The Economic and Political Motives of the American Constitution vs. the Articles of Confederation

The Economic and Political Motives of the American Constitution vs. the Articles of Confederation

Length: 4834 words (13.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Economic and Political Motives of the American Constitution vs. the Articles of Confederation


The Constitution of the United States of America is often revered and thought of as the basis for all democracies around the world. However, when it is used as an example of the perfect democracy, the facts and history behind its creation are often left out. While it is a fascinating document, it is not the pinnacle of perfection that we often hold it up to be. It had a stumbling start, full of problems and arguments, instead of the immaculate conception that is often described. Its beginnings were much humbler, and they started with the Articles of Confederation.

It is somewhat strange that the American people know so little of the fundamental nature of their system of government. Their acquaintance with it extends only to its outward form and rarely includes a knowledge of the political philosophy upon which it rests. The sources of information upon which the average man relies do not furnish the data for a correct understanding of the Constitution. (Smith, Allen, 1965: 30)

What I propose to show is that the Constitution of the United States is not necessarily the best form of government for the United States, but that a reworking of the Articles of Confederation would have been sufficient. The motives I would like to call into question are those of the Framers of the Constitution, but also those of the Framers of the Articles of Confederation. The Articles of Confederation are often historically overlooked, but they play a major role in the creation of the Constitution. By examining the creation of the Articles of Confederation and its demise, I hope to shed some light on why the Constitution was created an...

... middle of paper ... Company, 1936.

Bourgin, Frank. The Great Challenge: The Myth of Laissez-Faire in the Early Republic. New York: George Braziller, 1989.

Campbell, R.H. and A.S. Skinner, eds. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations. Glasgow edition of the works and correspondence of Adam Smith. Indianapolis: Liberty Classics, 1981.

Jensen, Merrill. Articles of Confederation: An Interpretation of the Social-Constitutional History of the American Revolution, 1774-1781. University of Wisconsin: University of Wisconsin Press, 1940.

Kenyon, Cecelia. The Antifederalists. New York: Bobbs-Merrill Co. Inc., 1966.

McDonald, Forrest. We the People: The Economic Origins of the Constitution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1958.

Smith, J. Allen. The Spirit of American Government. Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1965.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Thai History and Political Paranoia Essay

- The question as to what dictates the relationships and conflicts between the different political parties in Thailand is an intriguing one. While some may believe that the underlying influence is ambition, there is more substance to the argument that it is in fact political principles, personal loyalty, family alliance and, most importantly, political paranoia, which dictate Thai politics. The paranoia arises from a mutual distrust and fear that a fellow Thai member of the resistance may have some hidden agenda that is incompatible and in conflict with their own....   [tags: ideological differences, political parties]

Powerful Essays
589 words (1.7 pages)

The French and American Revolutions Essay

- The French and American Revolutions were derived amongst similar motivations to better their governments. However, they differ on other levels based on their actions and outcomes. The American and French revolutions both wanted its citizens to be viewed as equals, just as well as allow them to have some natural rights. Sovereignty however is, viewed differently by the two parties. The core reason for each revolution differs, but they both have the same ending results of a declarations document. Both documents are composed based off enlightenment thinkers John Locke’s Second Treatise of Government and Jean Jacques Rousseau’s Social Contract....   [tags: Results, Motives, Actions]

Powerful Essays
572 words (1.6 pages)

Does ‘The American Scholar’ Reflect the Values of the Declaration of Independence and the American Constitution? 3

- John states that “The declaration of independence is the usual name of a statement adopted by the continental congress on July 4, 1776, which announced that the thirteen American colonies, then at war with Great Britain regarded themselves as 13 newly independent sovereign and no longer a part of the British Empire.” The Declaration of independence means liberation of the nation and its people from powerful nation and the colonizer. When a particular nation is independent, she starts setting supreme laws under which the government functions based on legislative, executive and judiciary....   [tags: national identity, nationalism]

Powerful Essays
922 words (2.6 pages)

The American Empire: Exceptionalist Political, Economic, and Public Policies

- ... The persevering characteristics are a division of forces, federalism, and manifestations of judicial review connected with an unequivocal Bill of Rights. Separation of powers: The separation of powers alludes, regardless, to the work in the definitive record of legislative, executive, and judicial capacities to different institutions, independently constituted. These organizations are needed by the rules set down in the document to share policymaking, and in this way are ceaselessly commonly responsible, each to the others....   [tags: imitate, freedom, world, policies]

Powerful Essays
1440 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on Political, Economic, And Social Structures Of South Korea

- For most people division occurs as a result of differences, most notably on the basis of color, race, or dialect. Very seldom does this difference occur between two people who are closely related or alike through nationality. In the Korean situation, this is the case; whereas, there is one people divided, on an arbitrary geographic line of distinction, better known as the thirty-eighth parallel. The Korean situation, and more specifically, the South Korean situation is one that had its share of burdens and battles that have shaped the identity of the Korean people....   [tags: South Korea, Korean War, World War II, North Korea]

Powerful Essays
985 words (2.8 pages)

The Clashing Interests of The Founding Fathers Essays

- The Clashing Interests of The Founding Fathers The framing of the American Constitution resulted in several conflicts dealing with economic issues, political concerns and dynamic conflicts of interest between the delegates. Each separate force had a perspective, usually clouded by personal motives, on how the new governmental system should operate. During the framing of the Constitution, the central conflicts were between the small states and the big states while in the ratification period the struggle involved the anti-federalists and the federalists....   [tags: American History Essays Constitution]

Powerful Essays
554 words (1.6 pages)

Constructing and Reconstructing Essay

- 1. Woody Holton reveals the motives of the Founding Fathers depend widely on individual judgment of the terms under the Articles of Confederation. Holton claims that historians excessively rely on sources by the Federalist which reveals a prejudiced Federalist view (Hollitz, 110). Woody Holton uses the writings of James Madison and Alexander Hamilton to expose the Founding Fathers deeper motives in writing the Constitution. The Founding Fathers were frustrated because state legislatures had been given in to popular demands to reduce taxes and increase the money supply (for relief from the recession)....   [tags: Constitution, Founding Fathers, American History]

Powerful Essays
1282 words (3.7 pages)

American Imperialism Essays

- Nationalism was a prevalent ideology worldwide by the late 1800s, and as the industrial revolution allowed the United States to emerge as a world power at this time, there was an urge to compete with Europe in territory as well as technology. In the late 19th to early 20th century, “empire-building” allowed for U.S. capitalistic expansion, thinly veiled by nationalistic rhetoric of “the white man’s burden” and a moral necessity to extend American culture to “inferior” races. The discourse of imperialism necessitated an American national identity, which revolved around the virtues of capitalism and democracy, expressions of masculinity, and the supremacy of the white race....   [tags: U.S. Foreign Policy ]

Powerful Essays
1144 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Rethinking the Finality of and Democracy in the American Constitution

- ... In addition, Dahl (2001) asserted his respect for the Framers, which shows his empathy for those who might initially oppose his arguments. He notes that the Framers are wise: “WISE AS THE FRAMERS WERE, THEY WERE necessarily limited by their profound ignorance” (Dahl, 2001, p.7). He understood that the Framers were respectable for their profound interest for public service, but they were, nevertheless, imperfect human beings who were ignorant on aspects of history and the future. Dahl (2001) does not disrespect the Framers and acknowledge that their wisdom is deep enough to create the innovation that the U.S....   [tags: constitutional concepts, political values]

Powerful Essays
1723 words (4.9 pages)

Motives Of The Spanish American War Essay

- The Spanish American War started in 1898 and lasted about four months. Although the war might have seemed focused on freeing Cuba from Spain and gaining independence for Cuba and the Philippines, it was actually stimulated by nationalism and commercialism. Commercialism was a major factor when declaring war because the United States depended on Cuba and the Philippines for trade and business with other countries, especially in Asia and Latin America. Another major factor for the war was that the United States wanted to spread its Anglo-Saxon culture around the world and emerge as a world-wide power....   [tags: American History]

Powerful Essays
951 words (2.7 pages)