Accuracy in Epic of Gilgamesh and The Hebrew Bible Essay

Accuracy in Epic of Gilgamesh and The Hebrew Bible Essay

Length: 1389 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

There is much debate over the historical accuracy of the Hebrew Bible and The Epic of Gilgamesh. Some claim that to understand a work of literature requires extensive knowledge of the background of this work. The contrary position is that a work of literature can be interpreted solely on it’s content. The meaning of the term classical literature is that it can be applied during any period of time, it is eternal. Yet the conditions surrounding the author might still be of interest to the reader, and of importance to the work. As with many cases, the truth is somewhere in between the two extremes. Both sides have valid arguments about the importance of historicity.

To say that historicity is of the utmost importance may seem extreme. Yet to understand a work, it is important to know if these were fantastic, yet true tales, or if they came from the mind of an author. Some may read a deeper significance into a fictional work. The fact that a story was ‘invented’ usually mean that it was created for a specific purpose. An author would be more prone to using certain literary devices, even in the story line, then fate, or whatever one believes creates the true stories. A completely fictional story may have more use of symbolism, and to search for the meaning of this symbolism, it might be important to know the environment in which it was written.

On the other hand, a reader may put greater emphasis on the meaning behind stories based on fact. This may be because of a faith in a higher power that controls the events in a story. If one believes in God, or in any higher power, the events of a particular story can take on meaning as an act of this power, or even as a symbolic work from god. Still others may be more inspired by the...


... middle of paper ...


...f a leader. The fact that Gilgamesh is presented as divine in the book ends credence to the possibility that the actual King was believed to be godly.

It is in this instance, and others like it that we see another example of the importance of historicity. By studying these works, we can gain insight into ancient cultures, and even hypothesize about the past. If a work is highly historically accurate in other respects, it might lead one to believe that the other accounts in the work are accurate. Through this method, we may discover some of history through works of literature, history that records may not contain. Yet through this method we can only speculate, we cannot be certain of the accuracy of our results.

Works Cited:

Norman K. Gottwald The Hebrew Bible . Fortress Press, 1985.

Sandars, N. K., trans. The Epic of Gilgamesh. London: Penguin, 1972.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Gilgamesh : The Epic Of Gilgamesh Essay

- ... This makes you get the idea: it is a lot of event description from the outside, which the narrator takes us inside the characters thought. The first taste of this is after Enkidu had finished his frolicking with shamhat. He, therefore, realized he would like a friend (naturally) after all that loving with temple-prostitute. Before even Enkidu tells shamhat that, the narrator, therefore, lets us inside his head for a moment. Narrator’s point of view also comes in when at some points the characters talk in their voices about things that had taken place into their lives in the past still this comes in the third person frame....   [tags: Epic of Gilgamesh, Odyssey, Epic poetry, Ishtar]

Strong Essays
1008 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Epic Of Gilgamesh, By King Gilgamesh

- ... In Uruk a new king had taken over, King Lugalsaggizi was now ruling the historical city. Uruk was fast on the road to becoming the largest city in the world and it defiantly was the largest in Mesopotamia. Mesopotamia was a place with a lot of sun and very little rain. It was, however, between two rivers that flooded easily. Irrigation was a necessity if the Sumerians were to grow crops or raise cattle. Marshes were drained and ditches dug. The new system of laws helped decide who got how much water....   [tags: Mesopotamia, Sumer, Epic of Gilgamesh, Uruk]

Strong Essays
946 words (2.7 pages)

Textual Analysis of Epic of Gilgamesh and Book of Genesis of the Holy Bible

- A Textual Analysis of Genesis and the Epic of Gilgamesh The stories of the floods found in both Gilgamesh and Genesis contain many striking similarities that are inevitably beyond mere coincidence. One could surmise that both of these stories might have a basis in common historical occurrence. However, despite the fact that both of these works discuss a common topic, the portrayal of this event is quite different. Like identical twins raised in different cultures, the expressions of these works are products of their environment....   [tags: Epic of Gilgamesh Holy Bible]

Strong Essays
1051 words (3 pages)

Flood in Epic of Gilgamish and Book of Genesis of the Holy Bible Essay

- The Flood in The Epic of Gilgamish and The Bible The story of the great flood is probably the most popular story that has survived for thousands of years and is still being retold today.  It is most commonly related within the context of Judeo-Christian tradition.  In the Holy Bible, the book of Genesis uses the flood as a symbol of God's wrath as well as His hope that the human race can maintain peace and achieve everlasting salvation.  The tale of Noah's Ark begins with God's expression of dismay as to the degenerate state of the human race at the time.  People were behaving wickedly and sinfully and God decided that a genetic cleansing was necessary.  He spared only Noah and his famil...   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh Essays]

Strong Essays
883 words (2.5 pages)

Epic of Gilgamesh and Book of Genesis of the Holy Bible Essay

- Epic of Gilgamesh and the Book of Genesis History tells us that since we have been able to write, our human race has had the habit of recording historical tales, or stories. Most of the first stories were tales of heroic men, scouring their land in search of some noble prize. These stories are known as epics, and they give us an excellent idea of the lifestyles and basic thought processes of early humans. Along the lines of these epics are the accounts told in the Bible, especially those in the Old Testament....   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh essays]

Strong Essays
993 words (2.8 pages)

Flood of Epic of Gilgamesh and Book of Genesis of the Holy Bible Essay

- The Flood of Gilgamesh and Genesis   The Epic of Gilgamesh records a story of a world-wide flood and pre-dates Genesis. So some claim that this invalidates the Genesis record. But P.J. Wiseman presents an interesting theory in this regard in his book Ancient Records and the Structure of Genesis (New York: Thomas Nelson, 1985). He believes that Moses did not write Genesis but rather translated it from ancient stone tablets written in Cuneiform script. The tablets each would have been originally written by eye-witnesses of the particular events, or those who received their information from eye-witnesses....   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh essays]

Free Essays
724 words (2.1 pages)

Obedience and Arrogance in Epic of Gilgamesh and Book of Genesis of the Holy Bible

- Obedience and Arrogance in Gilgamesh and Genesis The issue of obedience figures prominently in both "The Epic of Gilgamesh" and the book of Genesis in the Bible. These works were produced by very different cultures and traditions (Middle Eastern and Hebraic, respectively) and the characters in each react to authority or advice with very different levels of obedience. Noah is found to be righteous by God and is rewarded with a means to escape the devastation of the flood. Gilgamesh, in his arrogance, thinks himself to be above the mortal concept of death....   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh essays]

Strong Essays
1239 words (3.5 pages)

Creation, Flood and the Hero in Epic of Gilgamesh and Book of Genesis of the Christian Bible

- Creation, Flood and the Hero in Gilgamesh and the Bible   The Epic of Gilgamesh compares to the Bible in many different ways. The epic has a different perspective than the Bible does. This paper is a contrast and comparison between the two books. The three main points of this paper will be the Creation, Flood and the Hero.   The way these two books start out is creation. This is the first similarity that we can state. God created man out of the earth, “In the beginning God created the Heaven and the Earth”....   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh essays]

Strong Essays
1008 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Flood Myth of Epic of Gilgamesh and Book of Genesis of the Holy Bible

- A Comparison of the Flood of Gilgamesh and the Bible People grow up listening to the story of Noah and the flood. They remember the length of the flood, the dove, and the rainbow very vividly. However, most people do not realize that the story is told throughout many different cultures and with accounts older than Genesis¹s version in the Bible. Although each of the accounts tells of the flood, there are many variations to the story. One such story can be found in the Epic of Gilgamesh. Although the Epic of Gilgamesh is similar to the Genesis version, there are some differences in the days leading to, during, and after the flood....   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh Essays]

Strong Essays
805 words (2.3 pages)

Flood of Epic of Gilgamesh and Book of Genesis of the Holy Bible Essay

- The Flood of Gilgamesh Perhaps the most popular comparison with Noah's Flood is that of an ancient Babylonian story of a similar flood. A quick look at the text does show some key similarities between them however there are also some pointed differences. I will show you both and let you decide whether there is or is not a connection. First let us look at the similarities: *It is set in the Iraqi/Turkey area.....similar to the Biblical Flood. *A man is warned by a god to build a ship so he could survive a coming flood, sent by the divine powers....   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh essays]

Free Essays
1107 words (3.2 pages)