The Forbidden Experiment by Roger Shattuck Essay

The Forbidden Experiment by Roger Shattuck Essay

Length: 1421 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Forbidden Experiment by Roger Shattuck


It is one of the oldest unanswered questions in all of science. Though slightly more grounded in empirical science than the likes of "Where did we come from?" or "Why are we here?" the impossible Nature/Nurture dichotomy has tormented truth-bound scientists for years. Recent advances in genetics have brought forward new possibilities for those who would study the pure effects of environmental variables on animals, but we are far from allowing ourselves to manipulate other human beings in such ways for the sake of collecting data. This strong moral stance does not diminish our curiosity and so the question must be asked: What would we do if a case in which the human had already been manipulated, by no will of our own, fell into the hands of science? How far would we go?

Every couple hundred years, one of these humans, by chance or by a case of true cruelty, falls into the hands of scientists, eager to make the most of such a 'misfortune'. Roger Shattuck's The Forbidden Experiment follows one of the more prominent cases of our recent history, that of the 'Wild Boy of Aveyron.'

The book takes little time to peak the reader's curiosity with the tale of a "savage" twelve-year-old wandering out of the woods of southern France on a cold January evening in 1800. Without a known history or the ability to communicate with his captors, Victor, as he was later named, was assumed to have lived in the wild for at least six years and probably more. In the midst of an intellectually lively France, Victor wandered into immediate fame and was brought to Paris so that the most capable scientists could take advantage of studying a human raised almost completely in isolation. The st...


... middle of paper ...


...t are our motives in these 'unfortunate' instances? Would we learn from the dumb how not to speak; how to forget? Or would we teach language and culture so that Victor may live with us and suffer as we do? What does that make us?

References

1) Shattuck, Roger. The Forbidden Experiment. New York: Farrar Straus Giroux, 1980

2)NOVA transcript, transcript for 'Genie' episode
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/transcripts/2112gchild.html

3)The Civilizing of Genie , the story of Genie
http://kccesl.tripod.com/genie.html

4)Online News Hour, Shattuck interview
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/gergen/january97/forbid_1-2.html

5)Ethical Culture Book Review, review of Forbidden Knowledge
http://www.ethicalculture.org/review/articles/forbiddenknowledge.html

6)Feral Children Website, a great resource about 'wild' children
http://www.feralchildren.com/en/index.php

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Psychological Experiment : The Stanford Prison Experiment Essay

- In 1971 three psychologists, Craig Banks, Curtis Haney, and Phillip Zimbardo were captivated in finding out whether the rough treatment described among guards in American prisons was due to the aggressive behaviors of the guards or the prisoners lack of respect for law and order (dispositional hypothesis) or had more to do with the prison atmosphere (situational hypothesis) (Maxfield & Babbie, 2009). If the prisoners and guards acted in a non-violent way this would corroborate the dispositional hypothesis, or if the prisoners and guards act the same way as people do in real prisons this would authenticate the situational explanation (McLeod, 2016)....   [tags: Stanford prison experiment, Milgram experiment]

Powerful Essays
1127 words (3.2 pages)

Art of Beijing’s Forbidden City Essay

- Through art, people can expose their ideas, their opposition to the government rules and regulations in a quiet way. The artists try to expose their revolutionary ideas and motivate the people to fight against the cruel actions of the government. The concept of Chinese government about art is that it must always serve the people and the government is always ready to promote art by giving systematic education about the new art. They always give preferences to the revolutionary art and the nonrevolutionary arts were banned at that time....   [tags: Beijing’s Forbidden City, Beijing, art,]

Powerful Essays
1945 words (5.6 pages)

The Stanford Prison Experiment : Experiment Essay

- Would you go into prison to get paid. Do you believe that you will come out the same or become different. Do not answer that. The Stanford Prison Experiment was an experiment that was conduct in 1971 by a team of researchers led by psychology professor Philip Zimbardo. Seventy applicants answered the ad and were narrowed down to 24 college students, which half were assigned either to be guards or prisoners by random selection. Those 24 college students were picked out from the of 70 applicants by taking personality tests and given diagnostic interviews to remove any candidates with psychological problems, medical disabilities, or a history of crime or drug abuse....   [tags: Stanford prison experiment, Philip Zimbardo]

Powerful Essays
1279 words (3.7 pages)

Imperialism Exposed in Roger & Me Essay

- "Black Thursday." The name itself sends shivers down your spine. October 24, 1929 the New York Stock Exchange crashed signaling the end of the Roaring Twenties and the start of the Great Depression. A depression can be defined as, "a prolonged deep recession." A recession is, "a period during which aggregate output declines." (Case 118) This was certainly quite a change, as in the twenties the economy seemed to be booming around the world. There was rapid increase in industrialization, and drastic improvements in technology....   [tags: Roger & Me Film]

Free Essays
3464 words (9.9 pages)

Essay about Roger Malvin’s Burial and History

- “Roger Malvin’s Burial” and History           Q. D. Leavis states that Hawthorne had among his forbears a “witch-hanging judge and the Quaker-whipping Major” (30). This is a reference to one instance of historical allusion in Hawthorne’s short stories. This essay will explore a variety of historical incidences referred to in his short story, “Roger Malvin’s Burial.” Clarice Swisher in “Nathaniel Hawthorne: a Biography” states the author’s deep historical ties: William Hathorne was a colonial magistrate involved in the persecution of Quakers, another Protestant religious group....   [tags: Roger Malvin’s Burial]

Powerful Essays
2012 words (5.7 pages)

Getting to Yes by Roger Fisher Essay examples

- Getting to Yes by Roger Fisher Whether or not we are aware of it, each of us is faced with an abundance of conflict each and every day. From the division of chores within a household, to asking one’s boss for a raise, we’ve all learned the basic skills of negotiation. A national bestseller, Getting to Yes, introduces the method of principled negotiation, a form of alternative dispute resolutions as opposed to the common method of positional bargaining. Within the book, four basic elements of principled negotiation are stressed; separate the people from the problem, focus on interests instead of positions, invest options for mutual gain, and insist on using objective criteria....   [tags: Negotiation Getting Yes Roger Fisher Essays]

Powerful Essays
1118 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Roger Williams' A Key Into the Language of America

- Roger Williams' A Key Into the Language of America During American colonial times, the native peoples of the new world clashed often with the English settlers who encroached upon their lifestyle. Many horror stories and clichés arose about the natives from the settlers. As one might read in Mary Rowlandson’s Narrative, often these disputes would turn to violence. To maintain the process of the extermination of the natives alongside Christian moral beliefs, one of the main tenets of colonial life was the belief that the natives were “savages”; that they were morally and mentally inferior to the English that settled there....   [tags: Roger Williams Savages Language America Essays]

Powerful Essays
2167 words (6.2 pages)

Essay about The Concept of Woman in Roger Malvin’s Burial

- The Concept of Woman in “Roger Malvin’s Burial”                John Erskine in Leading American Novelists says that “Roger Malvin’s Burial” is “the most powerful story, morally, of the Mosses from an Old Manse” (236). And what makes it so powerful. A very vital woman character by the name of Dorcas is key to the narrative-producing decision by Reuben to leave Roger to die alone. Dorcas is also key to the guilt preserved within the main character, Reuben, which leads to his growing into an irritable personality....   [tags: Roger Malvin’s Burial Essays]

Powerful Essays
2157 words (6.2 pages)

Osmosis Experiment Essay

- Background Knowledge: Osmosis definition: Diffusion of water molecules through a semi permeable membrane from a higher concentration to a lower concentration until the concentration on both sides is equal. Osmosis in animal cells: The cell membrane is the partially permeable membrane in animal cells. If the cells were placed in distilled water they gain water, swell and burst. This is known as haemolysis. Osmosis in plant cells: The cellulose cell wall of plant cells is fully permeable. Therefore it’s the cell membrane of a plant cell which acts as the semi-permeable membrane, deciding what gets into and out of the cell....   [tags: Science Experiment]

Powerful Essays
582 words (1.7 pages)

Essay about Roger Sperry

- Nowadays, it is widely known that the right and left hemisphere have different functions. The two hemispheres are equally important in a daily life basis. Nevertheless, in the 1960’s this was not common knowledge. Even though today the importance of the brain hemispheres is common knowledge, people don’t usually know to whom attribute this findings. One of the people who contributed to form a more defined picture about the brain hemispheres and their respective functions was Roger Wolcott Sperry, with the split brain research....   [tags: hemisphere, split, brain, Chemoaffinity hypothesis]

Powerful Essays
1874 words (5.4 pages)