Essay on Max Black and Humean Skepticism

Essay on Max Black and Humean Skepticism

Length: 1546 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Max Black and Humean Skepticism

In this essay I will argue that the Humean problem of induction is only truly problematic when a strange, impossible definition is given to the term “reasonable”. I will begin by explaining what it is I understand Hume’s induction problem to be, and to try to flesh out the issues relevant to my case. I will then examine Max Black’s proposed solution to the problem, and show in what ways this solution is useful and why it is ultimately unconvincing. In this latter context I will invoke the work of Wesley Salmon, and then try to solve the problem that Salmon poses.

Hume’s problem of induction is that inductive reasoning is not, in fact, reasonable. That is, we are not justified in reasoning inductively. This is because he believes that, in order to justify induction, we must use some form of the Uniformity Principle. This Uniformity Principle (henceforth noted as UP) states “[t]hat instances, of which we have had no experience, must resemble those, of which we have had experience, and that the course of nature continues always uniformly the same” (Hume 89). He also believes that “we must provide one of two types of justification for UP: (a) Show that UP is the conclusion of a deductive argument, or (b) show that UP is based on experience” (Crumley 15). He shows that it is not possible to prove this principle deductively because of problems of circularity, and that to show that it is based on experience is to be similarly circular. That is, providing evidence for something and using this as a justification for a believe is precisely what induction is all about, and so one ends up justifying induction through induction. (Crumley 14-16)

The first me...

... middle of paper ... only really problematic when an unpalatable and unattainable definition of “reasonable” is used. I have shown that Black provides a good start to the problem, but that his solution is ultimately unconvincing to skeptics of induction. And I’ve attempted to address the problem that Salmon brings up; that is, I’ve attempted to show that it is improper and non-valuable to try to provide reasons for induction. My conclusion, then, is that as long as being reasonable is something that is possible to be, humans are, in fact, reasonable.

Works Cited

1. Black, Max. Caveats and Critiques. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press, 1975.

2. Crumley, Jack S II. An Introduction to Epistemology. Mountain View, California: Mayfield, 1999.

3. Salmon, Wesley. “Should We Attempt to Justify Induction?” Philosophical Studies 8 (April 1957): 33-48.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Max Wilson Woodard Biography Essay

- Max Wilson Woodard Biography He was born in Palestine, Texas to the parentage of Clyde Burette Woodard and Marye Regina (McClung) Woodard at 9:45 AM at the Palestine Sanatarium. His parents lived in Elkhart, Texas where his father was the owner and operator of Woodard Cleaners and his mother, Bubbie, as he called her, was the owner and operator of a beauty shop. 1938-1941 His first dog was an English Shepard named Rex, who was a one man dog and his constant traveling companion. Beginning at about age three, he and his dog Rex had an insatiable desire to explore any place that was outside the house and within walking distance....   [tags: Max Woodard Biography]

Powerful Essays
1499 words (4.3 pages)

The Effects of Deweyan and Humean on the Conception of Knowledge at State University

- Little did I know the first day I arrived at Michigan but the contemporary conception of knowledge which pervades the university is a mixture of Deweyan and Humean thought. This becomes increasingly clear to me when I look back on some of my classes and activities at Michigan. For instance, the university prides itself on constantly trying to promote progress and improvement throughout society, which is very Deweyan. Michigan epitomizes the saying that "growth itself is the only moral end" (Dewey 177)....   [tags: Deweyan and Humean thought]

Powerful Essays
1600 words (4.6 pages)

Essay about A Dialogue with Max

- Knowing that my father wasn't home I went around back only to frantically begin searching for the abandoned spare key that I knew he used to leave out here for the nights he came stumbling home drunk without his own. After getting frustrate I gave up the search when remembering one of the glass panels on the back door had been loose for quiet a few year before I had left. Pushing on the panels till I found the right one I new when I suddenly popped forward slightly shocking me before I grabbed for it....   [tags: short story]

Powerful Essays
1217 words (3.5 pages)

Max Weber on Society Essay

- Max Weber on Society Max Weber was one of the world's greatest sociologists and wrote a lot about the capitalist world he lived in. He had a different conception of capitalist society than most of his contemporaries. He looked at capitalism from all the different aspects that the philosophy was made of. Some of these aspects are state power, authority, class inequality, imperialism, and bureaucracy. To understand how Weber thought one must look at each area separately then put them all together in a global package....   [tags: Max Weber sociology sociological Essays]

Powerful Essays
858 words (2.5 pages)

Soundtrack review: Max Tooney Essay

- Introduction The story was told in medias res as a series of flashbacks. The story started on a day of the post-Word War II period, but the main scenes took place on the Virginian, a vessel voyaged between Europe and America, in the early 1900s. Summary Max Tooney, a musician, entered a secondhand music shop to sell his trumpet. He asked to play it one last time. The shopkeeper agreed and the immediately recognized the song was the same as the one he got from a broken record matrix in a secondhand piano =....   [tags: music talent, leyend of the pianist]

Powerful Essays
1523 words (4.4 pages)

On Emotion and Value in David Hume and Max Scheler Essay

- On Emotion and Value in David Hume and Max Scheler ABSTRACT: While some philosophers tend to exclude any significance of emotion for the moral life, others place them in the center of both the moral life and the theory of value judgment. This paper presents a confrontation of two classic positions of the second type, namely the position of Hume and Scheler. The ultimate goal of this confrontation is metatheoretical — particularly as it concerns the analysis of the relations between the idea of emotion and the idea of value in this kind of theory of value judgment....   [tags: David Hume Max Scheler Philosophy Essays]

Powerful Essays
2866 words (8.2 pages)

Mr. Max's Speech

- In the novel Native Son by Richard Wright, the final plea of Mr. Max regarding the trial of Bigger Thomas is very important as it encompasses the main theme of oppression and its importance to the United States on a monumental scale. Mr. Max analyzes the life of Bigger Thomas in the way the author intends it to be seen, as a symbol of the lives of the 12 million African Americans living in the United States at that time. The passionate speech by Mr. Max covers the theme of blindness, and how the white populace uses it to shield themselves from guilt....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Powerful Essays
1130 words (3.2 pages)

A Humean Theory of Distributive Justice Essay

- This paper suggests a strategy for constructing a contemporary Humean theory of distributive justice which would serve to ground what I call an entrepreneurial welfare state. It is argued that blending David Hume's insights about the origins and purposes of justice with Ronald Dworkin's insurance-based reasoning supporting his equality of resources model of distributive justice will yield a state which, as a matter of justice, encourages its members to engage in entrepreneurial activities and which protects them from the worst extremes of market economies....   [tags: Hume Dworkin Entrepreneur Papers]

Powerful Essays
3972 words (11.3 pages)

Skepticism Essay

- Skepticism Skepticism is the Western philosophical tradition that maintains that human beings can never arrive at any kind of certain knowledge. Originating in Greece in the middle of the fourth century BC, skepticism and its derivatives are based on the following principles: There is no such thing as certainty in human knowledge. All human knowledge is only probably true, that is, true most of the time, or not true. Several non-Western cultures have skeptical traditions, particularly Buddhist philosophy, but properly speaking, skepticism refers only to a Greek philosophical tradition and its Greek, Roman, and European derivatives....   [tags: Skeptic philosophy philosophers]

Powerful Essays
1132 words (3.2 pages)

Skepticism Essay

- Skepticism You believe something, but you don't know it. So do you really know anything. Some believe the answer lies within the arguments of skepticism. I start by analyzing the argument from perspective. Do you believe that what you see is what it is. Let's say you and I are sitting on the couch looking at a picture on the wall. We both have different opinions of what we are looking at. And there's more to the picture than what we really see. Many factors impel us to have different opinions....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
477 words (1.4 pages)