“… he [Heinrich Schliemann] found layers of ruins … and two bore unmistakable signs of violent destruction. One of these layers, the seventh according to more recent excavators, was no doubt the city of Priam and Hector. The historicity of the Homeric tale had been demonstrated archaeologically.” - M.I. Finley, the World of Odysseus
The Trojan War and its characters are detailed in the writings of Homer, Vergil, Dante and many others. It is a fantastical tale of a decade-long siege of a powerful city by a massive pan-hellenic force. However, even though it has proved to be such a rich source of inspiration for writers, poets and artists throughout history, it is debated whether it actually took place. Heinrich Schliemann famously said “I have gazed on the face of Agamemnon.” on discovering tombs with the bodies of Mycenaean chieftains in Turkey. The German businessman-turned-archaeologist claimed to have discovered the city of Troy at the hill now called Hisarlik – about three miles from the Dardanelles. However, his claims are still disputed today. Before tackling the question of whether the Trojan War actually occurred, we must ask in what form. What exactly do we mean by “the Trojan War”? There is no definitive version of the events in the war, as our knowledge of it comes from a myriad different sources. Then we should consider Schliemann’s discoveries, and the other archaeological evidence for the Trojan War. Finally, after we have defined “Trojan War” in context of archaeology and historical fact, we must then draw conclusions about the extent to which archaeology proves its historical authenticity.
What do we mean by the “Trojan War”?
The first source that comes to mind is the writings of Homer – the Iliad and the Odyssey. The two epics are considered canon. However, Heroditus’ Histories briefly detail the major events of the war, and relays them as if they were historical fact. Heroditus’ account of the war differs slightly from Homer’s version, and he is well aware of this. After relating the tale of Alexander (Paris) carrying off Helen, Heroditus writes:
“Such was the tale told me by the priests concerning the arrival of Helen at the court of Proteus. It seems to me that Homer was acquainted with this story , and while disregarding it , because he thought it less adapted for heroic poe...
... middle of paper ...
..., or even “Did the version of events Heroditus describes have any foundation in truth?”. If the existence of Troy itself is uncertain, then the historicity of the war can only be more so.
- Homer, the Aeneid, translated by Samuel Butler, taken from www.patroclos.de
- Homer, the Aeneid, translated by T.E. Lawrence (Wordsworth, 1995)
- Homer, the Odyssey, translated by T.E. Lawrence (Wordsworth, 1995)
- Heroditus, Histories, translated by George Rawlinson (Wordsworth, 1996)
- Boardman, Griffin and Murray, the Oxford History of the Classical World (Oxford University Press, 1986)
- Finley, M. I., the World of Odysseus, (New York: The Viking Press, 1978)
- Finley, M. I., Ancient History – Evidence and Models, (Penguin, 1985)
- Alan B. Lloyd (editor), Battle in Antiquity (Duckworth, 1996)
- Heinrich Schliemann’s Telegrams taken from www.archaeology.org
- Wolf-Dietrich Niemeier interview extract from Hershel Shanks, taken from www.bib-arch.org
- Additional research taken from Ian Johnston’s web page www.mala.bc.ca/~johnstoi, and also http://devlab.dartmouth.edu/history
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Homer’s Iliad has been a European myth for many millennia , the long poetic narrative written in the 8th century B.C. recounts a fearsome war fought over a beautiful woman. The reliability of Homers Iliad as a true historical document has been challenged for hundreds of years and only through archaeological studies can the truth be deciphered. The Iliad was written five centuries after the war, where the stories had been passed down through the oral tradition, therefore the type of society reflected within the poems resemble much more the time of Homer .... [tags: Trojan War, Greek Mythology]
2935 words (8.4 pages)
- ... This layer had the fortifications and buildings that he expected, so he named Troy II the Troy of Homer. After he decided which layer he wanted, he quickly set out on expanding his trench, practically ignoring all layers above it. Schliemann’s haste to find evidence to support Homer proved to be his greatest weakness. Despite Calvert’s observations that Troy II was far too old, “at Hissarlik we find incontestable proofs of the existence of a settlement at a very early date, several centuries prior to the Trojan war”9, Schliemann continued to dig, and the “Schliemann Trench” still present at Hissarlik is a harsh reminder of his mistake.... [tags: Homer, Troy, Archaeology, TROY]
1326 words (3.8 pages)
- ... This continued up until Heinrich Schliemann’s discovery of Troy in the early 1870s. Determined to find the lost city of Troy on the Greek mainland where the conquerors of Troy lived but without any previous experience in archaeology, Schliemann used the Homeric poems as guides to pinpoint the location of the cities. Homer’s description of the springs at Troy led Schliemann to choose Hissarliik located in Turkey as the site where he would begin excavation. His crew dug trenches, some going down as low as 50 feet, and uncovered seven major levels each with several strata.... [tags: trojan war, achilles, heroic deeds]
1703 words (4.9 pages)
- At the time of the Trojan War, countries, as we know them today, did not exist. Instead, there were city-states. People lived in their homes and carried on their lives clustered behind the protective walls of their city. Powerful kings ruled the people. On the Greek mainland, King Agamemnon ruled over the city state of Mycenae and his brother, Menelaus, ruled over Sparta. On the mainland of present day Turkey, King Priam ruled over the magnificent city-state of Troy, its protective walls built by the gods.... [tags: Trojan War, Iliad, Greek mythology, Achilles]
1976 words (5.6 pages)
- ... This battle makes the high value placed on chariot-driving skills increasingly clear. Even the gods and goddesses enter and exit the fray on chariots. Throughout the whole Iliad, battle skills are admired and celebrated more than perhaps any other quality – it is a story of war, after all – and chariots and battle are simply inseparable. Chariots are not restricted to the battlefield, however. Another major use for them is in chariot racing, a sport which had emerged a few centuries earlier in the ancient world (Bennett 43).... [tags: Trojan War, Achilles, Iliad, Patroclus]
1052 words (3 pages)
- Women are designated scapegoats of societies throughout history. Women are blamed for using seduction to trick men or are used as prizes for men to fight over; consequently, this allows men to begin wars or arguments over a single woman. In the case of the Trojan War, as depicted through Homer’s Iliad, women are the outright reason for encouraging and causing the greatest heroes to fight for nothing. The Trojan War begins with the abduction of Helen (McAllister 8), which is described through previous mythology where Aphrodite awards her to Paris for judging that Aphrodite is the most beautiful goddess, thus beginning the cycle that women are made prizes.... [tags: Trojan War, Iliad, Greek mythology, Achilles]
2461 words (7 pages)
- ... In book twelve, Circe gives Odysseus advice on how make it home more safety. Circe gives Odyssey two choices, the first, stated “Scylla lurks inside it—the yelping horror, / yelping, no louder than any suckling pup, / but she’s a grisly monster, I assure you.”(94-96) in this quote, you can hear the warning that Scylla is not something to mess with. The second choice in lines 114-117 is states “beneath it awesome Charybdis gulps the dark water down. / Three times a day she vomits it up, three times she gulps it down, / that terror.... [tags: Odyssey, Odysseus, Trojan War, Achilles]
782 words (2.2 pages)
- ... Renaissance classicism, despite Shakespeare perhaps participating in the trend unwittingly, also put great acclaim on the tale not only as an element of nationalistic genealogy, but for the sake of its own cultural resonance as an original artefact of classical literature. What is surprising, and what has made Troilus and Cressida a problematic play in Shakespearean studies and discourse, is its generic mutability, as well as its deviation from not only the canonical material of Homer’s Iliad, but from the general medieval and Renaissance adaptations and receptions of Chaucer, Caxton, and Chapman.... [tags: Iliad, Trojan War, Achilles, Troilus and Cressida]
1369 words (3.9 pages)
- Homer was the ancient Greek poet said to have lived between around the 8th and 9th century B.C. Some believe that he was born on the island of Chios and others say he was in Ionia. He was said to be a court singer and a storyteller. He is famous for the writings of the epic poems the Iliad and the Odyssey. While there is controversy weather or not Homer alone wrote these pieces or many other people wrote it over a period of time and even if Homer was an actual person. Homer also wrote Homeric Hymns which are short poems celebrating various Gods.... [tags: Ancient Greece, Greek History, Trojan war]
1148 words (3.3 pages)
- ... We can compare this to the Greeks because they didn’t have good leadership either, this is why Patroclus had to step in, and lose his life. We see how Agamemnon isn’t a good leader by letting his emotions get the best of him, and by exiting the Trojan war not thinking twice about the consequences, therefor letting many Greeks get slaughtered by the Trojans. All of these events lead us to see how the Trojan War is timeless by seeing how warfare hasn’t changed at all. Veterans are still coming home with PTSD, and war is still dehumanizing them.... [tags: Iliad, Achilles, Trojan War, Greek mythology]
1104 words (3.2 pages)