Essay on Examining the Anti-Immigration Policies

Essay on Examining the Anti-Immigration Policies

Length: 2957 words (8.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Examining the Anti-Immigration Policies


United States immigration policies are designed as deterrents to immigration into the United States. Frankly, their message has always been "Stay out!" Recently, California policies have taken a harsher stab at immigration, namely Mexican immigrants that constitute the largest Latin American minority in the United States. This paper intends to examine these policies, the effects they have had on the Mexican population in California, and the connection they have to the anti-immigrant sentiment felt throughout the country.

First, though, looking closely at anti-immigrant sentiment in America and policies that have been enacted in the past by the U.S. are necessary to the understanding of the nature of Mexican immigration, legal and illegal, and the subsequent passage of the policies in California.

In the 1920s, congressional restrictionists in the U.S. deemed Mexicans objectionable to immigration into the United States because of their "mixed breed" status.(1) Having been exempted from the national origins quota and the numerical limitation system, in 1924, these restrictionists succeeded in establishing a militarized Border Patrol along the U.S.-Mexico border. (2) The U.S. Department of State, though, in conjunction with U.S. agricultural interests, claimed that the quota system would be interpreted as an "unfriendly act" and would "jeopardize [...] negotiations to relieve the plight of nationalized American businesses".(3) It is this exclusion from the national quota limitation system that is responsible for the great influx of immigrants from Canada and Mexico. (4) The U.S., though, finally placed a ceiling on the number of immigrants from Canada and Mexico in the form of the I...


... middle of paper ...


...m and Myron Weiner, Eds. Threatened Peoples, Threatened Borders:
World Migration and U.S. Policy, Pg. 91.

10. Figures in the above paragraph are taken from Threatened Peoples, Threatened
Borders, Pgs. 92-93.

11. Ibid. Pg. 92.

12. Larry M. Eig, "California’s Proposition 187: A Brief Overview".

13. Stuart Taylor Jr., "Crazy in California".

14. Pete Wilson, "Appeals Court Must Overturn Activist Proposition 187 Ruling".

15. Editorial, "Dreams deferred".

16. Ibid.

17. Paul Elias, "Prop 227 Suit Has Familiar Ring".

18. Ibid.

19. Stanley Mailman, "California’s Proposition 187 and Its Lessons".

20. Robin Cohen and Zig Layton-Henry Eds., The Politics of Migration. Pg. 157.

21. Michael S. Teitlebaum and Myron Weiner, Eds., Threatened Peoples, Threatened
Borders: World Migration and U.S. Policy, Pg. 175.

22. Ibid. Pg. 20.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Examining the Latino Population in the US through Two Films: Quinceañera and Spanglish

- Immigrant population has been steadily increasing in the U.S in the past twenty years. Immigration has been accompanied by myths and stereotypes that have caused strong support and opposition towards immigration legislation and policies. Due to popular television and movies, the average American has many misconceptions about what it is like to be an immigrant living in this country. In order to rid our nation of these misconceptions and generalities, they need to be identified and dispelled. This paper identifies and dispels some of these misconceptions, myths and stereotypes targeting the migrant populations....   [tags: immigrant culture, film analysis]

Powerful Essays
2241 words (6.4 pages)

Essay about A Short Note On Becoming Anti Bias Educators

- Becoming Anti-Bias Educators Our society is still struggling with diversity issues such as those related to race, social class, gender, sexual orientation, disability, and immigration. It is important to examine multiple aspects of these diversity issues in education to begin making changes that will benefit all students. Some of these aspects include the social-cultural environment, one’s own identity as it relates to diversity, and the school, curriculum, and pedagogical environment. Creating a proposal will encourage our school to become more anti-bias in nature and prepare students to be anti-bias citizens as well....   [tags: Education, Sociology, Culture, Social class]

Powerful Essays
1679 words (4.8 pages)

Immigration Policies Of The United States Essay

- Immigration policies have become an extremely heated and controversial topic especially as the upcoming loom closer. There is even a presidential candidate proposing that a wall be put up in order to stop illegal immigrants from entering the United States at Mexico’s border, but harsh immigration policies are actually hurting the economy and American Citizenry. Due to the fact that illegal immigrants actually strengthen the economy, the deportation and displacement of illegal immigrants that is caused by harsh immigration policy, eliminates the potential GPD that illegal immigrants add to the economy....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Powerful Essays
2000 words (5.7 pages)

Essay about Immigration Policies Of The United States

- America was built by immigrants. From Plymouth Rock in the seventeenth century to Ellis Island in the twentieth, people from every where came to America some were fleeing religious persecution and political turmoil. Most of them came for economic reasons and were part of extensive migratory systems that responded to changing demands in labor markets. In recent year, an increase number of immigration have course many America to believe that the country are overwhelmed by immigrant and urged policymakers to create laws that t discourage both legal and illegal immigrant....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Powerful Essays
1209 words (3.5 pages)

A Look Into The Cycles Of The Usa 's Immigration Policies Essay

- A look into the cycles of the USA’s immigration policies Before the Wars Before 1787, immigration policies were established and enforced on a local level and fluctuated with labor demands of the regions; then on September 17, 1787, Article I, section 8, clause 4 was added to the constitution of the United States, this addition gave Congress the power to establish a uniform rule of naturalization. Which led to the first naturalization law in 1790, the Naturalization Act of 1790. This act allowed ‘free white’ immigrants residing in the country for at least two years and at their current state of residence for at least a year to apply for citizenship if they were of ‘good moral character’....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Powerful Essays
2176 words (6.2 pages)

Immigration Policies in Canada Essay

- Canada has a very diverse group of people, each of whom has studied and is a professional in a different skill. From the 2006 Census, about one in five Canadians were born outside the country (McMullen, 2009). Each of these immigrants comes from a different culture and language, and have different characteristics such as gender, age, and education. Yet, it is not an easy process as it once was to immigrate to Canada (Dupuis, 2013). Upon arrival, immigrates face many different forms of barriers, such as: language, proper credentials, abandonment of education and work experience from abroad, discrimination, lower earnings and cultural differences....   [tags: Foreigners, Policies, Barriers]

Powerful Essays
1183 words (3.4 pages)

Anti Illegal Immigration Rhetoric Of The United States Essay

- Over the last year, I have withstood Donald Trump’s anti-illegal immigration rhetoric orbiting the 24 hour news cycle. His proposal appears to be plain and simple: build a wall to solve all of our problems. However, this plan falls short in addressing the true problem with immigration in the United States; it is not solely that the borders are insecure, it is the immigration system itself. The current immigration system allows for people to skip the legal procedures and reap opportunity, while the law-abiding people wither away in the time-consuming process....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Powerful Essays
1297 words (3.7 pages)

U.s. Immigration Policy Policies Essay

- Have you been in recent years in a circus. Well, you probably haven’t, but let me assure you that, yes, you actually have been. Lately, with the United States of America presidential election on the door, “Efforts to overhaul U.S. immigration policy often generate more show than substance” (Malakoff, May 31 2013). So, to obtain more substance than show, the United States of America needs compromised members of Congress to reform the immigration policy according to U.S. actual needs with clear and realistic objectives, and measurable intended outcomes....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Powerful Essays
1249 words (3.6 pages)

Anti- Immigration Attitudes in America Essay

- ... New laws are being voted on daily that limit and take away the rights of the average immigrant and even American citizens. A recent ruling by the Supreme Court on an Arizona immigration law in 2012, in particular, sparked a lot of controversy when made. The Supreme Court declared much of the law unconstitutional but kept the one portion of the law that received the most backlash. This portion was called the “papers, please” section and it stated that police had the right to demand proof of citizenship from anyone who “looks” like an undocumented immigrant....   [tags: policies, laws, citizens, crimes, racism]

Powerful Essays
602 words (1.7 pages)

Canadian Immigration Policies Essay

- Canada's immigration policies changed many times after the end of WWII. Before WWII the immigration policies were "picky" on the people who wanted to come to Canada, but after, it was fair and equal to everyone. Canada's immigration policies changed drastically from being discriminative to being fair and equal to everyone, every country and race after WWII. This act to eliminating discrimination was successful because of; the introduction of the Point System, the introduction of New Immigration acts/policies, and finally the changes made in accepting Refugees....   [tags: canadian politics, discriminative policies]

Powerful Essays
1145 words (3.3 pages)