Keith Basso's Wisdom Sits in Places Essay

Keith Basso's Wisdom Sits in Places Essay

Length: 1945 words (5.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Keith Basso's Wisdom Sits in Places


There is a deep relationship between the environment and Western Apache people. The bonds between the two are so strong that it is embedded in their culture and history. Keith Basso, author of Wisdom Sits in Places expanded on this theory and did so by divulging himself into Western Apaches life. He spent fifteen years with the Apache people studying their relationship with the environment, specifically concentrating on ‘Place-names.’ When Basso first began to work with the Apache people, one of his Apache friends told him to ‘learn the names,’ because they held a special meaning with the community. (Cruikshank 1990: 54) Place-names are special names given to a specific locality where an event took place that was significant in history and crucial in shaping morals and beliefs. Through the use of place-names, the environment became a teaching tool for Apache people.

Red Lake, Minnesota is an Ojibwa place-name. The area dates back 9000 yeas ago when the Stone Age peoples first inhabited the region that is now known as northwestern Ontario. These aboriginals were indigenous people familiar with the properties of the surrounding plants and wild animals. They lived along the waterways and treated their environment with respect and celebrated its bounties through their spirituality. (Web Site #1)

According to Ojibwa legend, thousands of years ago, two hunters came across a very large moose standing beside a beautiful clear blue lake. The Hunters thought the moose was an evil spirit named ‘Matchee Manitou’ and they tried to kill it. One of the hunters shot the animal with an arrow just wounding it. The grand and majestic animal escaped by diving into the water and disappearing forever. A large pool of blood colored the water red, masking the once beautiful blue lake. A creature so huge was never to be seen again. The hunters named the lake ‘Misque Sakigon’ meaning ‘Color of Blood Lake.’ Years later it became known as ‘Red Lake.’ (Web Site #1)

When I heard this story, 12 years ago, it came from the mouth of my father’s good friend, an Ojibwa man, named Henry Meekis. I still remember everyone sitting in front of him while he told the story. His passion for the story permeated the room and we were all captivated by it.

The importance of place-name study lies in the light it sheds on the cultural...


... middle of paper ...


...lace-names can be seen in the following quote given by an Apache named Benson
Lewis.

I think of the mountain called ‘White Rocks Lie Above In a Compact Cluster’ as it were my own grandmother. I recall stories of how it once was at that mountain. The stories told to me were like arrows. Elsewhere, hearing that mountains name, I see it. Its name is like a picture. Stories go to work on you like arrows. Stories make you live right. Stories make you replace yourself. (38)

When I read Wisdom Sits in Places I could feel the importance of place-names through the words of the Apache peoples stories. Events that took place many years ago in a specific areas reiterate the morals and beliefs the Apache people hold near to them. To say that they are anything but relevant to Apache history and culture would be a mistake.

Works Cited

Basso, Keith 1999 Wisdom Sits in Places. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.

Cruikshank, Julie 1990 Getting the Words Right: Perspectives on Naming and Places in Athapaskan Oral History. Artic Anthropology 27: 52-65.

1. www.red-lake.com/museum

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Keith H. Basso

- Keith H. Basso It is rare to find a book that is as informative as a textbook but reads as easy as a short story. But Keith H. Basso is successful in creating an interesting ethnography about the Western Apache culture by using two usually overlooked topics, geography and oral history. Geography and the location of places is usually forgotten or seen as just topography, but Basso proves that geography is more than a location. It is the forgotten history of the name of a place that makes the locality more important than it seems....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1676 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on Speaking Through Silence

- Introduction Keith H. Basso’s research titled, To Give up on Words: Silence in Western Apache Culture is an investigation of situations when members of a certain Apache community in western United State assume the state of silence as a form of social interaction. In this paper, I will first note details of the society under consideration and Basso’s interests in regards to the questions he is trying to answer. I will introduce some anthropological concepts that are suitable to the discussion, followed by Basso’s observations regarding silence in the Apache community including his methods, arguments, and conclusion....   [tags: Keith H. Basso, To Give Up On Words]

Powerful Essays
1953 words (5.6 pages)

Speaking Through Silence Essay

- Introduction Keith H. Basso’s ethnographic research titled, To Give up on Words: Silence in Western Apache Culture is an investigation of situations when members of a certain Apache community in the western United States assume the state of silence as a form of social interaction. In this paper, I will first note details of the society under consideration and Basso’s interests in regards to the questions he is trying to answer. I will introduce some anthropological concepts that are suitable to the discussion, followed by Basso’s observations regarding silence in the Apache community, including his methods, arguments, and conclusion....   [tags: Keith H. Basso, To Give Up on Words]

Powerful Essays
1937 words (5.5 pages)

Perception And Reality By Keith Wilson Essay

- What is sense perception. Everything we perceive in our senses can be misleading and an illusion. In the article “Perception and Reality” by Keith Wilson (see Article 1), the author goes over some of the aspects of how our perception deceives us to believe in things that aren’t there to begin with. For example are colors real. Well that is relevantly dependent on what is considered real, because real again is a perception of a single individual collecting information and making “sense” out of it....   [tags: Perception, Sense, Illusion, Understanding]

Powerful Essays
907 words (2.6 pages)

Ben E. Keith Foods Essay

- Ben E. Keith Foods does not manufacture or assemble any of the products they sell. They work directly with many manufacturers and, in some cases brokers, to procure the products they offer to their customers. They are considered to be distributors and operate in a break bulk fashion. Ben E. Keith places orders for individual products in large quantities, often full truck loads, and the warehouse is stocked according to inventory thresholds set for each product based on weekly demand. When orders are received, the products requested by each customer are pulled by warehouse personnel, in the quantities requested, and combined into shipments of mixed product to be delivered to each customer....   [tags: Sales, Customer, Profit, Customer service]

Powerful Essays
932 words (2.7 pages)

Central Themes of Gilbert Keith Chesterton's Essay 'In Lying in Bed'

- Central Themes of Gilbert Keith Chesterton's Essay 'In Lying in Bed' Gilbert Keith Chesterton was one of the greatest English authors ever to live. He wrote many essays and novels. He had much time to do this because he was a large man and could not move around easily. In Gilbert's essay, "In Lying in Bed" his deep understanding of humanity clearly evident. He speaks informally and rambles like the common speaker does. In my analysis I will describe and explain the central themes of Chesterton's essay....   [tags: Gilbert Keith Chesterton]

Free Essays
290 words (0.8 pages)

Essay on Notes On Wisdom Of Wisdom

- I searched countless sites for quotes regarding wisdom, but kept returning to the one written above. For an unknown reason, this quote is continuing to plaque my mind. I am not hundred percent sure of the reason yet, but I find sentimental value in it. In addition, I find that it relates perfectly to this class and the discussions we have had about places and becoming our places. Unit three revolves around the idea of wisdom sitting in places and I believe this quote begins to chip away at this concept....   [tags: Thought, Mind, Human, Experience]

Powerful Essays
717 words (2 pages)

Rabbit Proof Fence, By Keith Windschuttle Essay

- Every country has its own unique stories regarding races and how it treated the Indigenous peoples of the land. Australia’s history – shaped by the arrival of European settlers, notwithstanding any concord with the Aboriginal people, had led to the government’s policies of forcible removal of Indigenous children from their families over the period between 1905 – 1970. The movie Rabbit Proof Fence told one such story. Rabbit Proof Fence’s value does not only lie in its influence on the history of Australia’s silver screen but also in its heartfelt depiction of the Stolen Generations....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Indigenous peoples]

Powerful Essays
1094 words (3.1 pages)

Analysis of Robert Frost's Desert Places Essay

- Analysis of Robert Frost's Desert Places Robert Frost's 'Desert Places' is a testament to the harrowing nature of solidarity. By subjecting the narrator to the final moments of daylight on a snowy evening, an understanding about the nature of blank spaces and emptiness becomes guratively illuminated. The poem's loneliness has the ability to transcend nature and drill a hole through the mind of the narrator so that all hope for relationships with man and nature are abandoned. In the first stanza, ?snow....   [tags: Robert Frost Desert Places Essays]

Powerful Essays
1234 words (3.5 pages)

Robert Frost's Desert Places Essay

- Robert Frost's Desert Places One of the most monumental poetic works of T.S Eliot is ‘The Waste Land’. The poem emerges as a gigantic metaphor for melancholy, loneliness, solitude- the unavoidable companions of human existence. Similar kinds of feelings are evoked by Robert Frost in ‘Desert Places’. The very title is suggestive of a mood of emptiness. Throughout our life we cross various deserts to find our destiny. The beauty of the poem lies in the conjunction – the meeting point desert outside in the nature with the desert inside....   [tags: Poem Poet Poems Desert Places Frost Essays]

Powerful Essays
890 words (2.5 pages)