Massachusetts Legislature Votes to Ban Same-Sex Marriages but Approves of Civil Unions

Massachusetts Legislature Votes to Ban Same-Sex Marriages but Approves of Civil Unions

Length: 1902 words (5.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Massachusetts Legislature Votes to Ban Same-Sex Marriages but Approves of Civil Unions

As supporters and opponents were anxiously awaiting for a decision on Mar. 29, the Massachusetts legislature voted 105-92 to ban gay marriage when it approved of amending the state constitution that would overturn the Supreme Judicial Court’s ruling that made same-sex marriages legal five months ago. However, the legislature also voted to legalize civil unions.

The amendment was altered from when it was introduced this month, and now says that aside from permitting civil unions but banning gay marriage, it would clarify that gay couples who marry into civil unions would not receive any federal marriage rights and benefits. It cannot be changed again if lawmakers want it to continue onto the Nov. 2006 ballot.

Gov. Mitt Romney asked the court to deter same-sex marriages until voters can make a final decision in Nov. 2006. Attorney General Thomas F. Reilly told the Boston Globe that since Gov. Romney lacked, “a valid legal basis for stay, because the SJC has ruled twice in favor of gay marriage,” he would not take Romney’s request to the state Supreme Court.

It has not been decided what will happen to couples that marry between May 17 and Nov. 2006. According to the Boston Globe, a Mar. 2004 poll indicated 53 percent of Massachusetts residents opposed gay marriage while 60 percent supported civil unions. Also, 71 percent of the surveyed individuals feel voters should be able to define marriage, not the courts or the legislature.

“You vote on whether or not you want things like highway taxes,” says Valerie Fein-Zachary, who sees this as a civil rights issue, not a voting issue. “It should not be determined by the popular vote of the...

... middle of paper ...

...ture, making it difficult for all minorities to achieve equality. Hopefully, with all of the international progress currently taking place in Europe, some time in the near future same-sex couples will be able to have the same rights as heterosexual couples.

Works Cited

“Human Rights Watch: Allow Gay Marriage.” (2003, September 5). Retrieved October 20, 2003 from the World Wide Web: (

Klein, Rick. (2004, March 30). “Vote Ties Civil Unions to Gay-Marriage Ban; Romney to Seek Stay of SJC Order.” Boston Globe. p. A1

“Rabbis To Okay Gay Marriages: It's a 'Done Deal'.” (1999, December 24). The Forward, (31), 268, 1.

Reston, Maeve. Wednesday, November 19, 2003. “Victory For Gay Couples In Mass.; Same-Sex Marriages Ok'd By Highest Court.” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

Ryan-Vollmar, S. and Chuck, E. (2003, June 27). Boston Phoenix. p. 20-22.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Civil Unions and Same-Sex Marriages Essay

- The idea that same same-sex relationships in marriage are mandated by society is hard to fathom, even in today’s society. To understand the depth and meaning of this one must look at all aspects. The political and religious stance on the subject takes in no consideration of the individuals seeking the change. For years these people have fought in and out of court for the same rights as everyone else. At the same time they are denied these basic rights in many states. They are fighting for their rights....   [tags: Homosexuality, argumentative, persuasive]

Term Papers
1028 words (2.9 pages)

The Ban on Gay Blood Donors Essay

- In 1983 the FDA put a ban on gay men from donating blood if they have had sex with another man since 1977 (Thrasher). Certain activists believe this ban is harsh and should be repealed. While it would be great if everyone in the country could donate blood, gay men are at higher risk for certain diseases such as HIV/AIDS. This increased risk makes it unwise to eliminate this ban. As stated by Mark Skinner in his article Science Should Dictate Policy, “blood donor deferrals are not judgments about individuals but are scientifically based”....   [tags: blood, gay, ban, risk, policy]

Term Papers
558 words (1.6 pages)

The Right to Marry: Civil Unions and Same Sex Couples Essay

- The right to marry is something most people take for granted. The US Supreme court has even weighed in on this topic in their ruling for the 1974 case of Cleveland Board of Education v. LaFleur. They stated that the “freedom of personal choice in the matter of marriage and family life is one of the liberties protected by Due Process Clause (Gay). There is even nothing in the constitution that denies marriage to any group. So why will the government not recognize civil unions. Many people, including myself have family members and friends who are same-sex couples that would like to honor their relationship with one of the most sacred traditions, marriage (Gay)....   [tags: supreme court, divorce]

Term Papers
543 words (1.6 pages)

Michigans Gay Ban, Banned Essay

- In 2004, by a vote of 59% of the voters in Michigan with a turnout of 63%, Michigan Proposal 04-2 was ratified as an amendment to the Michigan State Constitution. It states, “To secure and preserve the benefits of marriage for our society and for future generations of children, the union of one man and one woman in marriage shall be the only agreement recognized as a marriage or similar union for any purpose.” In May of 2008 the Michigan Supreme Court ruled that it included not just marriage and civil unions, but from being able to get employee domestic partnership benefits including things like health insurance....   [tags: same-sex marriage, federal government]

Term Papers
1263 words (3.6 pages)

Essay about Unions Weapon of the 21st Century: Education

- The strength of any organization depends on how solid of a foundation it is built on. Education is that foundation. In the 1980’s unions encountered a major setback when globalization hit. This caused a change in the economy accounting for major losses of jobs affecting blue-collar workers. Unions were not prepared for the hardship it created for its members. Now in the 21st century, globalization is back. This time it has spared a greater magnitude of devastation. Not only for the blue-collar workers, but it has encompassed white-collar workers as well....   [tags: Unions]

Term Papers
1323 words (3.8 pages)

The Need For Advanced Training and Education Within Unions Essay

- Why must education be of top priority in every union. First of all let’s take a moment and think back to when you were an infant. Imagine as an infant you were born with no one to instruct you in your “trial and error” learning process. What happens. You have just been set up for failure; and with enough failures, comes extinction. Ok, now let’s bring you back from being an infant and back into the present. Imagine now you have been a “rank and file” union member for several years. Your union is about to hold elections for leadership offices and you decide to run....   [tags: Unions]

Term Papers
1183 words (3.4 pages)

Do Not Stigmatize Same-Sex Marriages as Inferior by Not Legalizing These Unions

- ... They based this on the reasoning that "the dissimilitude between the terms `civil marriage' and `civil union' is not innocuous; it is a considered choice of language that reflects a demonstrable assigning of same-sex, largely homosexual, couples to second-class status." Massachusetts became the first state in the United Sates to legalize gay marriage. Gay marriages can also provide financial profit to state and local governments. The revenue collected from gay marriages comes from none other than marriage licenses, higher income taxes (the "marriage penalty"), and decreases in costs for state benefit programs....   [tags: religious, gay, civil rights]

Term Papers
1229 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The History of Labor Unions

- After the Civil War, many ideologies developed into the United States of America. Some of these ideologies included the free labor ideology and the producerist ideology. Free labor endorsed the belief that by removing slavery, or any other kind of barrier, everyone had an equal chance to try to get wealth (Farless). The producerist ideology tried to stay to the customary view of society and it stressed the importance of viewing the community instead of an individual (Farless). With these two ideologies, they had an impact on labor....   [tags: Labor Unions]

Term Papers
1247 words (3.6 pages)

It's Time to Ban Smoking Essay

- Do you smell that. That foul scent mixed into the air. It’s killing you slowly inside, each time you take a breath of this putrid, polluted, dirty scent. You smell it too, the trillions of chemicals racing into your lungs. Now look around yourself, and you’ll see someone smoking on the bench beside you. Smoking is the number one avoidable causes of death. Therefore, smoking should be banned from all public areas. The ban from smoking in public will help to reduce the smokers intake of cigarettes/chemicals, cigarettes themselves are a danger to the earth, some may argue that this ban may damage the economy, and that smoking does not only effect the smoker himself/herself, it...   [tags: Pro Smoking Ban]

Term Papers
1691 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on History of Trade Unions and NTUC

- History of Trade Unions and NTUC A trade union is an organized group of employees in a particular sector, whose aim is to negotiate with employers over pay, job security, working hours by using the collective power of the members. They are funded by subscriptions from union members, and often offer legal advice and strike pay during disputes when members refuse to work. In general, the union is there to represent the interests of its members, and may even engage in social and political activities where legislation affects their members....   [tags: History Trade Unions]

Term Papers
1794 words (5.1 pages)