Aboriginal Customary Law VS European Law Essay

Aboriginal Customary Law VS European Law Essay

Length: 2499 words (7.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Aboriginal customary law and European law have been at odds since the first years of the European invasion, but only recently has the clash come into the open. Stuart MacMillan of the Aboriginal Resource and Development Services in the Northern Territory says that remote Aboriginal communities there and in Western Australia, South Australia and Queensland see no reason why they should submit to "whitefella law".
The governments of the Northern Territory and Western Australia are investigating how indigenous law can be incorporated into state law. Chris Sidoti of the Human Rights Council of Australia says: "Some people would say that human rights runs opposite to Aboriginal law, others that it provides a universal standard to which other legal traditions must adapt. Customary law can't remain immutable. The problem for those trying to bring the two systems into line is that human rights law derives from a western legal tradition which frequently contradicts Aboriginal law.
Colin McDonald, a Darwin barrister and expert in customary law, says that on such issues Australia's legal system may simply have to bite the bullet and go against the norms of international human rights.
Aboriginal women have often claimed that the law has been slanted to support the rights of indigenous men over women.
Lowitja O'Donoghue, who formerly chaired the government's Aboriginal affairs body ATSIC, believes that Australian law should be more aggressive in such cases. Some aspects of Aboriginal law are falling out of practice. Chris Sidoti believes that whatever balance is struck will be as distinct from traditional European law as it is from traditional Aboriginal law. "For traditional people, being put in jail is more inhuman than spearing, and any unified law would have to recognise that.
Aboriginal Customary Law
The High Court did, however, conclude in that case (a conclusion confirmed in WA v Commonwealth, Wororra Peoples v WA and Teddy Biljabu and others v WA, High Court, March 16 1995) that some Aboriginal land law (that which attracted the status of 'native title') survived the colonisation process. What is far less certain is the fate of Aboriginal customary laws that were not concerned with title to land. Did traditional laws on subjects such as family relationships, title to goods, community justice mechanisms, inheritance and criminal law survive c...

... middle of paper ...

...e necessary, and those laws which were to be applied could not be made applicable to all of the Aboriginal peoples but only to some.
It would not be inconsistent with the principle of equality before the law that, where members of the Aboriginal race have special needs, those should be recognised by special rules laid down by the law. Further, the law is flexible enough to allow the courts to consider the special situation of an Aboriginal party where that is relevant. As the courts have recognised, the sentencing of Aboriginal offenders presents particular difficulties. Judges, in an attempt to do justice in discharging the difficult role of sentencing tribal and semi-tribal Aboriginal persons, have gone further. Clearly the ordinary criminal law is capable of facing these difficulties. It is neither necessary, nor desirable, to apply to the Aboriginal peoples the rules of their customary law rather than the general law. The attempt to uphold Aboriginal customary law is one aspect of the notion that the Aboriginal peoples will benefit if they continue to be treated as a class separate from the rest of the community, which must necessarily be a dependent and disadvantaged class.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparing a Aboriginal and Australian Justice Systems Essay

- Interrelationship : Aboriginal & Australian justice system : The recognition of aboriginal customary laws under the Australian Criminal justice system is just confined to acknowledgement of just the traditional physical punishments at the stage of sentencing. It all depends upon the interpretation and readings of individuals who play a role in the Criminal justice system in the capacity of judicial officers, officers of the court, lawyers and police officers etc. (Aboriginal Law& criminal justice,Law Reform Commission,W.Australia) Comparison between Aboriginal & Australian justice system : There are certain areas of conflict between the Aboriginal Justice system and the Australian Law....   [tags: aboriginal customary laws]

Strong Essays
1288 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on Customary Law and the Status of Indigenous Australian's

- ... The customary law is also unrecorded and would become difficult to uphold, inform and enforce. Furthermore an enactment of one tribe’s customary law would disadvantage other tribes, leading to not only a discrimination to one but also the chance the other indigenous tribes would remain inferior in status. Although it is important to cherish and make efforts to understand customary law, in this sense recognition of the “elaborate system” would not only bring about no change in aboriginal status but lead to a possibility of a variety of other negative effects....   [tags: aborigine legislation in the common law structure]

Strong Essays
1162 words (3.3 pages)

Common Law V Customary Law Essay

- Common Law v Customary Law: The Case of Takamore Takamore v Clarke The Supreme Court’s decision in Takamore v Clarke raises the question of whether New Zealand permitted Ms. Clarke (the partner and executor of Mr. Takamore) to dispose of his body. When Mr. Takamore died, his body was taken by his extended family, and buried, against the wishes of Ms. Clarke. The judges of the Supreme Court agreed to dismiss the appeal by Ms. Takamore (sister of Mr. Takamore). As such the Supreme Court ordered the body to be exhumed and reburied in a place agreed to by Ms....   [tags: Common law, Law, Jury, English law]

Strong Essays
1385 words (4 pages)

Essay Customary International Law

- According to Article 38 of the 1946 Statute of the International Court of Justice, the Court shall apply “international custom, as evidence of a general practice accepted as law” in its decisions (Kritsiotis 123). In other words, the International Court of Justice cites customs as a formal source of law. According to Roberto Unger, author of Law in a Modern Society, customary international law is best defined as “any recurring mode of interaction among individuals and groups, together with the more or less explicit acknowledgement of these groups and individuals that such patterns of interaction produce reciprocal expectations of conduct that out to be satisfied (Shaw 72-73)....   [tags: Law]

Strong Essays
1669 words (4.8 pages)

Indigenous Speeches: Exploration of the Mabo Case, Stolen Generation and Reconciliation

- Exploration of the Mabo Case, Stolen Generation and Reconciliation Both Keating’s and Rudd’s speeches are firmly based on the ideas of recognition and reconciliation for the wrongs that European settlers, and their decedents, have inflicted on Indigenous Australians. To explore this idea I believe that it is necessary to take a closer look at both the plight of Eddie Mabo and the stories of the Stolen Generation. The Mabo Case Eddie Mabo is widely known for his plight to regain land rights for both Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people....   [tags: european settlers, stolen generation ]

Strong Essays
1838 words (5.3 pages)

Essay on The Law Of The European Union

- Spearheaded by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) the traditional means of enforcing a directive is through direct effect after the expiry of its transposition date; this is a judicially created principle that protects the rights of particular individuals. A directive usually has direct effect when its provisions are clear, precise and unconditional. However the enforceability of direct effect operates to the detriment of private parties. In this analysis, the aim is to reveal the development of principles surrounding the enforcement of directives for private persons, since there has been an ongoing debate concerning directives solely having vertical-direct effect, namely the...   [tags: European Union, European Union law, Direct effect]

Strong Essays
700 words (2 pages)

Essay on Aboriginal And Torres Strait Islander Law

- Compare and contrast the arguments that have been advanced for and against the incorporation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Law in the criminal justice system. Introduction The gross over representation of indigenous people in the Australian criminal justice system (CJS) is so disturbingly evident that it is never the source of debate. Rather it is the starting point of discussions centring on the source and solutions to this prominent social, cultural and political issue. Discourse surrounds not only the economic and social disadvantage of indigenous communities, but also the systemic racism and continuing intergenerational trauma resulting for the unjust colonisation of a nation...   [tags: Indigenous peoples, Culture, Law, Colonialism]

Strong Essays
2337 words (6.7 pages)

Supremacy of European Union Law Over National Law: The Factotame Case Essay

- The establishment of the European Union gave birth to various institutions, which bring order and reform to member states. One of these institutions which is extremely important the European Court of Justice as it interprets the laws of the European Union and makes sure that all the laws are applied in the same with in all of the European Union countries. Aside from interpreting laws it also settles legal disputes between the European Union government and the various institutions in the European Union....   [tags: European Union Law]

Strong Essays
1473 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Aboriginal Customary Laws and Australian Contemporary Laws

- Aboriginal Customary Laws and Australian Contemporary Laws Aboriginal customary laws, before white settlement in 1788, were considered primitive by the British, if considered at all. But Aboriginal laws and customs had lasted hundreds of years, based on traditions such as kinship ties and rituals. These laws were formed by ancestors, spirits, and Aboriginal beliefs, and were passed down the generations by word-of-mouth instead of written down. Being over 500 tribes (each with it's own clans) in Australia at one point, there were many variations to their guidelines, customised to each area of the land....   [tags: History]

Strong Essays
595 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on The Effects of European Immigration on Australian Aboriginal Culture

- Introduction The Aborigines are the indigenous people of Australia. According to their traditional beliefs, the Aborigines have inhabited Australia since the beginning of time, but most modern dating techniques have placed the first native Australians at closer to 60,000 years ago, based on carbon dating of fossils and knowledge of geological changes in the region. Sea levels have fluctuated throughout history and were 200 meters lower at the time the ancestors of the Aborigines were thought to have made their way to Australia....   [tags: Aboriginal Australia History Essays]

Strong Essays
2744 words (7.8 pages)