The debate on Ebonics has virtually left the media spotlight. The proposal by the Oakland School District in early 1997 to use Ebonics to help African-American children learn Standard English met with much opposition. Few people supported the Oakland resolution which, backed by the Linguistic Society of America, acknowledged Ebonics as a language variety complete with its own syntax, structure, and rules of grammar.
The media triggered a dialogue among Americans about the appropriateness of Ebonics in the classroom. "Are you for or against Ebonics?" was a common question many Americans pondered at work, at restaurant lunch counters, and in classrooms across the country. The issue divided Americans, not so much along racial lines, but along lines of understanding. Many people were unclear about the history of Ebonics, the premise and contentions of the Oakland School District's proposal, and the implications of educators beginning to appreciate Ebonics as a distinct language variety. Thus, part of this paper will explore further the educational implications of using Ebonics to improve the literacy of black students. This will be preceded by an analysis of how the New York Times and Los Angeles Times covered the Ebonics issue, and how each (to some extent) helped to legitimize and sustain negative attitudes toward Ebonics.
The Meaning of Ebonics
The term "Ebonics"was first coined in January, 1973 by Dr. Robert Williams, a professor of Psychology at Washington University. The term, which is a compound of "ebonies" and "phonics"(black sounds) refers to the language of West African, Cameroonian, and U.S. slave descendants of Niger-Congo origins. Some linguists disagree about whether Ebonics, or Black English ...
... middle of paper ...
...tions in English: What Role for Education?"(Opinion/Position Paper, 1991). ED 347796.
McWhorter, John. "Wasting Energy on An Illusion." The Black Scholar 27 (1997): 2-5.
Oneil, W. "If Ebonics Isn't a Language, Then Tell Me, What Is?" Rethinking Schools 12.1 (1997): 10-11.
"Original Oakland Resolution on Ebonics"( http://linguistlist.org/topics/Ebonics/Ebonics=res1.html).
Secret, Carrie. Interview. Rethinking Schools. Fall 1997: 18-19, 34.
Smith, E. "What Is Black English? What Is Ebonics?" Rethinking Schools 12.1 (1997): 14-15.
Taylor, Hanni. "Ambivalence Toward Black English: Some Tentative Solutions." The Writing Instructor Spring (1991): 121-135.
Williams, Patricia. "The Hidden Meanings of Black English." The Black Scholar 27 (1997) 7-8.
Winters, Clyde A. "Non-Standard English and Reading"(Opinion/Position Paper, 1993). ED 358438.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ObamaCare) has a goal to expand coverage, control healthcare costs, and improve the health care delivery system. Being one of the last wealthy countries without a universal healthcare plan, the website launch of Healthcare.gov on October 1, 2013 was supposed to be a ground breaking event in the fact that The United States government was moving towards a healthcare system where private insurance companies would have government implemented regulations and subsidides to ensure universal coverage and non-dicrimination; however, this change was soon seen as an international concern.... [tags: Media's Biased Coverage]
2261 words (6.5 pages)
- ... One photo displays a male individual wading through the chest high water clinging to items with the caption stating that he had just looted a grocery store whereas a second photo shows a male and female carrying similar items but the caption states that they had found the items at local grocery store. Though the photos are very similar there is one major difference, the photo with the single male black man whereas in the other photo of the man and woman they are both white. The question then arises since one photo suggests that looting is involved because the individual is black whereas the other suggests that they found the food (Morris, 2006, p.... [tags: Ethics, Hurricane Katrina, Morality, Black people]
1157 words (3.3 pages)
- An important case study subject that relates to journalism ethics is how today's news broadcasts and papers report the presidential campaign. More specifically, how journalism ethics affects the reports covering the republican debates and primaries. Additionally, the media has taken a high interest in reporting coverage about republican candidate Rick Santorum. Not only are the republican primaries important with the upcoming presidential campaign against President Barrack Obama, but also because the candidates provide interesting news coverage.... [tags: Media]
1395 words (4 pages)
- ... No media coverage highlighted this problem or even tied Ramos’ incident to other incidents where the press has been restricted. Even though Trump is known to keep journalists in a “press pen” during his rallies. He is also known for preventing reporters from attending his events. The Huffington Post mentioned in an article that “In recent months, the Trump campaign has denied credentials to reporters from BuzzFeed, Fusion, The Des Moines Register, and The Huffington Post”. (Calderone, “Trump Campaign”) The media thought is was more important to focus on and criticize Ramos for being unethical.... [tags: Mass media, Journalism, Journalist, Reporter]
759 words (2.2 pages)
- The discrepancies in media coverage in coverage of female and children athletics have large gaps, but are gaining momentum in sharing equality. Major athletic leagues such as the NBA and FIFA World Cup have wide gaps in marketing and ratings for their male and female athletes. Children are future athletes and superstars, but as funding and coverage in athletics catering to the males, women are breaking the barriers to be in the spotlight of sport. Both gender contribute equally to athletics, and challenge the each other to accept new ideas and change.... [tags: Media]
2534 words (7.2 pages)
- The media coverage has been consistent throughout the last ten years. The issue receives attention from the media when their is a study released by Statistics Canada or NGOs. These studies produces reports that are covered nationally. Other parts of the issue covered nationally are events that are meant to be national such as writing contests and other events meant to be national .The rest of the media coverage is local. The issue receives attention when their are events organized around the issue by NGOs such as Family Literacy Day .A national event established by the NGO ABC Life Literacy Canada.This gives the media focus and a reason to report on the issue .... [tags: Media]
1445 words (4.1 pages)
- Media Coverage on Hurricane Katrina News of the devastating hurricane Katrina and its economic, political, social, and humanitarian consequences dominated global headlines in an unprecedented manner when this natural catastrophe struck the region of New Orleans in mid August 2005 (Katrinacoverage.com). As a tradition, large-scale disasters like Katrina, inevitably, bring out a combination of the best and the worst news media instincts. As such, during the height of Hurricane Katrina’s rage, many journalists for once located their gag reflex and refused to swallow shallow and misleading excuses and explanations from public officials.... [tags: natural catastrophe, American society, media]
1298 words (3.7 pages)
- Media Coverage of the Duke Lacrosse Scandal The 2006 Duke Lacrosse Case brought to light many of the issues and divisions currently plaguing our media sphere. This terrible act of injustice, which blamed three innocent Duke lacrosse players, Reade Seligmann, Collin Finnerty, and David Evans, for the rape of an African-American stripper, garnered extensive media attention that gripped America for almost an entire year (Wasserman, 3). Today, many scrutinze the media’s methods of covering the case, and deem that certain codes of ethics were not adhered to.... [tags: Media Bias]
1761 words (5 pages)
- ... As Occupy Wall Street gained momentum, the public became aware of sexual assaults occurring within the Occupy Wall Street camps. As a result of this information, media began covering these assaults as part of their Occupy Wall Street coverage. This project will use a feminist media analysis of mainstream newspapers to explore the discourse around the ideology of sexual assault and women protesting in public space. I argue that the coverage of sexual assaults during Occupy Wall Street used a “blame the victim” narrative to link the participation of women protesting in public space to gender based violence.... [tags: protesters, sexual, assaults, media]
647 words (1.8 pages)
- Media coverage of news events can be disseminated to the general public in any number of different ways and media biases often “reflects certain organizational and/or professional preferences or values” (Bennett 2011, 173). In fact, Lundman (2003) points out “that journalists assess the newsworthiness of homicides occurrences using the relative frequency of particular types of murders and how well specific murder occurrences mesh with stereotypical race and gender typifications (357).” In addition, Johnson (2012) felt that the real job of media was to “create a message that…grabs public attention (62).” In other words, can the media grab the public’s attention and hold it.... [tags: Newsworthy, Race, Zimmerman Case]
893 words (2.6 pages)