Essay on The Debate Over Bilingual Education and Immersion Programs

Essay on The Debate Over Bilingual Education and Immersion Programs

Length: 3683 words (10.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Debate Over Bilingual Education and Immersion Programs

In recent years, the debate over whether bilingual education or immersion programs (such as English for Speakers of Other Languages) better serve the needs of limited-English-proficient (LEP) students in the United States has been heating up. The increasing need for such services insights passionate supporters and opposition to rise up against one another in the fight over which is better. Advocates of bilingual education stress the value in helping students retain and even enhance proficiency in their native language, while at the same time gaining proficiency in the English language. Critics of bilingual education, however, contend that such programs only “keep students in a cycle of native language dependency that ultimately inhibits significant progress in English language acquisition” (Bilingual Education, p.1). They prefer an immersion (ESOL) approach, that is, where classes are taught completely and only in English. They contend that students learn English faster and more effectively when they are completely immersed in the language.

The debate has been especially strong in states where Latino populations are high. In fact, changes in education programs have already occurred in such states as California and Arizona. The sunshine state’s infamous Proposition 227 (also know as the English for the Children initiative), Arizona’s Proposition 203, and a number of other state’s English for the Children campaigns are evidence that many people are dissatisfied with bilingual education and are seeking – and getting - changes. Regardless, the general public remains divided on the issue. Teachers, administrators, students, parents, politicians, and researchers ...


... middle of paper ...


...e language to be learned. She offers expert advice to educators, parents, and volunteers as to how to develop, modify, and maintain effective programs for students learning English as a second language.

Slavin, R. E. (2000). How do language differences and bilingual programs affect student achievement. In Educational psychology. (6th ed., pp.119-121). Massachusetts: Allyn and Bacon.

This section focuses on the affect of Bilingual Education programs on student achievement, offering definitions of key terms and analyzing the effectiveness of such courses. The author uses support from research to explain that Bilingual Education programs have experienced much success, but also points out the problems of the system. Additionally, there is some discussion of the recent movements to abandon Bilingual Education, followed by a brief discussion of their effect.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Language Barrier: Bilingual Education vs. English Immersion Essay

- Bilingual teaching in American schools is it good, bad, or both. Who is right in this national debate. Both sides make some impressive arguments for their side of the issue. Even the government has mixed issues when it comes to bilingual teaching. However, the government has shown their views in their budgets and their law making. Another question comes up with the bilingual teaching is should America make English its official language. Some say there is no need for it, and yet 22 states as of 1996 declared English their official language....   [tags: foreign language, spanish]

Powerful Essays
1234 words (3.5 pages)

The Successes and Failure of Educational Diversity Essay

- ... What if a student cannot keep up in class due to his inability to comprehend what is being said. What if a student’s parents decide that this is not the best option for their child. What other choices do they have in the public school system. These are some of the questions that need to be asked in order to find out what teaching method is best for the child as an individual. There should never be a set restriction with only one way in which to educate any student since every student is different and learns in different ways; of course the public school system will not be able to cater to every individual student’s learning needs, but having both Bilingual Education courses and English I...   [tags: bilingual education, English immersion]

Powerful Essays
848 words (2.4 pages)

Bilingual Education: Building Bridges Essay example

- Bilingual education, as an educational program, was initially promoted by educators in the seventies (Hunger of Memory 26) and since then has been a topic of many debates in America. Some argue that bilingual education only serves as a detriment to American culture. Others argue that bilingual education is beneficial to those who come to live in America and want to become a part of the culture, but lack proficiency in the English language. Two authors, who have each taken opposite sides of the debate on bilingual education in America, are: Richard Rodriguez and Ariel Dorfman....   [tags: Education]

Powerful Essays
2166 words (6.2 pages)

How to Give American Students a Billingual Education Essay

- ... Despite the lingering criticism from the 1980s, President Clinton reenacts the bilingual education law in 1994; however, President George W. Bush’s No Child Left Behind Act, which requires all students to meet standards otherwise schools will receive penalties, negates the bilingual education law (Jost 1039). Since 1998, many states have passed loopholes bypassing the teaching of another language similar to California’s Proposition 227 stating the specific teaching method of English immersion, when students only receive instruction in English, for English language learners....   [tags: melting pot, immersion, neuroscientists]

Powerful Essays
1323 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Legal and historical implications with bilingual education

- Intro There are many legal and historical implications with bilingual education. Article One Sheltered instruction: An empowerment framework for English language learners by Helen Abadiano and Jesse Turner discuss the movement in the early 1900s to develop standards for bilingual education in response to “Goals 2000: Educate America Act” along with other legislation designed to promote higher expectations in academia for all students (Abadiano & Turner, 2003). Abadiano and Turner note that English as a Second Language (ESL) in not listed as one of the federal designated content areas included for standard development....   [tags: Education, language]

Powerful Essays
895 words (2.6 pages)

Should Bilingual Education Be Taught In Schools Essay

- “Of the 281 million people age 5 and older in the United States in 2007, 55.4 million individuals — or 20 percent — reported speaking a language other than English at home.” (Newsroom) As the number of non-English speaking people in our country increases there is also a debate going on as well. This debate is over whether American Schools should offer a bilingual education to accommodate these people or not. “Bilingual Education is the practice of teaching non-English speaking children in their native language, while they are learning English.”(Bilingual Education) In “The Achievement of Desire”, Rodriguez writes about his experiences growing up as a Mexican-American student and the toll th...   [tags: business, english, low paying jobs]

Powerful Essays
1596 words (4.6 pages)

Bilingual Education in American Schools Essay

- Suppose your child has been moved to China. Your child does not speak Chinese; is it the school system's responsibility to teach your child in English. Or should your child be expected to learn in the country's language and perhaps get extra help on the side. Why should a school district spend money on bilingual classes rather than on reducing class sizes. In the United States of America we have become a large melting pot of ethnic and cultural peoples. Along with these peoples have come many different languages and alphabets....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]

Powerful Essays
1907 words (5.4 pages)

Essay about Bilingual Education

- The issue of bilingual education is a much debated topic in this country and especially in this state. The Spanish-speaking populace has grown tremendously in these past decades, much of which has immigrated with Spanish as their only language. This has left the public school system with an interesting problem; how to successfully transition Spanish speaking students into an English environment. Public school systems have generally adopted one of two approaches to this problem. One is to allow students several years to develop their English with lessons taught in both languages....   [tags: Politics]

Free Essays
577 words (1.6 pages)

The Increase in English language Learners Essays

- The United States has seen a dramatic increase in its non-native English speaking public education classrooms, especially from students born in Latin American countries. This population trend has been the encouragement for bilingual education reform throughout the decades. Bilingual education has been a long heated debate, especially in the political arena, that has focused on whether English language learners (ELL) should be taught primarily in English only, their home languages, or a combination of both....   [tags: bilingual education, english learners, ell]

Powerful Essays
1248 words (3.6 pages)

The Effects of Transitional Bilingual Education On Elementary Level Minority Students

- The Effects of Transitional Bilingual Education On Elementary Level Minority Students Bilingual Education has been an increasingly controversial subject throughout education systems in America. The growing numbers of bilingual students in the country have provided much debate regarding the most effective way of instructing these students in traditional American schools. Perhaps one of the newest and fastest growing methods throughout the country has become "transitional bilingual education," a program which integrates the English language into these classroom by adding more English instruction throughout the course of the lesson....   [tags: essays papers]

Powerful Essays
1664 words (4.8 pages)