An ongoing debate: Should gay and lesbian couples be allowed to legally marry? In the opposing articles from Newsweek (June 3, 1996), Andrew Sullivan defends the rights of gay marriage in “Let Gays Marry” and William Bennett expresses the opposite view in “Leave Marriage Alone.” Sullivan is one of the editors for The New Republic and has also authored a book entitled Virtually Normal: An Argument about Homosexuality. [Gruber 25] Bennett is best known as the editor of The Book of Virtues and is also the co-director of Empower America. [Gruber 29] Obviously, both parties have had experience in the topics they discuss. Through both articles, the reader is shown both perspectives into the issue of allowing same sex marriage.
First, Sullivan’s argument is based on his beliefs that the gay population deserve the same rights as the rest of America, and that one of those rights is marriage to a significant other. He says they are just like everyone else with the same hopes and dreams. He acknowledges that he’s not asking anyone to change religious doctrine and that it won’t change the way marriage will be practiced in the least bit. In contrast, Bennett’s counter argument shows all the reasons why changing what we have now, marriage between man and wife only, would be bad. He believes that allowing same sex marriages will ruin all that marriage is about in the first place. Marriage began as an institution between man and wife, and he believes that should not change.
Andrew Sullivan bases most of his argument on the logic of the situation, with some emotions in there as well. To him, allowing marriage between a same sex partnership makes just as much sense as a he...
... middle of paper ...
No matter what happens in the future, there will probably be no pleasing both parties. I personally hope to never see the day that marriage will be twisted and distorted to the point that it doesn’t mean what it should: “an honorable estate, instituted of God and built on moral, religious, sexual, and human realities” (Bennett 30). In conclusion, Bennett and Sullivan both present firm arguments, and if I didn’t already have my opinion grounded, I’m not sure which way I’d be swayed. All Americans do deserve the same rights, no matter their personal preferences or circumstances. On the other side, the rest of the American public shouldn’t have to give up something as important as the institution of marriage between man and woman to achieve this. It’s sad that this is even an issue, but I guess that’s something you have to face in the reality of things.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Should Same Sex Marriages Be Allowed. An ongoing debate: Should gay and lesbian couples be allowed to legally marry. In the opposing articles from Newsweek (June 3, 1996), Andrew Sullivan defends the rights of gay marriage in “Let Gays Marry” and William Bennett expresses the opposite view in “Leave Marriage Alone.” Sullivan is one of the editors for The New Republic and has also authored a book entitled Virtually Normal: An Argument about Homosexuality. [Gruber 25] Bennett is best known as the editor of The Book of Virtues and is also the co-director of Empower America.... [tags: Marriages Homosexuality Essays]
1165 words (3.3 pages)
- Same-Sex Marriages/Relationships Introduction Homosexuality is considered to be a sexual attraction between the members of the same gender. With the recent growth of homosexual relationships, this phenomenon is widely debated everywhere. As for this essay, it argues that that same-sex marriage should be supported as well as legalized due to the number of individual, social and moral challenges that are likely to lead to traumatic effects when disregarding the relationships of the abovementioned category of people.... [tags: Same-sex marriage, Homosexuality]
1768 words (5.1 pages)
- Same-sex marriages are stirring vigorous, occasionally strident, and sometimes downright hostile debates. It touches upon deep human longings and convictions. It affects individuals and families. Secondly, the controversy surrounding same-sex marriages is likely to prevail for a long time. For instance, liberal theorists argue that condemning marriages for same-sex couples is not compatible with some constitutive commitment to liberalism. In the emphasis, it violates the commitment to freedom to attaining equality, and particularly regarding rights of association and privacy.... [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage, Civil union, Rights]
1383 words (4 pages)
- One of the biggest controversies of our generation is same-sex marriage. It’s been on the front of media, plastered across thousands of newspapers, and even been heavily discussed at family dinner tables all across America. The dynamic of marriages going beyond that of man and women have been both praised and condemned. Since the beginning of civilization, same-sex relationships and marriages have been common practice. The Roman Empire was not hesitant toward same-sex relationships, and there was a broad approval of homosexuality and bisexuality among the Roman citizens.... [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage, Bill Clinton]
1690 words (4.8 pages)
- Marriage is a term that relates to the union of two people, a man and a woman together. According to Encyclopedia Britannica, the definition of same sex marriage is “the practice of marriage between two men or between two women.” There is a total of nineteen countries worldwide that have legalized Same Sex Marriages including Canada, Argentina, South Africa, etc. Every one in twenty people are gay. According to statistics, sixty percent of women and fifty three percent of men support same sex marriages.... [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage, Homosexuality, LGBT]
1139 words (3.3 pages)
- The idea of same-sex marriage has been a controversial topic for many years especially in the past couple of months. The Fight between what is Constitutional and what is not and where the Federal government has the right to interfere in state laws has caused major problems within our country. Media, Human rights, and opinions of the people are just some of the reasons this topic has gotten so much attention this past year. The legal definition of “Marriage” and who has the ability to determine that within the government has caused problems The question of whether people have the same rights, no matter their sexual orientation, including the right to marriage has been a controversial topic th... [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage, Homosexuality, Law]
1362 words (3.9 pages)
- Same-sex marriage is something that is not currently accepted by most of society, especially in Catholics, Christians and others. In the decade of 1970 begin to emerge in the United States marriages of the same sex. Today there are many views, which are analyzed on same-sex marriage. It has been considered through the impact it could have on children, in religions as well as in the freedom and equality in society. Today there are many studies which show that children of same-sex families are healthier and have better care than children of different- sex marriages.... [tags: Same-sex marriage, Homosexuality, Marriage]
730 words (2.1 pages)
- An issue which has been a topic of heated debate is whether same-sex marriage should be legal. Recently, the United States took a step forward and same-sex marriages became legal in all fifty states. However, there are numerous countries which currently prohibit same-sex marriage. People of the same gender must be able to marry because marriages could help boost economies, people should have the choice of marrying whoever, and countries should take into consideration laws that provide equal rights.... [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage, United States]
1298 words (3.7 pages)
- Same-sex marriage became legal in the United States of America on June 26, 2015. This meant that in all states, men were allowed to marry men, women were allowed women, and women and men could marry each other. Although some states had allowed civil unions and some offered legal marriages, these marriages were not recognized throughout the country as a whole. The civil unions that often resulted did not grant the couple the same legal rights as a typical man and woman would have if they got married at the same time.... [tags: Marriage, Same-sex marriage, Race, Miscegenation]
1405 words (4 pages)
- Same-sex marriage is considered by many people as something unnatural, bad and wrong. When you really think about it though, what is so unnatural, bad or wrong about it. Just because it goes against the ‘social norms’ does not necessarily mean it is wrong; it’s just different. There is not much that separates homosexual relationships and heterosexual relationships, except for the debate on who should be allowed to marry who because it is okay for a man and a woman to get married, but some believe that it is not okay for two men, or two women to get married.... [tags: Same-sex marriage, Homosexuality, Marriage]
1247 words (3.6 pages)