Comparing Katharina, of The Taming of the Shrew and Beatrice of Much Ado About Nothing

Comparing Katharina, of The Taming of the Shrew and Beatrice of Much Ado About Nothing

Length: 1324 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparing Shakespeare’s Katharina, of The Taming of the Shrew and Beatrice, of Much Ado About Nothing


Shakespeare’s Katharina, of The Taming of the Shrew and Beatrice, of Much Ado About Nothing, are very similar characters.  Each is plagued with unrequited love, and depressed by their inability to woo the suitor of their choosing.  Neither will accept the passive female role expected by society. Yet, both women seem to accept their role as wife by the conclusion.  Upon further examination, one will find that Beatrice is a much more complex character.  One would have to agree with the critic who said, "Katharina is a character sketched in bold, rapid stokes, with none of Beatrice's sophistication, verbal brilliance, or emotional depth." 

In Taming of the Shrew, the first introduction to Katharina, by Gremio and Hortensio, tells that she is a shrew, (1.I .54-60) and that she will never find a groom.  When she first speaks we see her responding to these insults, but she was provoked so her words seem appropriate.  Yet as the play continues we see Katharina tying up Bianca, (2.I.29) and hitting her.  This can be rejected as sibling rivalry, but later Katharina slaps Petruchio when he is trying to woo her (2.I.214). Katharina seems to have a physically violent side that isn't present in Beatrice.  She also does not seem to have as strong as a character as Beatrice, especially when one considers that Petruchio was able to tame her in a very short time.

In the opening scene of Much Ado About Nothing,  Beatrice says some harsh things about Benedick (1.I.37-43).  She seems to be unprovoked but very rigid in her opinion of him.  In Leonato's house, the discussion of Beatrice and marriage leads her uncle to conclude that, "Thou...


... middle of paper ...


...y is important.  But the most important thing to note is that the weaker of the two did change her attitudes, beliefs and actions in order to become a better wife for her husband.  Both women seem to be happy as do the men and like most conclusions of Shakespeare's plays, all the loose ends are tied up.

Works Cited and Consulted

Barton, Anne. Introduction. Much Ado About Nothing. The Riverside Shakespeare, 2nd ed. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co., 1997. 361-365.

Dash, Irene G. "Wooing, Wedding, and Power: Women in Shakespeare Plays". The Critical Perspective Volume 2. Ed. Harold Bloom. New York: Chelsea House Publishers, 1986. 825-833.

Shakespeare, William. The Taming of the Shrew. Logan, IA: The Perfection Form Company, 1996.

Shakespeare, William; Much Ado About Nothing; Washington Square Press; New York, NY; New Folger Edition May 1995

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Benedick and Beatrice's Love in Much Ado About Nothing Essay

- Entry 1: Act I: Don Pedro and his men return from the war and visit the house of Leonato and his brother, Antonio. This sudden meeting reunites Beatrice with her archrival, Benedick, and it is here that Claudio and Hero fall in love. React: In Shakespeare’s Much Ado about Nothing, there are the usual characters that show up in most of Shakespeare’s pieces. For instance the characters Hero and Claudio could easily be compared to Romeo and Juliet. Both Hero and Juliet are innocent, quite, and beautiful young women who fall in love instantly without conversing with the other person....   [tags: Much Ado About Nothing Essays]

Strong Essays
1362 words (3.9 pages)

Differences between Beatrice and Hero in Much Ado about Nothing Essay

- Differences between Beatrice and Hero in the early scenes of Shakespeare’s play ‘Much Ado about Nothing’ Shakespeare’s play ‘Much Ado about Nothing’ has two main female characters, Beatrice and Hero, who are cousins. Both appear to be completely different in the beginning of the play but, as things progress and their characters develop, there are also some very obvious similarities between them. Hero and Beatrice have a very close relationship; they are best friends. Leonato is Hero’s father but Beatrice has no parents, which gives her greater freedom....   [tags: Much Ado about Nothing Shakespeare]

Strong Essays
1199 words (3.4 pages)

Much Ado About Nothing: Beatrice, Portia and Marriage Essays

- Much Ado About Nothing: Beatrice, Portia and Marriage Hero and Claudio represent the Elizabethan norm in marriage. Claudio is the shrewd, hardheaded fortune hunter and Hero is the modest maiden of conduct books and marriage manuals, a docile young woman. It is important to note that Claudio is more concerned with advancement in Don Pedro's army than he is with love. Therefore, Shakespeare illustrates to the reader through the near tragedy of mistaken identity that Claudio must learn that marriage is more than a business arrangement and become worthy of Hero's love and affection....   [tags: Much Ado About Nothing Essays]

Free Essays
525 words (1.5 pages)

Much Ado About Nothing Essay: Beatrice, Benedick, and Love

- Beatrice, Benedick, and Love in Much Ado About Nothing William Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing  is set in thirteenth century Italy.  The plot of the play can be categorized as comedy or tragicomedy .    Villainy and scheming combine with humor and sparkling wordplay in Shakespeare's comedy of manners. Claudio is deceived into believing that Hero, is unfaithful. Meanwhile, Benedick and Beatrice have "a kind of merry war" between them, matching wits in repartee.  This paper will attempt to present the fact that Beatrice and Benedick are in love during the entire play despite their witty rivalries.  Their friends' schemes lead each to think that the other is in love, which allows the tr...   [tags: Much Ado About Nothing Essays]

Strong Essays
892 words (2.5 pages)

Comparing and Contrasting the Relationships of Beatrice and Benedick, and Hero and Claudio in Much Ado About Nothing

- In Shakespeare’s play, Much Ado About Nothing, written in the early 15th century, the relationships between Benedick and Beatrice and Hero and Claudio are the key to the play and create a lot of tension and comedy. The two relationships are interesting in different ways, and this essay will explore this in terms of the language used, the plot, characterisation and how the two relationships stand thematically. Beatrice and Benedick are interesting due to Shakespeare’s use of language. Confusion is created as to whether they love or hate each other owing to their snide comments, such as Beatrice’s response “A bird of my tongue is better than a beast of yours” (1.1.104), notably continuing the...   [tags: shakespeare, Analytical Essay]

Strong Essays
2111 words (6 pages)

How Does Shakespeare Introduce and Develop the Characters of Beatrice and Benedick?

- Much ado about nothing was written by William Shakespeare in 1595.It is about relationships, love, deceive and hatred. Benedick (one of the main character) enjoys speaking his mind in a witty argument with Hero’s cousin and companion, Beatrice. Beatrice is also like Benedick. She is an Elizabethan feminist who is strong; she speaks her mind and lets everyone (including Benedick) know exactly what she thinks of Benedick. Shakespeare has created another couple who is totally the opposite of Beatrice and Benedick....   [tags: Much Ado About Nothing play, character analysis]

Strong Essays
950 words (2.7 pages)

The Presentation of the Characters Beatrice and Hero in Much Ado About Nothing

- The Presentation of the Characters Beatrice and Hero in Much Ado About Nothing In this essay I’m comparing the characters Beatrice and Hero from Shakespeare’s play, ‘Much Ado about Nothing’. ‘Much Ado about Nothing’ is a comedy written by William Shakespeare c. 1598 – 1599. Shakespeare found the story in Orlando Furioso, which is a great poem written by Ludovico Ariosto, however Shakespeare did come up with the Benedick - Beatrice plot. The attention of the characters is aimed at Claudio and Hero and their young, romantic love and Benedick and Beatrice are the comedy pair in the play, their witty battles of words provides great comedy....   [tags: Free Essays]

Free Essays
400 words (1.1 pages)

The Character of Beatrice in Much Ado About Nothing Essay

- The Character of Beatrice in Much Ado About Nothing Many would believe this to be a understated summary of the way Shakespeare presents her character in Much Ado About Nothing because Beatrice is not just a humorous character but a strong role model for both ShakespeareÂ’s time and for a modern audience defying social expectations and being equal to her male counter parts, she is the heroin of the play and even though speaking “all mirth” which would probably be expected from a lead Shakespeare role, however she is much more that that....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1638 words (4.7 pages)

Essay about Beatrice and Hero in Much Ado About Nothing

- Beatrice and Hero in William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing Beatrice is a young, attractive woman, who lives to be an unconventional member of her community. She is technically a free woman as her father died when she was younger and she has no one to say to her no, or that’s enough, or in general tell her what to do. She lives her life as she wishes and is known as Lady Disdain by one of her fellow characters, Benedick. However, Hero is the complete opposite to her cousin Beatrice....   [tags: William Shakespeare]

Strong Essays
1365 words (3.9 pages)

A Comparison of Beatrice and Hero in Much Ado About Nothing Essay

- Compare/Contrast Essays - Comparison of Beatrice and Hero in Much Ado About Nothing In the play of `Much Ado About Nothing', Beatrice is portrayed as a witty and strong willed woman who talks a great deal, appearing determined not to marry. However, Don Pedro concocts a plot that brings her together with Benedick and they marry at the end. She was an orphan, the niece of Leonato. Her most obvious objective is to stay a lonely spinster. She has known Benedick for years and because he wants to be a bachelor their hate for the opposite sex clashes- until they fall in love that is....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
435 words (1.2 pages)