Dufay's Piece for Peace: an Ironic Battle Between Structure and Word Essay

Dufay's Piece for Peace: an Ironic Battle Between Structure and Word Essay

Length: 2636 words (7.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Dufay's Piece for Peace: an Ironic Battle Between Structure and Word


On April 8, 1433, the Pope Eugenius and Sigismundus, King of the Romans, united to sign a treaty of peace. The king was crowned Holy Roman Emperor and there was much celebration. To commemorate this joyful occasion, Guillame Dufay wrote the motet "Supremum est mortalibus bonum" ("The highest good for mortals is peace"), including the names of these two honored men in his great sustained chords near the piece's conclusion (Bent, CD notes). Dufay's main text is shared by his top two voices, the triplum and motetus, and is divided into two stanzas. The first 12 lines comprising the first stanza speak of the benefit of peace to men of all classes and of the freedom and joy it brings to the natural world. The second stanza, encompassing the final 8 lines, prays for the eternity of peace and praises Eugenius and Sigismundus, the envoys of peace. Dufay carefully sets these words to music, colorfully painting their meanings before our eyes through his rich melodic lines. Ironically, however, as he also struggles to bring isorhythmic structure and support to his work, he battles between text and design, foregoing a sense of peace to create a curious collage of his musical ideas.

Dufay's motet is of isorhythmic design, employing a repeating tenor line that moves slowly beneath the other parts, functioning as a foundation for the work. As noted by Grout, isorhythmic motets have tenors built up of colors (the "repeating series of pitches") and talea (the "long recurring rhythmic unit").1 Dufay's tenor has six 15 bar units of a certain talea. His piece is curious, for we could interpret it as having two colors, since the entire melodic line of the tenor repeats only o...


... middle of paper ...


... the last three measures of the work's introduction, bringing the motet full circle. The last two beats of bar 119 tease us with odd tension and dissonance on the final "men," which is peacefully resolved on the final cadence of bar 120. (Play Example 12) With "Supremum est Mortalibus bonum" Dufay has created a piece that lavishly illustrates text while also employing fauxbourdon and isorhythmic design. With so many competing forces fighting to be displayed and heard, Dufay's work about peace is ironically at war with itself. Though a fine composition on all these levels, a careful listening and analysis leaves us feeling unsettled and certainly not at peace!

Works Cited:

1Grout, Donald J. and Claude V. Palisca, A History of Western Music, (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, Inc., 1996) 104-105.

2 The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians, Vol. F, 434.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Separate Piece, By John Knowles Essay

- In John Knowles’ novel, A Separate Piece, the main Character, Gene Forrester, has to learn to become friends with his hazardous roommate, Phineas, at his school, Devon, in New Hampshire. The novel is affected by a number of changes, however the largest and most significant change is the change in seasons. In Thomas C. Foster’s novel, How to read literature like a Professor, chapter twenty explains the significance of the seasons. Foster states that, “Summer [symbolizes] adulthood and romance and fulfillment and passion,” while, “ winter [symbolizes] old age and resentment and death.” John Knowles’ book A Separate Peace, all aspects of Summer, Fall, and Winter are excellently represented as...   [tags: Season, Autumn, A Separate Peace, Winter]

Term Papers
910 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Symbol and Ironic References in The Story of an Hour

- The story of an hour its has lots of Irony and symbolism. Irony is a figure of speech where by an expression of something is made contrary the intending meaning. Symbolism is the applied use of symbol icon representations thatcarries particular conventional meaning. The term symbolism is often limited to use in contrast. All symbolic concepts can be viewed in relation where change in context may imply systemic change to individual and collective definition of symbol. This lady had a heart problem, she found out her husband was in train wreck she was sad but then she realized she was finally free she wasn’t as sad as people though she was she was actuallyhappy that she can tardy a new life....   [tags: peace, heart trouble, arm chair]

Term Papers
1038 words (3 pages)

The Ironic Battle for Democracy in Europe During WW I Essay example

- As President Wilson asked Congress to declare war on Germany on April 2, 1917 because “The world must be made safe for democracy” (War Messages, 65th Cong., 1st Sess.), the United States joined forces with the allies very soon in a crucial time of the war; Germany made an armistice with Russia in December the same year, so Germany was able to mobilize all its troops to the Western Front. Back in the U.S, due to the separate but equal policy brought forth by the Plessy V. Ferguson supreme court ruling of 1896, military units were segregated....   [tags: world war, croix de guerre, democracy]

Term Papers
2036 words (5.8 pages)

The Role of Women in Peace-Building Essay

- In the undeniable patriarchy of the modern world it could be argued that with an increase in female participation in positions of power and influence there would inherently be an increase in world peace. This statement is multifaceted and riddled with a huge lack of empirical data due to only 20% of the world’s political leaders being female. Though with limited data, it can be seen that gender plays no real influence on how a leader will lead a state, and therefor has no play on whether a leader will be more peaceful....   [tags: international peace, human nature]

Term Papers
1547 words (4.4 pages)

A Separate Peace, by John Knowles Essay

- People frequently betray others because of the evil in their hearts. In A Separate Peace, John Knowles uses the pureness of the rakish Finny to portray the savage or bad side of the vulpine Gene. He also uses it to prove that peace is exceedingly difficult to acquire until a person accepts the ignorance in their own heart. That means that acceptance is the key to finding peace. Thus, Gene finds his peace when Finny forgives him and when Gene learns to forgive himself as well. Gene assumes that Finny and he despise each other, until he becomes aware of how flawless Finny really is, which Gene loathes....   [tags: A Separate Peace, John Knowles]

Term Papers
740 words (2.1 pages)

The Steptoe Battle Essay

- Introduction In 1858, warriors from the Spokane, Palouse, and Coeur d’Alene tribes routed an expeditionary force commanded by Colonel Edward Steptoe. The running battle resulted in seven soldiers dead, two soldiers missing, two howitzer cannons buried, the complete loss of the pack train, and three interpreters killed. Colonel Steptoe and his command escaped in the middle of the night nearly out of ammunition and in desperate condition. The mounted infantry known as Dragoons rode through the next day covering approximately seventy miles to the relative safety of the Snake River....   [tags: colville mines, battle of pine creek]

Term Papers
1827 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on Battle Royal, by Ralph Ellison

- "Battle Royal" "Battle Royal," by Ralph Ellison was a very difficult piece of literature for me to understand. As a little background information, Ellison was very much into music (228). He was born in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma on March 1, 1914 (221). Different themes are presented throughout this short story, which reflect different views that Ellison had at the time that he wrote this essay. One boy is invited to speak at local men’s club where he will deliver his graduation speech....   [tags: Battle Royal Essays]

Term Papers
1200 words (3.4 pages)

Realization in Welty’s A Piece of News Essay examples

- Realization in Welty’s A Piece of News Ruby’s death fantasy reflects the conflict between her wants, needs, and life in this Eudora Welty story. We first meet Ruby while she is coming in from a storm with a package of coffee wrapped in newspaper from a man from Tennessee. We find out later that she has a habit of hitchhiking and picking up men from Tennessee. Welty writes, “When Clyde would make her blue, she would go out onto the road, some car would slow down, and if it had a Tennessee license, the lucky kind, the chances were that she would spend the afternoon in the shed of the empty gin” (14)....   [tags: Welty Piece of News Essays]

Term Papers
2362 words (6.7 pages)

Allegory for War in Battle of the Ants by David Thoreau Essay example

- Allegory for War in "Battle of the Ants" by David Thoreau The reading journal that I chose was "Battle of the Ants" by David Thoreau. I chose this essay because I felt that it was a strongly written piece about a somewhat interesting topic. When I first read it I was taken aback by its seemingly uninteresting nature of topic, but after I read it a couple more times I began to see its true beauty. The story is about government and war and depicted by ants battling to the death. "The legions of Myrmidons covered all the hills and vales in my wood-yard, and the ground was already strewn with all the dead and dying, both the red and the black," the ants represent humans struggling for freedom...   [tags: Battle of the Ants David Thoreau]

Term Papers
530 words (1.5 pages)

Essay about Tolstoy's War and Peace

- Tolstoy's War and Peace Summary War and Peace tells the story of the Rostovs, an upper-class family in Russia, and several people associated with them. It follows the characters through fifteen years during the Napoleonic Wars, from 1805 to 1820. It gives a fictional description of the events in the life of the Rostov family as well as some of the historical events of the time. Analysis Tolstoy is regarded by some as the greatest writer about war (Bayley 16). He includes details in the military scenes of War and Peace....   [tags: Tolstoy War Peace Essays]

Term Papers
933 words (2.7 pages)