Essay Roosevelt a Liberal and Hoover a Conservative

Essay Roosevelt a Liberal and Hoover a Conservative

Length: 1066 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Roosevelt a Liberal and Hoover a Conservative
Thesis: Because the Great Depression quickly changed America's view of liberalism, Roosevelt can be considered a liberal and Hoover a conservative, despite occasionally supporting similar policies.

Written for the Advanced Placement U.S. History Document Based Question from the A.P. test.


The political shifts in American history during the last two centuries are often explained by Arthur Schlesinger's cyclical explanation of eras of public purpose followed by private interest. What is considered liberal versus what is considered conservative shifts in a similar pattern. While laissez-faire policies are considered liberal in the Roaring 20's, the onset of the Great Depression in 1929 quickly changed America's view of liberalism. Suddenly, the small government politics of Hoover were conservative and the progressive politics of Roosevelt were considered liberal. Thus, because the Great Depression quickly changed America's view of liberalism, Roosevelt can be considered a liberal and Hoover a conservative, despite occasionally supporting similar policies.

Because the Great Depression occurred during Hoover's term as president, in the public's mind, Hoover started his presidency as a liberal and ended it as a conservative. With the end of the Progressive Age in 1910, big business flourished because Harding, Coolidge, and Hoover kept government from intervening in the economy. Compared to the public purpose policies of Teddy Roosevelt, the laissez-faire policies of these presidents seemed extremely liberal. The invention of the production line which spurred on the Second Industrial Revolution, allowed businessmen such as Henry Ford to prosper, while automobiles and electrical appliances became available to the masses. America's success and optimism caused people to support the liberal policies of the 1920's.

However, even before the Depression, there were signs that Hoover was becoming more conservative. As Document A suggests, Hoover did not want to be considered completely laissez-faire. He seemed less determined to preserve the extremely capitalistic society of the 1920's which was run, often corruptly, by political machines, such as Tweed. However, the success of the American economy under the private interest beliefs of Harding and Coolidge required him to ensure that the lack of intervention ...

... middle of paper ... afloat as shown in Document D.

Roosevelt immediately gained the public's favor with his liberal ideas. In the first 100 days, Roosevelt stabilized banks with the Federal Bank Holiday. In the New Deal he fought poverty with the TVA, NRA, AAA, CCC, PWA, and CWA. These policies were definitely liberal in the 1930's and because of the new programs, Roosevelt received false credit for ending the Depression. Ironically Roosevelt succeeded only a little more than Hoover in ending the Depression. Despite tripling expenditures during Roosevelt's administration, (Document F) the American economy did not recover from the Depression until World War II.

Thus, while Roosevelt can definitely be characterized as a liberal by today's standards and the standards of the 1930's, Hoover's characterization changed as the public's view of a liberal quickly became a conservative during the depression. Furthermore, Hoover's ideas changed from opposing government intervention in the economy to supporting government incentives for employment. Unlike most presidents (under Schlesinger's theory) Hoover experienced private interest, transition, and public purpose within the one term of his presidency.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Liberal Franklin D. Roosevelt vs. Conservative Herbert C. Hoover Essay examples

- ... Because government is exponentially larger today than it was before the Great Depression, conservatives today often critique the status quo and are resistant to further governmental expansion. Because of the different meanings associated with the terms liberal and conservative, neither President Hoover nor President Roosevelt can strictly be characterized as one term or another. Today, President Herbert Hoover would likely be characterized as a conservative. He believed in less government participation in the people’s daily life....   [tags: president, depression, freedoms]

Strong Essays
1529 words (4.4 pages)

Roosevelt and Hoover DBQ Essay

- Roosevelt and Hoover DBQ The Great Depression quickly altered America's view of liberalism and therefore, Roosevelt can be considered a liberal and Hoover a conservative, despite the fact that they did occasionally support very similar policies. The United States experienced political shifts during the Great Depression, which are described by Arthur Schlesinger’s analysis of eras in which public objectives were placed before personal concerns. It seems that the public view of what constitutes as liberal beliefs versus what is thought to be conservative beliefs shifts in a similar way....   [tags: Hoover Roosevelt AP US History Document Based Ques]

Strong Essays
1437 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on Roosevelt Vs. Hoover and the Great Depression

- Roosevelt and Hoover The Great Depression drastically changed America's definition of Liberalism. Prior to the onset of the depression, in the roaring twenties, policies of laissez-faire were considered liberal, radical, revolutionary, and even democratic. This was due to the fact that revolution was a horrifying notion and not until after the laissez-faire and the system of free market fails in the 1920's do people begin to look about for alternatives. The time when people starting to seek alternatives was at the onset of the depression when America's political views drastically change....   [tags: American History]

Strong Essays
1653 words (4.7 pages)

FDR And Hoover Political Beliefs Essay

- Hindsight is 20-20 only so long as that particular hindsight comes from an accepted frame of reference. This applies as much to descriptions of historical individuals as it does to any other thing. For their actions while serving as president, FDR and Hoover are described as a liberal and conservative, respectively. The label given to Roosevelt was mostly true, while the moniker used to define Hoover is largely false. The description of a set of beliefs as "liberal" or "conservative" is a task that, in history, has changed in its requirements and protocol....   [tags: Political Science]

Free Essays
958 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on The Great Depression Era Presidents

- The Great Depression Era Presidents: Liberal or Conservative. Throughout the 1920s, the United States thrived economically, but by the end of the decade the United States were thrown into a major depression, the worst the country had ever seen, and no one knew exactly what to do about it. During the Depression, the US had two presidents, Herbert Hoover and Franklin Delano Roosevelt, both had different ways of approaching the severe deficit, and both were labeled as conservative or liberal. Conservative meaning a general belief in a less powerful federal government, a laissez-faire (hands-off) method with business, and a drip down method of helping the economy....   [tags: Franklin D. Roosevelt]

Strong Essays
1229 words (3.5 pages)

Franklin Roosevelt 's New Deal Reform Essay

- After rapid industrialization in the nineteenth century and consumer revolution at the start of the twentieth century, the United States economy saw an unprecedented commercial boom. As Europe laid in ruins after World War I, the Harding and Coolidge administrations enjoyed prosperity and rejuvenated American spirits, but on October’s infamous Black Tuesday, there was a stock market crash that shook the global economy, and the nation toppled into a period of unemployment, stagnation and low morale....   [tags: Ronald Reagan, President of the United States]

Strong Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)

Conservative and Liberal Ideologies in Regard to Health Care Essay

- Conservatives, ideology places the values on status quo. They have difficulties accepting changes, and believe that change should be taking at a slow pace. They believe that human institutions are the product of a gradual process of experience. Conservatives believe slow changes would be more effective over a long period of time. time. They believe changing institutions and practices would affect the would affect the underlying structure. Conservatives be that it is not realistic to expect that that changes in institutions and practices would replace the existing without causing chaos....   [tags: USA, conservative, liberal, health care,]

Strong Essays
715 words (2 pages)

Liberal Arts And Conservative Arts Essay

- It is not difficult to figure out what the liberal arts are; all it took was a simple google search and the definition was brought up instantly. Liberal arts are academic subjects such as literature, philosophy, mathematics, and social and physical sciences as distinct from professional and technical subjects. I am not majoring in any of these subjects and I hardly have any classes such as these in my schedule so I decided I needed to look up definitions that actually pertain to me. The definition of a liberal arts college was just as easy to find as the last one....   [tags: Liberal arts, Liberal arts college, Christianity]

Strong Essays
1012 words (2.9 pages)

Franklin Roosevelt And Herbert Hoover Essay

- Oaths and promises were made by Franklin Roosevelt and Herbert Hoover in their inaugural addresses. Hoover and Roosevelt helped the country face the depression and transition into World War II. Both presidents’ inaugural addresses voiced concern and hope for the country. In their inaugural addresses, Hoover and Roosevelt expressed views about the future, the current situation, the challenges that were faced by our leaders, and how the Great Depression impacted the nation Hoover outlined his hopes for America’s future during his inauguration....   [tags: World War II, Great Depression, Adolf Hitler]

Strong Essays
708 words (2 pages)

Essay on Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt

- Hoover and Roosevelt President Franklin D. Roosevelt faced one of the biggest challenges ever when he was first inaugurated March 4, 1933. This was right in the hart of the depression. F.D.R. came up with the new deal to try and pull our country out of the depression. After his first new deal F.D.R. came up with the second new deal and 11 other plains of making the American people pull out of debt. Some of his most popular plains are like welfare and the new deal. President Herbert Hoover was the total opposite of F.D.R....   [tags: American History]

Free Essays
1013 words (2.9 pages)