more emphasis on having power over the enemy.  This makes their views of man completely different when it comes to how religion has affected our lives and how we act toward one another.  Like Winthrop, I believe that God is the basis of our life, and He has shown us the way to lead a productive life by loving our enemies.  Without religion, America would not have become the civilized country that it is today.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Growth Of The New England Essay

- ... For example, unlike the South, where women had strong property rights, women in New England were required to give all their property to their husband upon marriage. Additionally, many laws enforcing the integrity of marriage was established. Divorce was generally unpermitted, and separated coupled were often forced to reunite by the authorities. Overall, the longevity of the New England colonists led to the development of large stable families. The New England society was extremely tightly knit....   [tags: Slavery, Thirteen Colonies, New England]

Better Essays
1208 words (3.5 pages)

Compare and Contrast Lincoln And Jfk Essay

- Abraham Lincoln was born in a log cabin on February 12, 1809 in Hardin County, Kentucky. Much of his childhood was a struggle; his mother dying when he was just ten years old, and with his father being a frontiersman, money was scarce. He had to strive for a comfortable living, and he spent his days working on a farm and keeping a store. Education was also something of limited resources, but because of his hunger for knowledge, he was able to read, write, and cipher. Lincoln was elected to Congress in 1846 where he played part of the Illinois legislature for eight years, and for many years he also rode the circuit of courts....   [tags: American History]

Better Essays
1740 words (5 pages)

The New England, Middle, And Southern Colonies Essay

- ... Ten years later the Puritans came to New England for religious reasons as well. The climate and geography dictated the lives of the New England settlers. The rocky soil and cold winters enabled its residents to specialize in fishing, shipbuilding, and manufacturing metal goods. Middle colonies are Pennsylvania, Delaware, New York and New Jersey. Middle colonies and American colonies consisted .also the settlement was non-English Europeans Dutch and German. Middle colonies good farmland, timber also import natural resource .the Middle settlements had slightly warmer weather with soil more effective....   [tags: Thirteen Colonies, New England Colonies]

Better Essays
895 words (2.6 pages)

New England and Chesapeake Bay Colonies Essay

- By 1700, differences in religious convictions, wealth, and climate transformed the New England and Chesapeake Bay colonies into distinct societies with markedly contrasting cultures and values. Having fled England because of religious persecution, the Puritans placed a greater emphasis on religion. In contrast, the Chesapeake society, consisting mostly of men who were affected by the primogeniture laws, placed more importance on wealth and land. The climates of the two societies fostered distinct economies and new cultural practices, such as the tobacco wives in the Chesapeake region....   [tags: chesapeake society, new england, puritans]

Better Essays
670 words (1.9 pages)

The Middle Colonies Of New England Over Living During The Chesapeake Bay

- After reviewing the differences, I believe I would choose life in the middle colonies of New England over living in the Chesapeake Bay. New England colonists were more focused on family and their security. Versus the Chesapeake who preferred to be individuals and work and live on their own. Both areas have their pros and cons but New England’s lifestyle was the better choice because of the low life expectancy rates the Chesapeake had, also from their way of living and fight for survival. Life in New England was centered on the family unit....   [tags: Marriage, Family, Puritan, New England]

Better Essays
960 words (2.7 pages)

Applying the Kotter Eight Step Change Model to New England Wire and Cable

- Companies are not unlike species, they must both change with the current environment or risk becoming extinct. Charles Darwin succinctly states this idea, “It is not the strongest of the species that survive, nor the most intelligent but the one most responsive to change.”1 In the case study, “Other People’s Money,” in the scene presented there is a proxy vote going to take place by the shareholders of the New England Wire and Cable (NWC) Company. But, before the votes are casted both the Chairman of the Board and patriarch Andrew "Jorgy" Jorgenson and the potential majority shareholder Lawrence "Larry the Liquidator" Garfield are afforded the opportunity to deliver speeches to the body of...   [tags: New England Wire and Cable]

Better Essays
1921 words (5.5 pages)

Essay about Use of Allegories in A New England Nun

- Use of Allegories in A New England Nun    In "A New England Nun", Mary E. Wilkins Freeman depicts the life of the classic New England spinster. The image of a spinster is of an old maid; a woman never married waiting for a man. The woman waiting to be married is restricted in her life. She does chores and receives education to make her more desirable as a wife.          This leads to the allegories used in this short story. The protagonist life paralleled both of her pets' lives, her dog Caesar's and that of her little yellow canary....   [tags: New England Nun Essays]

Free Essays
1725 words (4.9 pages)

A Fever in Salem: A New Interpretation of the New England Witch Trials Essay examples

- The author of this book has proposed an intriguing hypothesis regarding the seventeenth-century witchcraft trials in Salem, Massachusetts. Laurie Winn Carlson argues that accusations of witchcraft were linked to an epidemic of encephalitis and that it was a specific form of this disease, encephalitis lethargica, that accounts for the symptoms suffered by the afflicted, those who accused their neighbors of bewitching them. Though this interpretation of the Salem episode is fascinating, the book itself is extremely problematic, fraught with historical errors, inconsistencies, contradictions, conjecture, and a very selective use of the evidence....   [tags: New England Witch Trials]

Better Essays
685 words (2 pages)

Essay about Catharine Maria Sedgwick’s A New-England Tale and Hope Leslie

- Catharine Maria Sedgwick’s A New-England Tale and Hope Leslie - Opening Doors for Women Limited opportunities for women to share their opinions publicly throughout the Nineteenth century caused an abundance of females to communicate their ideas through writing. Catharine Maria Sedgwick was among the first of American authors to publish historical and other fiction. Much of her work deals with the role of white women in society, especially involving the Cult of Domesticity or True Womanhood....   [tags: New England Tale Essays]

Better Essays
3303 words (9.4 pages)

Jane Elton's Identity Conflict in Catherine Maria Sedgwick’s A New England Tale

- Jane Elton's Identity Conflict in Catherine Maria Sedgwick’s A New England Tale In her article “‘But is it any good?’: Evaluating Nineteenth-Century American Women’s Fiction,” Susan Harris provides methods and criteria for examining Women’s Fiction in what she calls “process analysis” (45). To apply Harris’ guidelines to Catherine Maria Sedgwick’s A New England Tale, I must first “acknowledge the ideological basis of [my] endeavor” (45) as a feminist/equalitist critique of the text. Furthermore, I identify the three-fold approach that Harris describes as historical, in distinguishing early nineteenth-century from mid- to late-century attitudes, rhetorical, in labeling Sedgwick’s communicat...   [tags: New England Tale Essays]

Better Essays
2005 words (5.7 pages)