Procedures of American Criminal Trial Essay

Procedures of American Criminal Trial Essay

Length: 2653 words (7.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Procedures of American Criminal Trial

One of the most vaguely understood events in the United States is the modern criminal trial. Most people have a faint knowledge of the goings-on of criminal proceedings, mainly due to what is seen on television, but the person who knows the real course of a trial is rare. However, there is nothing mysterious about the events that determine criminal guilt. Trials are carefully orchestrated, following procedures that have been laid in legal concrete over the years, and generally follow the same basic format across the United States.

Criminal law is distinguishable from civil law in the aspect that criminal acts are officially considered to injure not only individuals, but society as a whole. This is the reason why criminal cases are described as state v. offender. The state, as the injured party, is taking the defendant to court. The purpose of a criminal trial is to determine if the offender is legally guilty of the crime, but this does not necessarily mean that the person in question committed the crime. As opposed to factual guilt (the person ‘did it’), legal guilt merely means that a jury of the defendant’s peers is convinced without reasonable doubt. As can be seen, this leaves room for possible discrepancies.

Before a trial can proceed, certain events must take place. The first is the arraignment of the defendant, which can happen anytime between arrest and a logical, non-specific time before the trial itself. Arraignment consists of the court reading to the defendant the substance of the charge, and calls on the subject to enter a plea within a given time.

The defendant may consult with and be advised by an attorney on what plea to offer the court. He may plead guilty or no...


... middle of paper ...


...e and money involved, which is sometimes quite substantial, is wasted. But a verdict is reached successfully 99 percent of the time. The jury, led by the foreman, gives the verdict to the judge in open court. If the verdict is guilty, the defense attorney may choose to ‘poll the jury.’ He asks each juror his personal opinion, and in a few cases, a juror’s doubts re-emerge to cancel the verdict. This rarely happens, but if it does the result is a victory for the defense.

A criminal trial is a complicated but closely choreographed event. Almost nothing happens without proper precedent, and even the most factually guilty defendant can be sure of having at least a small chance of getting “off the hook.” The unbiased trial is a constitutional institution that may not always make sense to the average person, but that reflects the value of justice in American society.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Courtroom Procedures and the Role of the Prosecution Essay

- During a trial, there are many rules, procedures, and codes of conduct that must be observed. These are in place to allow a trial to proceed more efficiently and fairly for both the defense and prosecution. According to one author, “Police, prosecutors, and criminal court Judges see too much crime, so they tend to see crime everywhere. We need rules to control their conduct, Judges to carefully apply those rules, and other Judges to review those decisions (law-article.net).” Courtroom procedures are important because, without them, defendants and prosecution alike could be treated unfairly....   [tags: police, prosecutors, criminals]

Powerful Essays
922 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Comparing the Criminal Justice Systems of the US, UK and Japan

- The criminal justice systems vary in each country as far as their policies and procedures go. Each aspect of the criminal justice system has its advantages and disadvantages. The main purpose of the criminal justice system is to sanction criminals, mitigate crime, increase security and uphold a fair system of justice. In some cultures, fairness is not always given as certain laws are expected to be honored. This paper will discuss the criminal justice system in the United States, England and Japan....   [tags: policies and procedures, components]

Powerful Essays
2408 words (6.9 pages)

The Stages Of A Jury Trial Essay

- The stages of a Jury Trial The stages of a jury trial are of immense importance in any line of law enforcement. The moments spent in the court room decide whether or not it is justifiable to strip a suspect of the rights he has been guaranteed his entire life. Because if the prosecution can prove, without any reasonable doubt, that the suspect is indeed the individual responsible for the crime being investigated, the jury will move to convict; thus diminishing the suspect’s rights promised in the constitution....   [tags: United States Constitution]

Powerful Essays
1924 words (5.5 pages)

The Fourth Amendment in Criminal Procedure Essay

- ... The search happened because of the arrest warrant not because of the illegal traffic stop. If Frierson had been pulled over and not had an arrest warrant for him then the search would have never happened and he would have left with no issue. However since he did have an arrest warrant on file and it had to be served upon discovery and the gun was then found because of a search incident to arrest as mentioned above. Another example a lot that was use to help make the ruling more sound was that police will often canvas high crime neighborhoods and ask random people for their I.D....   [tags: right to privacy]

Powerful Essays
1504 words (4.3 pages)

Forensic Science And The Criminal Justice System Essay

- Forensics experts have made many mistakes regarding handling and analyzing evidence. This has led to people being wrongly convicted. Ray Krone was one of those who was wrongly convicted because of mistakes in the forensic laboratory. There have been experts such as Jacqueline Blake, who broke protocol regarding evidence that led to wrongful convictions. It is important to learn how and why this happens to better prepare those in the criminal justice field to handle such situations and try to minimize the amount of errors in forensics....   [tags: Crime, Federal Bureau of Investigation]

Powerful Essays
1170 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on The Institution of Plea Bargaining

- The institution of plea bargaining appeared for the first time in the United States of America, in the early twentieth century, for pragmatic reasons - to facilitate the work of courts. Criminal hearings started to become long and tedious, especially since the late nineteenth century. Given the circumstances, practitioners could not resolve all cases through a "full trial", ie a process in front of jurors, and so they started to look for alternative solutions. The institution of plea-bargaining of has raised many controversies all over the world where was implemented, (in Italy is known as pattegiamento and is France is called plaider-coupable) the most heated ones can be found in the U.S.,...   [tags: criminal hearings, american jurisprudence]

Powerful Essays
1144 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on The Rights Of The Us Constitution

- The right to a trilby jury is one of the main freedoms guaranteed in the Bill of Rights of the US Constitution. In criminal cases, a jury of twelve citizens decides the guilt of the person being accused. The government cannot take someone’s right to life, liberty, or property until those twelve citizens are convinced of the accused person’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. In civil cases, the jury represents common sense and the community’s conscience when resolving disputes. The story of the jury, from its origins to its role in the modern justice system, reflects the movement toward self-governance....   [tags: Jury, United States Constitution, Law, Jury trial]

Powerful Essays
1254 words (3.6 pages)

Procedures in the Criminal Justice System Essay

- “The criminal process is part of the State’s response to crime, part of the mechanism which the State applies substantive criminal law to its citizens”. (Ashworth & Redmayne, 2005, p.2) Within this essay, I will be looking at the procedures in the Criminal Justice System. Before laying the foundations of this work, I will briefly dedicate a few lines on what the Criminal Justice System is about. A Criminal Justice System is a set of legal and social establishments for carrying out the criminal law in agreement with a definite set of procedural regulations and restrictions....   [tags: Criminal Justice ]

Powerful Essays
1038 words (3 pages)

The Legal System Of The Criminal Trial Process Essays

- The law balances the rights of victims, offenders and society to a certain extent in the criminal trial process. Mechanisms such as the use of evidence and witnesses, charge negotiations and juries are ways in which the legal system attempts to balance the rights of victims, offenders and society in the criminal trial process. Whilst they are effective in balancing rights, there are limitations to these mechanisms such as false witness statements, pressure to agree with charge negotiations and issues of bias with juries....   [tags: Jury, Jury trial, Law, Trial]

Powerful Essays
1178 words (3.4 pages)

Perfect Evidence Essay

- Perfect Evidence is an episode of the weekly radio program This American Life focusing on the theme of DNA evidence. The program starts out with the story of four innocent teenagers who served fifteen years in prison for murder and concludes by recounting how legal police procedures manipulated a fourteen-year-old into falsely confessing to the murder of his sister. In both cases, the introduction of DNA evidence years later proved the innocence of all wrongfully convicted parties. In 1986 police arrested four teenagers, Larry Ollins, Omar Saunders, and cousins Marcellius and Calvin Bradford, in connection with the rape and murder of Lori Roscetti....   [tags: Criminal Justice]

Powerful Essays
1291 words (3.7 pages)