Merchant of Venice Essay: Refuting the Critics

Merchant of Venice Essay: Refuting the Critics

Length: 837 words (2.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


In The Jew of Venice, Granville takes up and refutes the principal "subversions,"

in The Merchant of Venice that modern and postmodern critics have imposed

upon on the play.  Without its’ alleged contradictions, the play has a tight formalist

structural unity, it focuses on an essentialist Platonic idea, and, resolving all

conflicts, it ends in closure. 

            On the topic of Antonio's sadness, Granville picks up a clue that to my

knowledge no modern critic has noticed.  In his "methodizing" process, he

moved Antonio's play-opening line--"I know not why I am so sad"--to Bassan-

io's feast, between the toasts and the masque, and merged it with Jessica's

fifth act misgiving--"I am never merry when I hear sweet music" (5.1.69).

Listening to the music at his friend's feast, Granville's Antonio laments,

 

                                   O Bassanio!

          There sits a heaviness upon my heart

          Which wine cannot remove:  I know not

          But music ever makes me thus. (2.2.35-38)

 

Lorenzo's comforting answer to Jessica in act 5 of Shakespeare's play then

becomes Bassanio's comforting answer to Antonio act 2 of Granville's:

          The reason is, your spirits are attentive:

    &nb...


... middle of paper ...


... spoils."

            In The Jew of Venice, Granville, who resides in Shakespeare's own moral

community, takes up and refutes the principal "subversions," "leaks,"

"interrogations," and "dark shadows" in The Merchant of Venice that modern

and postmodern critics, working from what I argue are irrelevant post-

capitalist prejudices, have imposed upon on the play.  Without its’ alleged

contradictions, the play has a tight formalist structural unity, it focuses

on an essentialist Platonic idea, and, resolving all conflicts, it ends in

closure.  Unless there are other reasons than those commonly given for

alleging that The Merchant of Venice is "multivalent and "plural" in meaning,

we will have to assume, for the time being at least, that it isn't.

 

 

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Merchant Of Venice By William Shakespeare

- William Shakespeare printed the Merchant of Venice in 1590, it can be said to be one of his most contentious dramas ever written. The Merchant of Venice is an Elizabethan comedy play. The play was based in Venice, which is located in northern Italy. Venice in these days was known for its “wealth, political wisdom, impartial justice and liberalism (Halio, 2000,p.23). This essay will discuss the following themes Usury, Male Friendship, Marriage (in reference to the role of the woman), Mercy and Justice and Judaism....   [tags: The Merchant of Venice, Shylock, Renaissance]

Better Essays
1355 words (3.9 pages)

Religion in The Merchant of Venice Essay

- Religion was a major factor in a number of Shakespeare’s plays. Religion motivated action and reasoning. In Shakespeare’s “The Merchant of Venice,” religion was more than a belief in a higher being; it reflected moral standards and ways of living. In the “Merchant of Venice,” “a Christian ethic of generosity, love, and risk-taking friendship is set in pointed contrast with a non-Christian ethic that is seen, from a Christian point of view, as grudging, resentful, and self-calculating.” (Bevington, pg....   [tags: Merchant of Venice Essays]

Better Essays
1944 words (5.6 pages)

Shylock in Merchant of Venice Essay

- The Character of Shylock in Merchant of Venice        Few characters created by Shakespeare embodies pure evil like the character of Shylock in The Merchant of Venice. Shylock is a usurer and a malevolent, blood-thirsty old man consumed with plotting the downfall of his enemies. He is a malignant, vengeful character, consumed with venomous malice1; a picture of callous, unmitigated villainy, deaf to every appeal of humanity2. Shylock is the antagonist opposite the naive, essentially good Antonio, the protagonist; who must defend himself against the "devil" Shylock....   [tags: Merchant Venice Essays]

Free Essays
1694 words (4.8 pages)

The Merchant of Venice Essay

- "The Merchant of Venice" by WIlliam Shakespeare. "The Merchant of Venice" is a play about revenge, justice, deseption and friendship. The story is about, Shylock a wealth Jew, lending one of his enemies, Antonoi, three thousand ducats. Although Antonio is a rich merchant all his resources are in his ships, trading too distant countries, but because he wants to help out his friend, Bassanio, he has no choice but to ask Shylock for a loan , not to know it could lead to his death. In this play there is a big difference between the Christian charaters and Shylock, the main difference being Shylock seems to be more interested in his money and business rather than human relationships, which the C...   [tags: Free Merchant of Venice Essays]

Free Essays
471 words (1.3 pages)

The Merchant Of Venice Essay

- What They Cannot See In this world, there are many aspects of blindness whether it is mentally or physically. Either way, each blindness brings out the disability in each person. Such portrayal was shown throughout the play The Merchant of Venice. Shakespeare presents more than one form of blindness, which complicates the social order of the society, and I feel that the blindness, being their imperfection, creates tension between characters, which is weakened by blindness. When the characters are being blind, they are corrupted by their actions and somehow they do not care who they are hurting as long as they know they are getting the best out of something....   [tags: Free Merchant of Venice Essays]

Free Essays
2455 words (7 pages)

The Merchant Of Venice Essay

- When William Shakespear wrote, The merchant Of Venice, he made a female character that has a huge influence on the play. In most of his work, the women don’t have much power and are not very smart. In the Merchant Of Venice, Portia is a woman that saves the life of a man using her head. Another woman created by Shakespear that is a lot alike with Portia is Beatrice, from Much Ado about Nothing. Both of these ladies add to the main theme of the plays because of their brains, and smart remarks, as well as being careing....   [tags: Free Merchant of Venice Essays]

Free Essays
1041 words (3 pages)

Essay merchant of venice

- The Merchant of Venice The play, ¡°The Merchant of Venice¡± by William Shakespeare has two main settings. One setting is Venice, a city where many businessmen live, a place, full of unhappy and unkind people. It a world of commercial and law. Shakespeare has portrayed Venice as the ¡°real¡± world. The other setting is Belmont, a city which houses a rich, happy society of beautiful people. Belmont is a fairy-tale world of music and love. In this play, it is evident that, good things happen in Belmont and not so pleasant events happen in Venice....   [tags: Merchant of Venice Essays]

Better Essays
1384 words (4 pages)

Essay Merchant Of Venice

- The Storytellers in The Merchant of Venice In this play two characters have a bigger role than one might imagine. Salerio and Solanio are the storytellers in The Merchant of Venice. They fill in important information that the audience needs to full understand the play. First, the two names differ by only a few letters, they are so close that one might confuse the two and think that they are the same person. I feel that this is Shakespeare's intention in this play. He makes the two similar so that they are not very important to the plot of the play....   [tags: Free Merchant of Venice Essays]

Free Essays
592 words (1.7 pages)

Merchant of Venice Essays

- Antonio, a Venetian merchant, complains of melancholy; his friend Bassanio asks for a loan to travel to Belmont to court the beautiful heiress, Portia. Antonio agrees, but says that he must borrow the money from one of the city's moneylenders because all of his ships are at sea. At Belmont, Portia is also melancholy because, according to the terms of her father's will, she must marry the man who chooses the casket (out of a choice of gold, silver or lead) containing her portrait. If he chooses wrongly, he is condemned to remain unmarried forever....   [tags: Free Merchant of Venice Essays]

Free Essays
498 words (1.4 pages)

Merchant of Venice Essay examples

- Mercy v. Justice – Old Testament v. New Testament While the conflict between justice and mercy plays a key role in determining the outcome of The Merchant of Venice, this conflict is even more important because it provides a setting for the contrast between the rigid law and rules of the Old Testament and the concepts of mercy and forgiveness as taught by Christ in the New Testament. It is in the climactic trial scene that The Duke, hoping Shylock will excuse Antonio's penalty, asks him, “How shall thou hope for mercy rend'ring none?” He is referring to expectations of judgment in the afterlife....   [tags: Merchant of Venice Essays]

Better Essays
1334 words (3.8 pages)