A Comparison of Classical Management Theorists and Contingency Theorists

A Comparison of Classical Management Theorists and Contingency Theorists

Length: 2637 words (7.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Comparison of Classical Management Theorists and Contingency Theorists


The management field is characterised by a wide variety of theories,
schools and directions. This essay examines the classical and
contingency schools of thought -- the approaches to organization that
have had the greatest impact on management today. Firstly the essay
delineates and criticises the important theories propounded by
classical writers. The essay continues with an account of the
contingency school, and finally evaluates its impacts on managerial
thought.

Up until about the late 1950s academic writing about organisational
structure was dominated by the classical management school. This held
that there was a single organisational structure that was effective in
all organisations. (Clegg & Handy, 1999). According to Holt (1999),
the classical school is characterised by ?being highly structured,
with emphasis on the formal organisation with clearly defined
functions and detailed rules, autocratic leadership, a rigid chain of
command and control by superiors? (Holt, 1999, p.137). The three
greatest proponents of classical theory were Taylor, Fayol, and Weber.
Each identifies detailed principles and methods through which this
kind of organisation could be achieved.

Taylor (1947) developed a systematic approach to called ?Scientific
Management?, which focused on efficient production. Through the study
of task movements, or ?time and motion studies? as it was known, he
recognized matching the correct worker to the task was crucial to
increasing work efficiency. Under this so-called Taylorism, emphasis
is placed on power confered to those in control. According to Morgan
(1997), this approach to work design is found in traditional forms of
assembly-line manufacturing and in production processes.

Another major sub-field within the classical perspective is
?Administrative Management,? set forth by Fayol (1949). While
Scientific Management took a micro approach, Fayol saw the macro
concepts, a body of knowledge which emphasised broad administrative
principles applicable to large organizations. In Fayol?s account,
management is conceptualised as consisting of five elements, namely
planning, organizing, command, co-ordination, and control. He also
developed 14 principles of management or organisation, the best-known
being division of work, unit...


... middle of paper ...


...ure. Academy of Management
Journal, 25 (3), 553-566.

Luthans, F. (1973). The Contingency Theory of Management: A path out
of the jungle. Business Horizons, 6, 67-72

Meyer, M.W. (1972). Size and the structure of organizations: A causal
analysis, American Sociological Review, 37, 434-441.

Pugh, D., Hickson, D., Hinings, R. & Turner, C. (1969). The context of
organization structures. Administrative Science Quarterly 14:91-114.

Pugh, D. & Hickson, D. (1996). Writers on organisations. London:
Penguin.

Robbins, S. & Barnwell, N. (2002). Organisation Theory: Concepts and
cases. Victoria, Australia: Pentice Hall.

Taylor, F.W. (1947). Scientific Management, Harper & Row.

Watz, T. (1996). Technology rules OK? A review of technological
determinism and contingency theory. Creativity and Innovation
Management, 5(1) 13-21.

Weber, M. (1947). The Theory of Social and Economic Organization. A.H.
Henderson and Talcott Parsons (eds.). Glencoe, IL: Free Press.

Woodward, J. (1980). Industrial Organization: Theory and Practice,
second edition. New York: Oxford University Press

---------------------------------------------------------------------

[1] Pugh et al.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Management And Management Theory Of Management Essay examples

- Management is commonly used in all organisation across the globe. It is very crucial and the best approach which is required to complete the work. Management consists of three objectives, one which includes reaching goals without having to pay too much expense with minimal amount of wastage produced (Olum, 2016). There are several evidence that suggests people during the pre-historic times followed simple principles of management (Pindur, 1995). Management has developed over the years and in order to maintain a stable organisation, different approaches are used and as the time goes by the theories in regards to management gets modified hence creates modern management theory....   [tags: Management, Theory, Scientific method, Theories]

Powerful Essays
984 words (2.8 pages)

Management Techniques Essay example

- A review of current managerial techniques and adaptations reveals that little is known in regards to management variance within small to large organizations (Moates & Kulonda, 2000). In order to critically evaluate if ‘Managerial jobs are the same in both large and small organizations’, a comparison of Fayol’s fourteen principles of management (Cole, 1984, p. 13-14) is carried out between the supervisors and middle management of small and large organizations, classified as having under 50 employees, or over, respectively....   [tags: Business Management]

Free Essays
1684 words (4.8 pages)

Classical Theory And The Classical Management Theory Essay

- The concept of management was radicalized from the golden age of the Industrial Revolution; the economic influences of Adam Smith coupled with the philosophies of David Hume colluded to define modern day economics. The classical management theory advanced from its infancy stage throughout the Industrial Revolution of Great Britain. Its conception is accredited to the works of Frederick Taylor, pioneer of productivity theory, Max Weber, architect of the hierarchical structure of power, and Henri Fayol, father of the 14 principles of management (Walonick)....   [tags: Management, Decision making]

Powerful Essays
720 words (2.1 pages)

Contingency Theory And Situational Theory Of Leadership Essay

- Contingency theory and situational view. Contingency theory, developed by Fiedler (1967), is similar to situational theory, in that the leader applies various leadership methods; however, the similarities end there. Rather than adapting to situations, the contingency leader adapts least favored-worker concept to draw the disinterested or less skilled worker into the environment (Fiedler, 1967). Contingent reward offers a kind of acknowledgement or feedback that motivates the quality of affiliation between transactional leaders and their followers....   [tags: Leadership, Fiedler contingency model]

Powerful Essays
1127 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Kurt Lewin 's Contingency Theory

- Fielder’s Contingency Theory Introduction Leadership styles refer to the manner and approach, through which directions are provided, plans being implemented and motivating people. From the employee’s perspective, it encompasses the patterns of both explicit and implicit actions that a leader performs. Kurt Lewin conducted the first major leadership study in 1939 by leading a group of researchers in identifying the various types of leadership (Burnes, 2004). The study remained influential by establishing three major styles of leadership....   [tags: Leadership, Fiedler contingency model, Management]

Powerful Essays
821 words (2.3 pages)

Contingency Theory Essay

- In this assignment I shall discuss three theories explaining structure choice; management choice, population ecology theory and contingency theory including their strengths and weaknesses. I shall outline and compare functional and team structures as they are the two greatest opposites, using sources to support or disprove statements. Comparisons will then be made between centralised and decentralised structures, commenting on how they relate to the contingencies outlined by the contingency theory whilst also taking into account related issues such as motivation and competitiveness....   [tags: Business Management ]

Powerful Essays
1886 words (5.4 pages)

Classical Management Theory Essay

- Classical Management Theory Early Management Theories Early Theories of Organizations emerged mainly for military and Catholic Church. The metaphor of the machine was dominant, where organizations are viewed as machines. Therefore, the organizational application was, since workers behave predictably (as machines do rarely deviate from the norm), management knows what to expect, and workers operating outside expectations are replaced. Classical Management Theories There are three well-established theories of classical management: Taylor?s Theory of Scientific Management, Fayol?s Administrative Theory, Weber?s Theory of Bureaucracy....   [tags: Classical Management Theories Essays]

Powerful Essays
1964 words (5.6 pages)

Essay Contingency Theory

- Contingency Theory “Contingency theory is a class of behavioral theory claiming that there is no best way to organize a corporation, lead a company, or make decisions” (Pfeffer, 1997). There is no simple or one right way to run things. In the 1950’s and 1960’s, two men named Henri Fayrol and Frederick Taylor continued the study of contingency theory. Research in the 1970’s dealt with the organizational structures and leadership styles for different situations (Thompson, 2005). Contingency theory was started by Joan Woodward, whose company research found that different types of processes were linked to different structures and amounts of control....   [tags: Business Management]

Powerful Essays
1102 words (3.1 pages)

Contingency Planning Essay

- The topic that I have chose from the New Era of Management, Richard L. Daft Tenth Edition is contingency planning. My main idea for the contingency planning is it is very vital for either company or other condition to solve the problem when an emergency is happened and minimize the consequences of the problem. Contingency planning can be also a supporting plan that deals with on specific type of emergency to achieve the goal. The first article I have chose which is related to the contingency plan is “Oil Spill Response Information System and Contingency Planning for Guinean Waters”, page 673-700 which says the Guinea government decided to draw up a plan and organisation to develop Guinean M...   [tags: New Era of Management, emergency, project]

Powerful Essays
1900 words (5.4 pages)

Essay about Classical Management Theories

- Successful management requires an understanding of the fundamental concepts of effective management techniques and principles. In order to gain such insight, and manage effectively and efficiently, managers must develop an awareness of past management principles, models and theories. From the turn of the 20th Century, the need for a formal management theory was growing evident; organisations required a system to guide managers in an attempt to improve productivity and efficiency of workers. This urgency for a theory saw the development of six major management approaches, the focus of this essay will be on two of the classical management theories; the scientific management theory and the huma...   [tags: Business Management]

Powerful Essays
1529 words (4.4 pages)