On January 23, 2003, the world’s leading computer networking equipment maker Cisco Systems, headquartered in San Jose California, filed a lawsuit against China-based Huawei Technologies and its United States subsidiaries Huawei America and FutureWei Technologies. In the lawsuit, Cisco alleged that Huawei stole intellectual property by copying its Internet Operating System (IOS) software and its copyrighted user manuals. Cisco also claimed that Huawei infringed on its patents. After numerous failed attempts to resolve these complaints directly with Huawei, which included a cease and desist letter to one of Huawei’s United Kingdom distributors, Cisco decided that a lawsuit was necessary to protect the company and its shareholder’s interests. The lawsuit was processed through United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas. This paper will provide an overview of this landmark case and discuss whether each company had a different view of ethics that originated from differing cultural perspectives.
I. Case Background
Cisco Systems’ 77 page complaint filed in the United States District Court for the Easter District of Texas demanded a trial by jury in response to Huawei’s misappropriation and intellectual property infringement in the development of its competing Quidway routers. One of Huawei’s United States based wholly-owned subsidiary, FutureWei, is located in Plano, Texas; the other subsidiary Huawei America is located in California’s Silicon Valley, nearby Cisco Systems’ headquarters. The China-based parent company is a multi-billion dollar corporation that has manufactured network and telecommunications equipment since 1988.
Huawei marketed its Quidway router...
... middle of paper ...
... “Huawei: Cisco Code is Gone,” April 15, 2003, http://www.lightreading.com/document.asp?doc_id=31253
 “Cisco Wins Huawei Injunction,” June 9, 2003, http://www.lightreading.com/document.asp?doc_id=35058
 “Managing in the Multicultural Environment”, Charis Intercultural Training Corporation, 2004.
 “Differences of Opinion: The Cisco-Huawei Lawsuit”, The Hoffman Agency, China High Tech PR Newsletter, http://www.chinahightechpr.com/fullArticle.cfm?code=284
 “WTO Ministerial Conference Approves China’s Accession”, November 10, 2001 Press Release, http://www.wto.org/english/news_e/pres01_e/pr252_e.htm
 The United States and China: Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) and Protection, http://usinfo.state.gov/regional/ea/iprcn/
 Baase, S.; A Gift of Fire, 2nd edition, Prentice Hall, 2003.
Flags obtained from http://www.enchantedlearning.com
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The purpose of this report is to explain the arguments for and against software piracy. Software piracy is a major problem, mainly to the businesses that develop and market software on a global scale. Software piracy is illegal copying or redistribution of software that doesn’t belong to you. Illegal copying of software is called piracy. You might be thinking, why does this affect me. Unfortunately, software piracy affects everyone because software piracy has an impact on the economy because revenue is lost when software is being pirated.... [tags: Market Software, Illegal, Piracy]
1227 words (3.5 pages)
- Software in the Land of Smiles (a study of software piracy in Thailand) 1.Overview Walk down the street in Thailand and amongst the numerous trinket vendors, you will find one that has catalog of software titles. The same catalogs can also be found at the major shopping malls at numerous retailers. Flip through the catalogs, choose your software titles, and pay around US$3. A runner will go retrieve your titles and, in about 5-10 minutes, you will have your new software. This is only a glimpse of the multi-million dollar world of software piracy and how accessible it has become in the land of smiles, Thailand.... [tags: Software Piracy Thailand Papers]
2483 words (7.1 pages)
- Software Piracy in Lebanon Abstract What is it about copying software that is desirable. Simply because it is free. In the United States, one might think twice before copying a Microsoft product. Copyright issues are all over the media --remember Napster. For a period of a year, we read countless stories of students all over the US and the world that were arrested for copying and trading MP3s. However, travel across the Atlantic to the chaotic world of Lebanon and one would not even think twice about copying a version of Microsoft Office 2000.... [tags: Software Piracy Expository Essays]
2297 words (6.6 pages)
- Software Piracy Software piracy is the copying and reselling of software without the consent of the software creator. It is the copying and reuse of software by large corporations. It is copying software and distributing it on the Web. A country with maybe the biggest software piracy problem is China. In 1994, software piracy was 97% in China.1 In 1999 the rate was still 91%. 2 Software piracy is a huge problem in China. Only Vietnam has a higher piracy rate than China. Stopping the software piracy problem in China will be very difficult.... [tags: China Software Piracy Papers]
2347 words (6.7 pages)
- Option B: Software Piracy (Page. 540, 10th Edition) The unauthorized copying of software programs, known as software piracy, is a large scale issue within the information technology industry both in the United States and abroad. Unauthorized copying is against the law since the type of software often copied is copyrighted, meaning it technically is the intellectual property of its creator, and thus a purchase is required by the end user in order to obtain a legal copy or “license” of such software.... [tags: Information Technology Industry, Piracy]
980 words (2.8 pages)
- Software Piracy and Copyright Laws: United States versus Vietnam I. Introduction "Software piracy is the unauthorized duplication, distribution or use of computer software". Five main types of software piracy exist: publisher patent and copyright infringement, industrial piracy, corporate piracy, reseller piracy, and home piracy. Software piracy is a large global issue, which has become a more pressing issue due to a number of reasons: software is now easier to distribute on a global scale due to global access to the internet; culturally, people have not been taught that copying software is like stealing; a physical component does not need to be manufactured; and finally individuals stat... [tags: Software Piracy Computers Essays]
2821 words (8.1 pages)
- Software Piracy Many people these days are guilty of being ‘software pirates’. They justify their actions by claiming they are stealing from the huge corporate company’s that are just out there to make a buck and don’t care about their customers. This viewpoint, however, overlooks the real fact that it is such actions that what is actually hurting customers and those who are law abiding citizens. “Software piracy is the unauthorized copying or distribution of copyrighted software. This can be done by copying, downloading, sharing, selling, or installing multiple copies onto personal or work computers.” (What is Software Piracy?) The whole idea behind software piracy is that you are purchas... [tags: Software Technology Illegal]
1865 words (5.3 pages)
- Software Piracy Software piracy is the illegal reproduction and distribution of software applications, whether it is for personal use or business. In society today, Internet users are obtaining millions of dollars in software illegally. Piracy includes the illegal copying of programs, counterfeiting and distributing software, and even sharing a program with a friend. Software has become such an important productivity tool, the illegal copying and distribution of software piracy persists globally.... [tags: Illegal Computer Software Program Distribution]
741 words (2.1 pages)
- Malaysian Piracy Industry Though it isn’t the largest or the most lucrative business of its type, the Malaysian software piracy industry is arguably the boldest and most blatant in the world. Despite international pressure, government crackdowns, and attempts by focus groups, the industry survives and flourishes to this day. The purpose of this examination is to reveal what keeps the pirates running, what is being done to curb them, and ethical issues involving the unauthorized duplication and distribution of copyrighted software products in Malaysia.... [tags: Piracy Software Ethics Computers Essays]
4804 words (13.7 pages)
- Software Piracy Software piracy is the copying and selling of copyrighted software. There are many types of software that can be pirated including operating systems, application programs, internet downloads, including music, software, or movies. Many people do this knowing that they are partaking in something illegal; however some people have no clue that they are breaking the law. In some cases a person may have inadvertently purchased pirated software. The consequences of having or distributing pirated software can be serious in some cases.... [tags: Computer Software Copyright Violation]
828 words (2.4 pages)