Thankfully, we have more than a Hollywood protagonist to fight for the protection of rights. John Stuart Mill, Robert Nozick, and John Rawls provide a philosophic framework for evaluating the security-for-rights compromise. Though their respective theories vary greatly in theory and in practice, they provide models to condemn this exchange. Nevertheless, each differs in the persuasiveness and effectiveness of their tools for argumentation. Mill’s utilitarianism, Nozick’s libertarianism, and Rawls’ egalitarian liberalism reject the tradeoff of security for a majority in exchange for the violation of the rights a minority. John Stuart Mill outlines a sometimes dubious plan for protecting rights and lacks the a priori protection of rights that Rawls and Nozick afford. John Rawls presents the most convincing and solid argument for the omnipotence of rights in the confines of a welfare state. His philosophy acts as an ideal synthesis of libertarianism and utilitarianism; he demands the utmost respect for rights while trying to maximize utility f...
... middle of paper ...
...t for rights because Tom Cruise says so and because Mill, Nozick and Rawls prescribe it.
Bentham, Jeremy. Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. Published online by Constitution Society. Web 18 June 2015.
Mill, John Stuart. "Utilitarianism." Web 20 June 2015.
Nozick, Robert. “Distributive Justice.” Macquarie University, Modern Political Theory. Web 18 June 2015.
Rachels, James. The Elements of Moral Philosophy. Birmingham, Alabama: Mcgraw-Hill College, 1999.
Rawls, John. A Theory of Justice. Harvard, MA: Harvard University Press, 1999.
Minority Report. Dir. Steven Spielberg. Perf. Tom Cruise, Max Von Sydow, Steve Harris. Videocassette. 20th Century Fox, 2002.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Are you always aware of your surroundings. Do you ever ponder what life would be like if you were abducted. Slavery is still a harsh global reality for too many victims. What we don’t realize is that slavery is not only a piece of history we read about in textbooks. Rather, a realistic element of our world’s current events. The threat of human trafficking endangers citizens of all countries. Victims of modern day slavery comprise a diverse group of men, women, and children of all ages and social classes.... [tags: Human Rights Essays]
1964 words (5.6 pages)
- A man struggles to get the water out of his lungs as his torturer removed the cloth and water that he had been using to water board. He sputters and coughs as more water is forced into his lungs over and over. This man just blew up twenty innocent people and is a leader of a terrorist group. The question remains, is it ethical to torture this man for information, or should this be stopped. David Gushee has several things to say on this subject. Torture is a major ethical issue especially with the ever current war on terror and fight against ISIS.... [tags: Ethics, Morality, Human rights, Torture]
1207 words (3.4 pages)
- Can you imagine a life without pre-meditated murder. In his movie Minority Report, Steven Spielberg brings this vision to reality in the trappings of a police state. The pre-crime unit is charged with the elimination of pre-meditated murder using three pre-cogs, humans with the ability to predict violent crime. Minority reports- sporadic, erroneous predictions- indicate the fallibility of this system of imperfect procedural justice. Civilians have their rights to privacy violated on a regular basis for collection of intelligence.... [tags: the security-for-rights compromise]
3124 words (8.9 pages)
- Abstract This essay explores the concept of feminism as a human right rather than merely a struggle of American women to achieve equal opportunity and salaries in the corporate world. Without denying the importance of such achievements, the facet of feminism that is explored for the most part is the ability for women around the world to be treated as human. Not only are women denied rights such as the opportunity to be educated or to earn money to feed their children, moreover they are considered property and subject to abuse.... [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Essays]
2675 words (7.6 pages)
- ... While the rich have many options and can choose those that’ll increase their profit rate, in other words: make them richer. Perkins comments, “Our own government , in alliance with the big corporations and banks, has created an empire that brings servitude, misery, and death to millions of people.” (Perkins 268) Thus, advocating the realism of exploited workers and their sacrifice in making American goods. John Perkins practices global peace and prosperity in ways he included on cutting back on oil consumption and shopping; being aware of products bought as well as the companies one supports.... [tags: multinational corporations, capitalism]
728 words (2.1 pages)
- ... It is also important to note that the assumption is that it is possible to fight terrorism without infringing human rights, not that States actually do so in practice. There is a lack of empirical data, i.e. research showing the prevalence of terrorism in countries with strong human rights records as opposed to countries with poor human rights records. There is significant judicial support for the assumption that you can fight terrorism without infringing human rights. The European Court of Human Rights, a judicial organ which has produced the most cogent body of international human rights law in existence, has on many occasions found that robust actions by Governments in the fight again... [tags: punishment, unlawful, assumption]
712 words (2 pages)
- 1. When the word slavery come to mind, every one thinks that it is an old ill story, a treatment of a human being as a private property or a commodity reduced to a state of dependency via threats, violence and humiliation. It is considered as a severe violation of fundamental human rights and had destroyed the fabric of the African society. Nowadays, slavery or human trafficking still exists and on an even substantial scale than it did during the empirical era . 2. All over the world, this shameful crime can be addressed only with coordinated and comprehensive strategies, taking into account the transnational nature of the problem.... [tags: Africa, Slavery, Human rights, African Union]
1238 words (3.5 pages)
- ... Article 11 of the European Convention on Extradition which excludes extradition unless the requesting Party gives reasonable assurance that death penalty will not be executed. Furthermore, the fact that this convention is unable to limit the political application of political crimes which opens opportunities to abuse by subjects. The European Union Members achieved to tackle this problem by signing the European Convention on the Suppression of Terrorism which entered into force in 1977. Outside of this convention The EU Framework Decision on extradition policy among member states has turned into a new form with adopting European Arrest Warrant (EAW) in 2004.... [tags: human, rights, laws, process]
1943 words (5.6 pages)
- ... She experienced firsthand the benefits of education, as well as her inability to further her education in the same way as men. Marjane Satrapi sacrificed many things for education, and her parents made sure she had access to it, no matter what the cost. As a girl in Iran Satrapi faced many disadvantages even beyond a lack of education which was prevalent because of the many restrictions on their clothing, the hijab they were forced to wear, and that they were unable to wear makeup (Satrapi 3-341).... [tags: knowledge, childhood, human rights]
1451 words (4.1 pages)
- As stated above, there are various actors in the international community. These actors include intergovernmental and nongovernmental organizations who help shape the foundation and creation of human rights. IGOs and NGOs listen to the international community to monitor and protect their human rights. According to the textbook, nongovernmental organization have been especially vocal and effective in the international system when it comes to human rights. NGOs groups that have a great impact on human rights through specific groups like Amnesty International, and the Human Rights Watch.... [tags: Human rights, United Nations]
1074 words (3.1 pages)