Morality and Gay Rights Discourse Essay

Morality and Gay Rights Discourse Essay

Length: 2631 words (7.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Morality and Gay Rights Discourse

When Aristotle discussed the material premises of enthymemes as being important in rhetoric, he was prescient of the kind of appeals that would be tendered by opponents in the discourse over gay rights issues long after his time. Smith and Windes express the nature of this conflict accurately when they write, “symbols expressing fundamental cultural values are invoked by all sides” (1997: 28). Similarly, Sarah S. Brown describes the participants in a “struggle to stake out symbolic positions of good and to frame their side in terms of morally powerful conceptions of right and wrong” (2000: 458). Fascinatingly, she suggests, “even people with deeply conflicting opinions appeal to the same moral concepts for the force of their arguments” (458). In fact, these same moral concepts are ubiquitous to all discourse and to life. They penetrate the social order at the most fundamental level. They are not static, however, and their malleability gives rise to a constantly shifting landscape of debate wherein, as Smith and Windes (1997) assert, the adversaries literally have so much impact as to drive the process of self-definition for one another.

Related to that process is the way in which the landscape itself is defined, which Haider-Markel and Meier see as consequential in terms of “what resources are important and [what] advantages some coalitions [in the struggle] have over others” (1996: 346). (See also: Kintz, 1998; Smith and Windes, 1997). Particularly, they demonstrate that models of discourse which conceptualize gay issues in terms of morality (or culture) as opposed to politics or civil rights offer a rhetorical upper hand to proponents of anti-gay arguments. It is the objectiv...

... middle of paper ...

...vation in Gay Rights/Special Rights.” In: Kintz, Linda and Lesage, Julia. 1998. Media , Culture, and the Religious Right. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

Patten, Steve. “Preston Manning’s Populism: constructing the common sense of the common people.” Studies in Political Economy, Vol.50 (Summer, 1996): 95

Schulze, Laurie and Guilfoyle, Frances. “Facts Don’t Hate; They Just Are.” In: Kintz, Linda and Lesage, Julia. 1998. Media , Culture, and the Religious Right. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

Smith, Ralph R. and Windes, Russel R. “The Progay and Antigay Issue Culture: Interpretation, Influence, and Dissent.” Quarterly Journal of Speech, Vol. 83 (1997): 28-48

Terry, Jennifer. “Unatural Acts In Nature: The Scientific Fascination with Queer Animals.” QLQ: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies, Vol.6.2 (2000): 151-193

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Gay Rights in Ireland

- The Republic of Ireland has a complicated relationship with contemporary human rights laws that many western nation-states have been setting the precedent for, for quite some time. The Republic of Ireland prides itself on its strong Catholic roots, and indeed the adherence to what is essentially Catholic law. Ireland has a unique history that has seemed to act as both an enabler and an explanation as to why for a ‘western country’ it has been able to remain “about twenty years behind the west” (Hug 2001:26)....   [tags: Gay Rights Essays]

Powerful Essays
2911 words (8.3 pages)

The Fight for Gay Rights Essay

- The fight for gay rights has always been going on in America. The purpose of the gay rights movement was to earn equal rights for homosexual couples which were denied to them because of the belief that it was “wrong”. But in the early 1900’s homosexuals became more outspoken about their right to be equal. In 1951 the first gay rights organization is formed by Harry Hay, who some consider the founder of the Gay Rights Movement. In 1962 Illinois became the first state to decriminalize relations between two men with consent....   [tags: gay rights movement, LGBTQ, homosexual]

Powerful Essays
1139 words (3.3 pages)

The Spark That Lit the Gay Rights Movement Essay

- As New York City was waking up on Saturday, June 28, 1969, the New York City police raided the Stonewall Inn, a popular gay bar in Greenwich Village. The raid led to riots and protests that lasted several days. Such police harassment was hardly uncommon at the time, but this particular raid proved to be the last straw. What could have been a quickly forgotten brawl instead became “the beginning of the modern struggle for gay civil rights” (Teal). The Stonewall Riots pushed the gay rights movement to the forefront of hot-button topics in the United States, where it has remained ever since (Teal)....   [tags: gay rights, stonewall riots, same sex couples]

Powerful Essays
1698 words (4.9 pages)

Liberty and Justice for All: The Pursuit for Gay Rights Essay

- Historically defined as the union between a man and women the idea of marriage has been socially ingrained into the minds of Americans leaving any other possibilities of who love can happen between as unacceptable. These strong societal beliefs are far from the truth yet dictate the ability of homosexuals rights to marry one another. Avoiding defining what marriage entails in the constitution, the issue of whether or not gay people have the right to marry has become a state issue. The conservative idea of marriage is changing as society is undergoing a transformation in its beliefs to a more liberal stance....   [tags: gay rights, same sex]

Powerful Essays
1251 words (3.6 pages)

Lawrence v. Texas and the History of Gay Rights Essay

- Gay rights have always faced an uphill battle in a country like America, one founded with Puritanical ideals rife with sexual repression. Viewed as sexual deviants and detrimental to society, the LGBT community has fought discrimination long before the acronym for the gay community ever even existed. The public fight for sexual equality goes all the way back to the 1920s, when “The Society for Human Rights in Chicago [became] the country's earliest known gay rights organization” (Infoplease 2013)....   [tags: LGBT rights, gay rights, alternative lifestyle]

Powerful Essays
2561 words (7.3 pages)

The Fight for Gay Rights Essay

- The fight to legalize gay marriage has won many battles in recent years. It has become available in Canada, England, New Zealand, and here in the United States it is now legal in 13 states ( Gay couples have become more prominently accepted in modern society, appearing in popular TV shows such as “Modern Family” and “The New Normal”. Gay marriage is even the inspiration for popular songs such as “Same Love” by Macklemore & Ryan Lewis. Even with same sex couples being more commonly accepted, there are still conservative and religious leaders that remain opposed....   [tags: Gay Marriage, Legalization]

Powerful Essays
1237 words (3.5 pages)

The Fight for Gay Equality Essay

- As the world evolves all the people who live on it evolve as well. The United States basis its constitution on equal rights and that all people should treat each other with equal standards. The gay community over the past couple decades has evolved from not being able to marry legally, to a handful of states passing a law to allow gay marriage. Although laws are being enacted to better the equality of homosexuals, the gay community has a long way to go before they are equal with the rest of society....   [tags: Gay Rights]

Powerful Essays
1280 words (3.7 pages)

The Debate Over Gay Rights Movement Essays

- ... Following the issue of marriage and procreation, many believe and thus argue that marriage is a privilege and not a right. It’s said that marriage was “created to allow society to support heterosexual couples in procreation” basically meaning that marriage only exists to bring forth acceptance of a couple’s relationship through the community. (“Gay Marriage’). Again, the main focus of many arguments against marriage equality is the procreation. In a list of pros and cons, the majority of the cons arguments include the fact that marriage is between a man and a woman and that homosexuals shouldn’t be allowed to marry because they can’t procreate....   [tags: LGBT community, gay marriage]

Powerful Essays
2716 words (7.8 pages)

Essay on Gay Rights United States

- United States is supposedly one of the free countries in the world and other nations look at it with awe and aspiration. America is a nation with multi – cultural background and people with different identities and personalities. However, if two men walking on the street gradually start kissing each other many people would look at them with disgust. Even being a most modern country, homosexuality is still looked down upon with much intolerance. Is there something wrong with what those men just did....   [tags: homosexual, equal rights, LGBT]

Powerful Essays
2684 words (7.7 pages)

Gay Rights: Homosexuals Deserve the same Rights as Heterosexuals Essay example

- Homosexual people do not want to have special privileges. They just want to have the same rights as heterosexuals, nothing more, and nothing less. Homosexuals are a growing minority with nearly a million gays and lesbians identifying themselves as members of same-sex couples in the 2000 census. But the total gay population is much larger, since the census didn’t provide an opportunity for single homosexuals to identify their sexual orientation, and didn’t count gay couples who live apart (Mason 1)....   [tags: Gay Lesbian Marriage]

Powerful Essays
1456 words (4.2 pages)