Although the ability-grouped students learn the same amount as those students who are in mixed ability classes, there are a number of positive and negative effects between-class ability grouping has on the students and their teachers. This type of grouping has a more positive effect on the high level students. “It is known that the top 10 to 15% of these students benefit from this grouping” (Considering Individual Differences). For those students in the middle and lower levels, there is no proven effective change in their achievement level. Because of this problem, the achievement gap between high and middle to lower level students is now wider than before.
In pertinence to certain subjects such as reading or mathematics, between-class ability grouping can produce greater achievement gains than mixed-ability groups. However, a common problem with between-class grouping is that the students in one group have little or no contact with others students outside their group. Yet another problem they are faced with is “teachers’ expectations and the quality of instruction are often lower for the low-ability groups” (Considering Individual Difference). It is shown that teachers instructing one specific level educate differently from one another in the classroom. In addition, teachers who have low ability students are not as organized with their lesson plans and they often use different strategies to get their lesson across to their students. A final problem with this type of grouping is that studen...
... middle of paper ...
...rm of ability grouping that we would choose to implement. We feel that it gives the students the chance to exercise their individualistic traits by attempting their full potential when working alongside peers on the same ability scale as they. It also gives the other students in the class (who may be behind) the opportunity to ask questions freely, and not feel unintelligent or hesitant in that they are working alongside students with the same capabilities as themselves.
1. Ability Grouping in Elementary Schools
Author: Hollifield, John
Publication date: 1987 revised in 2000
2. Is Ability Grouping the Way to Go---Or Should It Go Away?
Article by Gary Hopkins
Copyright © 2004 Education World
3. Huitt, William. Considering Individual Differences. June 1999.
4. Snowman, Jack. Biehler, Robert. Psychology Applied to Teaching. Houghton Mifflin
Company: Boston. 2003.
5. Westchester Institute for Human Services Research. The Balanced View: Ability
Grouping. Volume 6: #2. July 2002.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Does ability grouping increase the academic achievement of gifted students. Does it hurt the self-esteem or achievement of the average or below average students. Should the curriculum vary by ability group. The controversy on whether or not ability grouping is the best or right way to divide classes has been debated for years. There are just as many proponents for ability grouping as there are opponents and there is also a wide variety of research done. In education, this controversy still has yet to be solved and more research is needed.... [tags: Education]
1022 words (2.9 pages)
- Flexible instructional groups are the product of a methodology in which teachers are empowered to group their students based upon the student’s readiness to begin learning specific levels of course content. Basically, data is collected based upon one or more forms of assessment to determine at what level of mastery of a subject the individual student is currently located. Using this data, the student is assigned to a particular group with other students at the same or nearly the same level of learning readiness.... [tags: Education]
1131 words (3.2 pages)
- The teachers are the overall distributors of the ability grouping program. Teachers are human beings and they are just following the basis on which they were taught. It is an incredible responsibility to be expected to improve and come up with better teaching methods then the professors and educators before had set in place. There are all of these programs and regulations one has to follow when taking on the world of education. There are so many overlapping problems to face when confronting a certain type of curriculum to teach.... [tags: Education, High school, Program, Teacher]
850 words (2.4 pages)
- Ability Grouping (also known as Tracking) is a method of combining students of similar learning abilities in the same classroom. This is a method that is done in the hopes of continually challenging higher students so they can achieve at their highest level. Heterogeneous grouping on the other hand is grouping students into classrooms no matter the level of student achievement. The basis of heterogeneous grouping is to put students of all levels into a classroom. A study of tracking in Kenya found some great results in support of this method.... [tags: Education, teaching]
1796 words (5.1 pages)
- Use of Ability Grouping How widespread is ability grouping. No reliable national surveys of ability grouping in elementary schools have been conducted, but a consistent picture emerges from several local studies. According to the article “Ability-Group Effects: Instructional, Social, or Institutional?,” (Pallas, 1994) ability grouping for reading instruction appears nearly universal, especially in the early grades. Schools seek to create teachable groups of children within classes containing a broad range of skills, from students who independently breeze through children's novels to those who have yet to learn basic letter sounds.... [tags: essays papers]
2016 words (5.8 pages)
- Ability grouping is a widely spread practice used among many educators today. Between-class grouping is by far one of the most commonly used types of ability grouping. “The goal of this grouping is for each class to be made up of students who are homogeneous in standardized intelligence or achievement test scores” (Snowman, Biehler). In this type of grouping, the schools separate their students into different classes or courses. “Between-class ability grouping is where students spend most of the day in ability groups and use the same or similar curriculum substantially adjusted to their ability levels” (Ability Grouping 3).... [tags: essays research papers]
2042 words (5.8 pages)
- Within-Class Ability Grouping As a future educator ability grouping is more than likely going to be a part of my classroom. I think it can and will be a valuable tool in effectively teaching all students of varying abilities. Ability grouping is a greatly debated area in the field of education. Opponents to the practice believe ability grouping is detrimental to learning and student self-esteem, but ability grouping, specifically within-class ability grouping, can be very effective in teaching children.... [tags: Essays Papers]
2744 words (7.8 pages)
- Eder, D. (1981). Ability grouping as a self-fulfilling prophecy: A micro-analysis of teacher-student interaction. Sociology of Education, 151-162. Eder did a social analysis of ability grouping and how it affects a child 's social interactions. The author looked at many of the psychological studies including this topic and found that students become goal oriented when placed in a group of peers similar to their ability. The article also concludes that this grouping has a positive effect on social interactions overall.... [tags: High school, Education, Secondary school, Tracking]
1934 words (5.5 pages)
- Does ability grouping improve or enhance a student’s learning. Close to 60% of elementary schools are breaking kids into different levels that include high ability learners as well as whole-class grouping according to ability. According to Anne Wheelock, the author of Crossing the Tracks: How “Untracking” Can Save America’s Schools (New Press, 1992), ability grouping does not enhance learning. She states that it is not a neutral practice, either. In fact, she believes it to be harmful to kids and that it actually depresses student achievement.... [tags: Education, Learning styles, High school, Tracking]
1248 words (3.6 pages)
- Due to the range of learning from student to student, regardless of age, school children should be grouped in levels based on their level of academic achievements. Students throughout the world, that are taught in groups, are taught in two different ways homogeneous, at the same level of academic knowledge, and heterogeneous, a mixed level of academic knowledge. The advantages of homogenous classrooms can be associated with faster paces of knowledge for students who are learning at a faster pace than their peers.... [tags: Education, Classroom, Ability grouping]
1042 words (3 pages)