There are NO Just and Holy Wars Essay

There are NO Just and Holy Wars Essay

Length: 2133 words (6.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

War can often be considered an evil act, an act of aggression against another country for economic or social gain, or can be considered a noble event of justice, a defense mechanism of a protectorate country helping a country in need. However, sometimes the issue of war is mingled with religion, which brings the value of war into question. In some religions, war is considered noble and a gateway to heaven. A jihad in Islam is an example of this type, where some Muslims believe that attacking the “infidel” is considered strong promotion of their religion. However, in many religions the ethics of a Holy War, loosely defined as “any war that is regarded as a religious act or is in some way set in a direct relation to religion,” (Erdmann 3)) is in a very grey area. Christianity is one of those religions. Starting in the late 11th century, the Christian church started a series of Holy Wars called the Crusades. After looking at the motives for the war and the teachings of Jesus, the supposed basis of Christianity, it seems as if these wars were not actually representative of how Christians should act toward conflict even though they were considered for the good of the church.

Onward Christian Soldiers

The view of the Church towards war from its inception in the first century until 1095, when Pope Urban II officially called Christians together to fight in the first Crusade, changed drastically according to Thomas Madden (1). In the first hundred years after the death of Christ war was seen for only stately gain by the Roman state, which was persecuting Christians. However, the conversion of Emperor Constantine brought a union between the state and Christianity. War became a necessary tool, but due t...

... middle of paper ...

... I mentioned before, Osama bin Laden proclaimed his attack on the World Trade Center a holy war. While the world looked back and could not understand how this could be considered holy, if one were to look back they could see similarities between the Christian Crusades and the terrorist attacks. When I was looking for websites on just war theory of St. Augustine, nearly every single site I found had a discussion on whether the possible action by the United States in Iraq would be justified according to St. Augustine. Most declared that it would be justified based on the actions of Iraq over the past decade and our status as a world leader with an international council such as the United Nations. It is nice to know that the information from the Crusades can help us now, but I prefer knowing that the Christian church has not repeated its action in the past 500 years.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Wars of Religion

- Politics and religion in the world of today aren’t subjects that generally go hand in hand in our own society. This was not always the case however; in Europe the two were synonymous up until relatively recently, (recently meant in the loosest sense of the word,) and are still closely tied in foreign parts of the world, the most obvious example being the Middle East. The duos intimate relationship was exemplified during the late sixteenth century, extending into the seventeenth century, during a series of wars which would later on come to be called “the wars of religion.” But is this title completely appropriate....   [tags: Role of Politics]

Powerful Essays
1267 words (3.6 pages)

Muslims And Muslims : The Holy Bible Essay

- ... In fact, Ibn Munqidh 's uncle prioritized a Christian doctor to help the lord of al-Munaytirah. This story raises an important question, if the holy wars were truly between Muslims and Christians, why did the Christian doctor criticize another Christian doctor in front of Muslims. This shows that the holy wars were more between Europeans and Arabs including Christian Arabs. However, ibn-Munqidh ignored this fact and he condemned the ideologies of Christianity, which is shown is the third story that he wrote....   [tags: Islam, Muhammad, Qur'an, Jesus]

Powerful Essays
1134 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about The Peace Of Augsburg, By Charles V, Emperor Of The Holy Roman Empire

- As Charles V, Emperor of the Holy Roman Empire, lifted his quill and signed the Peace of Augsburg, he hoped to solve the great religious tensions of his region; little did he know it was this very document that would lead to one of the longest and most devastating wars in European history. The Peace of Augsburg (1555) may have solved the immediate conflicts, but it did little to resolve the underlying problem. Within 60 years, a new religious war would break out, forever changing religion 's role in politics....   [tags: Thirty Years' War, Holy Roman Empire]

Powerful Essays
1863 words (5.3 pages)

The Holy Roman Empire Essay

- ... However, through that process, the theology slightly changed as it spread to different regions. Also, since several kings and emperors declared Christianity as the empire’s faith, officials and teachers began to philosophize with a Christian viewpoint. The change from a polytheistic opinion to a Christian standpoint vastly changed the ways rulers and common people would treat each other. Throughout the Middle Ages, Christian theology changed as military and government advancements were made and it resulted in a better opportunity for the spread of Christian Religion....   [tags: Christianity, Pope, Middle Ages, Christendom]

Powerful Essays
890 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on Were the Crusades Just Wars?

- Wars are started due to different beliefs whether it is religion, ethics, etc. The Crusades were a series of “Holy Wars”. Prior to the Crusades, in 1009 the Arabs rule Jerusalem, a sacred site to both Christians and Muslims. At the same time, El Hakim ordered the burning of the Holy Sepulcher. This brought mistrust with the Muslims. In 1054 the Church split into the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox. Sixteen years later, the Turks conquered Jerusalem and started to attack the Byzantine Empire....   [tags: World History, War, Muslims]

Powerful Essays
1123 words (3.2 pages)

God's Wars? Essay

- Religious wars, especially in the centuries following the rise of empires, were quite common in the Western Europe and northern Middle East regions. The Crusades are known to most as some of the bloodiest and most widespread religious wars of all time, yet the reasons behind, misconceptions about, and possible consequences of the Crusades are still being researched by many historians today, and even show quite outstanding parallels to current religions conflicts. The Crusades, “military campaigns sanctioned by the Latin Catholic Church during the high middle ages to restore Christian access to Holy places in and near Jerusalem” (The Crusades 1) were fought mainly between Christians and Musl...   [tags: religious war, middle east regions, crusades]

Powerful Essays
1080 words (3.1 pages)

The Italian Wars Essay

- The Italian Wars The Italian Wars 1494-1559: - Introduction: The key issues over which the Italian Wars were fought were primarily financial incentives for Charles VIII of France. He declared that he intended to use Naples as a base to drive the Ottomans out of Europe and liberate Constantinople. In actual truth his main motivation was self-glory and the mouth-watering prospect of acquiring some exquisite prizes of war. On the way he would acquire rich cities and portable pieces of art. It seems that this invasion had been planned for two years prior since Charles had already bought off potential rivals like Henry VII of England, Ferdinand and Macsimilion....   [tags: history]

Free Essays
1757 words (5 pages)

Essay on The European Religious Wars

- When one looks at the religious wars, it is very difficult to identify a beginning and middle. People can argue that the seed for the wars was planted in the wars between the Calvinists and Hapsburgs, otherwise known as the Dutch and the Spanish. In addition, people can argue that the Protestant Reformation in Germany and other parts of Europe sparked these “religious” wars. It was inevitable that the growing division between Christian churches in Europe would lead to a series of armed conflicts for over a century....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
950 words (2.7 pages)

Timeline of Wars and Reasons for Wars Essay

- Timeline of wars/Reasons for Wars Trojan War c. 1200 BC lasted for approx. 9 years Greeks vs. people of Troy Trojan prince Paris abducted Helen, wife of Menelaus of Sparta. The Spartans refused to return Helen to Sparta so Menelaus persuaded his brother Agamemnon to lead an army against Troy. They fought for nine years but never were able to defeat he main city. The Greeks then built a large wooden horse in which warriors were hidden inside. The Greeks appeared to leave and the horse was left at the front gates of the city....   [tags: History Essays]

Free Essays
2075 words (5.9 pages)

Religious Wars Essay

- Religious Wars Religion has played a key role in wars and death. Religion is the basis of belief for humans, it is a belief that there is a higher being that watches over us guiding us, a belief that there is life after death and if we follow these beliefs we shall enter heaven the most beautiful place. However religion has also played a role in wars, religious conflicts in Ireland (Protestants and Catholics). Israelis and Arabs (Holy Land) and the Holy Crusades of the eleventh century (recapturing the Holy Land)....   [tags: history]

Powerful Essays
1121 words (3.2 pages)