Essay about Sacrifice to the Signifier, in Comic Praise of the Logos

Essay about Sacrifice to the Signifier, in Comic Praise of the Logos

Length: 1340 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Sacrifice to the Signifier, in Comic Praise of the Logos


When Socrates wanted to inspire Glaucon with knowledge of the pure forms, he conjured up a rhetorical fantasm—a word-picture whose referent could appear no other way, and whose signified emerged from a cluster of signifiers (men chained before a blazing fire, shadows on a cave wall, etc.). At once self-consciously artificial and didactic, Socrates’ allegory prompts an understanding, produces a knowledge that leans upon fantasy and imagination as its only supports. Replying to Socrates, Glaucon registers his appreciation of the allegory: "All this I see."

Perhaps this primal scene of philosophical instruction can most productively be grasped as a deaf moment, or as an occasion of occult second sight that funds the philosophical drive toward the absolute. An ambitious, and careless, reading of this allegory might suggest that it illustrates a logic of signification grounded in imaginary (as opposed to symbolic) identifications—that sight, and not sound, image and not voice, is the most fundamental sensual modality, and that, consequently, all rhetoric is "visual." Herman Rapaport tempers ambition with caution: "More interesting is how a prop such as the cave image can suddenly turn into a stage, how an mage, itself framed, can immediately stage itself as stage and in that way absent itself or disappear from the viewer’s consciousness as image, object, or prop." That disappearing or absenting harnesses a sensual response, a response that, paradoxically, evokes a disembodied gaze. "So much, then, depends on a stage prop, on the theatricalization of philosophy." And more than that, so much depends upon the reduction of significance into sensation, the return or even...


... middle of paper ...


...unking of commodity fetishism or idolatry, nor a bloodless deconstruction of the social imaginary. Rather, it is a wary and cultivated respect for the passion of the image, its yearning (and, sometimes, promise) to be the transubstantiated Word: A comic orientation toward visual rhetorics described by Burke as a charitable attitude toward communication "that is required for purposes of persuasion and co-operation, but at the same time maintains our shrewdness concerning the simplicities of ‘cashing in.’" Such an attitude would command the power to see and not believe, to note one’s own foibles—to recognize oneself as both origin and apparition, anchor and crafted chain, self-conscious performer and bungling automaton—and to be wary of being cheated or seduced by delusions while also being capable of collapsing into the visions of others. Yes, indeed, all this I see.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Rhetoric, Pathos, Logos, And Logos

- Rhetoric is when a writer or speaker uses different techniques in order to persuade or impress an audience. The main area of rhetoric that most writers focus on is rhetorical situation. Rhetorical situation includes three concepts: ethos, pathos, and logos, these concepts are shown throughout the duration of the “Love Your Hair Longer with Pantene” commercial. The “Love Your Hair Longer with Pantene” commercial includes Selena Gomez and two other women dancing to her song “Hands to Myself” while showing off their hair by flipping it around....   [tags: Rhetoric, Logos, Ethos, Pathos]

Strong Essays
831 words (2.4 pages)

Rhetoric, Pathos, Logos, And Logos Essay

- Many people today enjoy a piece of gum to have refreshing breath and keep our teeth healthy. Extra-Origami commercial ties in the love a father has for his daughter while she is growing up until she is packing for college. Extra develops its idea of it being long lasting gum by comparing it to a father figure who is dependable and always there for you. The company has established its commercial through the rhetoric devices of ethos, pathos and logos. This advertisement attempts to persuade families who value their relationships to buy Extra gum through the story of a father and his daughter....   [tags: Rhetoric, Ethos, Logos, Pathos]

Strong Essays
1000 words (2.9 pages)

Con : Comic Con Fair Essay

- For anyone observing The Louisiana Comic Con ad, they might become filled with confusion as to what is this event all about. Is there a revival in town, a Walking Dead convention, a Star Wars fan club meeting, or have all these actors gathered for a true Comic Con fair. Comic Con is a science fiction fantasy come true, cult following party. No matter your age or gender there seems to be something for everyone to experience. Deadheads, Trekies, Go Go Power Rangers, Cowabunga dude, which are you a fan of....   [tags: Comic book, Comics, Comic strip, Magazine]

Strong Essays
1220 words (3.5 pages)

The Discussion of Homosexuality in Comic Books Essays

- The discussion of homosexuality in comic books has a long history, reaching back to 1954, when German-American psychiatrist Frederick Wertham published Seduction of the Innocent, a book that warned about the negative effect of popular literature. The book was a minor bestseller and was taken seriously at the time, creating alarm in parents with the claim that reading the crime-, superhero- and horror comics that contain descriptions of violence, sex, drug use and other adult themes, children will be encouraged to similar behavior (Wikipedia)....   [tags: homosexuality, comic books]

Strong Essays
1990 words (5.7 pages)

Human Sacrifice And The Aztec Culture Essay

- Human sacrifice was a religious practice characteristic of the Aztec civilization, and much of Mesoamerica. Spanish conquistadors, Hernan Cortes, made observations of and wrote reports about the practice of human sacrifice. These reports tended to be great exaggerations of what they saw, nor did they comprehend the significance of sacrifice among the Aztec culture. These tales were fabricated to convince the people of the world that the Aztecs were less than human. An array of reasons and interpretations of the Aztec practice of human sacrifice have been proposed by modern scientists....   [tags: Human sacrifice, Mesoamerica, Sacrifice, Aztec]

Strong Essays
1004 words (2.9 pages)

Essay About Love And Sacrifice

- Love and Sacrifice Love is a universal feeling. No one has never felt love and everyone has endured sacrifices of their own. Love always has sacrifices and are required if you love someone or something. There are many sacrifices that can show affection and care that have positive externalities such as, giving up luxuries, personal goals or even physical sacrifices. In the wake of perhaps, a financial problem a person could sacrifice the luxuries of their lives to benefit another cause in their life that they care for....   [tags: Love, Sacrifice, Life, Human sacrifice]

Strong Essays
1874 words (5.4 pages)

I Would Sacrifice Everything For You ! Essay

- I Would Sacrifice Everything for You. (Three Messages from Federico 's Falcon) I would sacrifice everything for you...Just Kidding. Ha, fooled you, huh. As if I believe that you are actually going to stay with me for me to actually believe that I am willing to sacrifice for you. Ha, Never. This is my most precious baby, my everything, as if I would just sacrifice him for the likes of you. Never. Now, Leave and please, don’t ever come back. Harsh, so harsh, but I guess you never knew real love huh....   [tags: Love, Sacrifice, Human sacrifice]

Strong Essays
1261 words (3.6 pages)

Essay On Parental Sacrifice

- What is Parental Sacrifice. “You will come to know that what appears today to be a sacrifice will prove instead to be the greatest investment that you will ever make.” - Gordon B. Hinckley. In today’s culture, the act of sacrificing is viewed in a negative light. The dictionary definition for sacrifice is described as the destruction or surrender of something for the sake of someone else (Webster, Sacrifice). This view of sacrifice isn't necessarily incorrect, but I think it also depicts the self-centered attitude of people today....   [tags: Sacrifice, Binding of Isaac, Korban, Isaac, Parent]

Strong Essays
1299 words (3.7 pages)

Comic Art: The Seduction of the Innocent Essay

- Comic Art: The Seduction of the Innocent In 1991, at the 13th Annual World Fantasy Convention, an issue of the comic book series The Sandman was selected by a panel of experts in the field as the Year's Best Short Story. This was not the first time that a comic book has been nominated for a prestigious literary prize (the first and only previous one being Art Spiegelman's retelling of the Holocaust in animal fable form Maus for the National Book Critics Circle Award in 1987), but it was the first to have won....   [tags: Comics Art Artistic Comic Papers]

Strong Essays
3300 words (9.4 pages)

Essay on Effective Use of Dialogue in The Sacrifice of Isaac

- Effective Use of Dialogue in The Sacrifice of Isaac        In the Brome version of The Sacrifice of Isaac, the suspense created by the emotionally charged dialogue is likely what kept the audience's attention. While it is incredibly likely that the audience knew the entire story, the emotional flavor of the dialogue, such as Abraham's innocent expressions of his love of and thankfulness for Isaac at the beginning of the play, is bound to evoke a certain concern for the characters which dims the audience's foreknowledge of the tale's happy ending....   [tags: Sacrifice of Isaac Essays]

Strong Essays
1488 words (4.3 pages)