On Emotion and Value in David Hume and Max Scheler Essay

On Emotion and Value in David Hume and Max Scheler Essay

Length: 2866 words (8.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

On Emotion and Value in David Hume and Max Scheler

ABSTRACT: While some philosophers tend to exclude any significance of emotion for the moral life, others place them in the center of both the moral life and the theory of value judgment. This paper presents a confrontation of two classic positions of the second type, namely the position of Hume and Scheler. The ultimate goal of this confrontation is metatheoretical — particularly as it concerns the analysis of the relations between the idea of emotion and the idea of value in this kind of theory of value judgment. In conclusion, I point to some important theoretical assumptions which underlie the positions of both thinkers despite all the other differences between them.

In at least four types of ethical theories emotions and feelings are regarded as a vital factor in explaining the nature of both value judgement and value itself. Such types of ethical theories, however, offer not only different theories of value and valuation but they also assume or imply quite different theories of emotions and feelings. A look at the history of philosophical psychology can convince us that there has been no generally accepted theory of emotion but the idea of emotion has been changing together with the idea of mind or soul. (1) One could expect that there is a correlation between the idea of emotion and the idea of value or the good in each type of the above mentioned theories.

In what follows, I shall discuss this correlation for two ethical theories in greater detail. I shall consider the moral philosophy of David Hume which I construe as psychological naturalism of non-relativistic type. (2) I shall also consider the case of emotional intuitionism exemplified by Max Scheler. Both H...


... middle of paper ...


...the objects of emotion see: Sousa, de R. - The Rationality of Emotion, The MIT Press, Cambridge MA, 1990.

(9) For excellent discussion of this point see: Hudson, S. D. - Humean Pleasure Reconsidered, "Canadian Journal of Philosophy" 5 (1975), no 4, pp. 545-62; Fieser, J. - Hume's Classification of the Passions and Its Precursors, "Hume Studies" 18 (1992), no 1, pp. 1-17.

(10) See note 8 above.

(11) Scheler, Max - Der Formalismus in der Ethik und die materiale Wertethik, Gesammelte Werke, Bd. 2, Francke Verlag, Bern - München 1954, pp. 256-278; hereafter cited as F.

(12) F, pp. 341-356. See also: Smith, Q. - Scheler's Stratification of Emotional Life and Strawson's Person, "Philosophical Studies" (Irleand), 25 (1977), pp. 103-127.

(13) F, pp. 125 -130.

(14) Cf. Calhoun, Ch., Solomon, R. C. - What is an Emotion, Oxford University Press, New York 1984.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Max Black and Humean Skepticism

- Max Black and Humean Skepticism In this essay I will argue that the Humean problem of induction is only truly problematic when a strange, impossible definition is given to the term “reasonable”. I will begin by explaining what it is I understand Hume’s induction problem to be, and to try to flesh out the issues relevant to my case. I will then examine Max Black’s proposed solution to the problem, and show in what ways this solution is useful and why it is ultimately unconvincing. In this latter context I will invoke the work of Wesley Salmon, and then try to solve the problem that Salmon poses....   [tags: Max Black Hume Essays]

Powerful Essays
1546 words (4.4 pages)

David Hume ( 1711-1776 ) Essay

- DAVID HUME (1711-1776) is considered as one of the more notable philosophers that was a representative of the empiricism. Hume stated that it was critical that the concept of causality wasn’t denied and that this principle had an existing objective. He argued that cause and effect are factors that not are united by ties needed; if not that his union is arbitrary. By custom or by habits, nothing ensures that the logical or experience happens without a cause. For example the Sunrise necessarily follows an effect: supply of heat to the Earth....   [tags: Metaphysics, Ontology, Causality, David Hume]

Powerful Essays
817 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Emotion And Emotion Of Emotion

- Emotion is a natural action or reaction of a person in certain circumstance of life. The subject of emotion is quite interesting and when thinking about emotion a person is having a reaction of emotion towards it. There are different types of emotion like, anger, happiness, frustration and depression. A lot of times people have an emotion and act upon that emotion depending on the circumstances. This is all cognitive controlled and differs from person to person. An emotion can consist of an action such as showing affection for someone or something....   [tags: Psychology, Emotion, Sadness, Emotion and memory]

Powerful Essays
1309 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about Max Weber And The Bureaucratic System

- Max Weber advanced six points that should be present in the bureaucratic system. He believed that a bureaucratic administration was carefully run it could lead to effective decision-making, the best use of resources, and the accomplishment of organization’s goals. Weber wrote that politics, and more broadly, public administration, should be viewed as a vocation rather than a job. A vocation something that you feel very passionate about, some people might even say it is what you were born to do. A vocation allows you to use your skills in combination with your interest in a work situation where you feel you are most able to effect change....   [tags: Management, Bureaucracy, Sociology, Max Weber]

Powerful Essays
801 words (2.3 pages)

An Analysis Of Max Weber And George Ritzer Essay

- Learning Unit 5 COLLAPSE As the world around us has become more complex, large formal organizations have become more powerful and universal. A formal organization is a group designed for a special purpose and structured for maximum efficiency. Sociologist argue that bureaucratic formal organizations are necessary for the functioning of modern society. A bureaucracy is a component of a formal organization; it uses rules and hierarchical ranking to achieve efficiency. Max Weber and George Ritzer both believed in concepts founded by the same principles, they were Bureaucratization (Weber) and McDonaldization (Ritzer)....   [tags: Sociology, Max Weber, Bureaucracy]

Powerful Essays
727 words (2.1 pages)

How We Gain Knowledge and What We Do with Knowledge: David Hume Essay

- David Hume was an imperialist philosopher who revolutionized scientific argument and methodology with his skepticism. His arguments about the way people though up to his day, and still today, are fundamental in explaining how we gain knowledge and what we do with this knowledge. Hume helped pave a road leading toward a higher state of consciousness for humanity with his theory concerning the perceptions of the mind. He divided the minds perception into two distinct group's impression and ideas. With these two classifications Hume rationalized the depths of human understanding....   [tags: David Hume, Knowledge, philosophy]

Powerful Essays
1766 words (5 pages)

Essay on Hume vs. Kant

- Many different philosophers have their own way of looking at not only the world, but society as a whole. This is clearly seen with the two philosopher’s Kant and Hume. Though totally different styles of philosophizing and looking at an ethical theory, it is not to say that one’s theory is better or more justified than the other. It is perhaps a different point of view or another opinion to take in. We must not directly rule out either Hume or Kant because both of their ethical theories have been approved by numerous philosophers and scholars alike....   [tags: Hume Kant Compare Contrast Philosophy Essays]

Powerful Essays
1110 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on David Hume and Future Occurrences

- In An Inquiry Concerning Human Understanding, David Hume demonstrates how there is no way to rationally make any claims about future occurrences. According to Hume knowledge of matters of fact come from previous experience. From building on this rationale, Hume goes on to prove how, as humans we can only make inferences on what will happen in the future, based on our experiences of the past. But he points out that we are incorrect to believe that we are justified in using our experience of the past as a means of evidence of what will happen in the future....   [tags: Philosophy Hume Philosophical Essays]

Free Essays
1020 words (2.9 pages)

Hume's Wide Construal of the Virtues Essay

- Hume's Wide Construal of the Virtues ABSTRACT: The term "virtue" has traditionally been used to designate morally good character traits such as benevolence, charity, honesty, wisdom, and honor. Although ethicists do not commonly offer a definitive list of virtues, the number of virtues discussed is often short and their moral significance is clear. Hume's analysis of the virtues departs from this tradition both in terms of the quantity of virtues discussed and their obvious moral significance....   [tags: Hume Virtues Virtue Philosophy Papers]

Powerful Essays
3849 words (11 pages)

Essay on Hume Vs Kant

-      Hume’s ultimate goal in his philosophic endeavors was to undermine abstruse Philosophy. By focusing on the aspect of reason, Hume shows there are limitations to philosophy. Since he did not know the limits, he proposed to use reason to the best of his ability, but when he came to a boundary, that was the limit. He conjectured that we must study reason to find out what is beyond the capability of reason.      Hume began his first examination if the mind by classifying its contents as Perceptions....   [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Hume Kant Essays]

Powerful Essays
1749 words (5 pages)