Essay on Brain versus Mind By Logic,A Historically Irresolvable Debate

Essay on Brain versus Mind By Logic,A Historically Irresolvable Debate

Length: 2369 words (6.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Brain versus Mind By Logic,A Historically Irresolvable Debate


As computer and neuroscience technology progresses, the perceived role of the human brain grows ever more complex and seemingly more determinant as to what makes a person, a self. Research and development projects in both the fields of neuroscience and artificial intelligence add fire to the Mind versus Brain debate. Are the biochemical mechanics of the brain sufficient explanation for human behavior, or is there a “mind”, distinct from the brain, which harbors free will? In other words, are human thoughts and conscious actions[1] entirely based on science or on purposive cause, calling for unscientific philosophy and/or religion? Whether there is a teleological explanation[2] for human behavior and brain activity centers around the issue of determinism. A purely mechanical explanation is intrinsically deterministic, whereas a teleological explanation leaves room for free will. Because the Mind versus Brain debate rests on whether there is free will, and because neither a purely mechanical nor a teleological explanation is logically defensible to a satisfactory extent, the teleological debate concerning human behavior and brain activity is logically irresolvable.

To understand fully teleological and purely mechanical explanations of human behavior and brain activity, it is first necessary to understand the fundamental biochemistry of brain function. Although the brain is the most complex and least understood organ of the human body, its functionally essential constituent is the neuron, which exists in clusters called ganglia.[3] A neuron, or an excitable nerve cell, transfers within the brain an electrochemical (or sometimes a purely elec...


... middle of paper ...


...10. AND Weil, John L. A Neurophysiological Model of Emotional and Intentional Behavior. Springfield, Illinois; Charles C. Thomas, 1974. Pg. 146. Hereafter cited as Neurophysiological Model: Emotions, Intents.

[14] Neurophysiological Model: Motions, Intents. Pg. 146.

[15] Ibid. Pg. 148.

[16] Neuroscience and Person: Science and Divine Action. Pg. 191.

[17] McMullin, Ernan. “What Difference Doe A Mind Make?” FROM Brain and Behavior. Pg. 444.

[18] Ibid.

[19] Granit, Ragnar. “In Defense of Teleology” FROM Brain and Behavior. Pg. 400.

[20] Searle, John R. The Rediscovery of the Mind. Cambridge, Massachusetts; The MIT Press, 1992. Pg. 21.

[21] Brain and Behavior. Pg. 435.

[22] Ibid.

[23] Mechanistic Conditions. Pg. 451.

[24] Pinker, Steven. How the Mind Works. New York, New York; W. W. Norton & Company, 1997. Pg. 80.

[25] Ibid. Pg. 450.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Mind Body Problem Is The Philosophical Debate Essay

- The concept of self is something everyone in their question throughout their life time. Trying to understand yourself as an individual to better understand your role in society and what you want to accomplish in your life. Starting from an infant by developing a sense of self-awareness, understanding the difference between you and the person standing in front of you. Then understanding yourself as a human being; learning about your body and how your body functions. To learning functional skills, skills needed in day to day life, feeding yourself, dressing, learning how to cook....   [tags: Philosophy of mind, Mind, Psychology, Brain]

Powerful Essays
1090 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on The Mind And Body Vs. Mind

- The Mind and Body vs. The Mind or Body The debate of whether or not the mind is part of the body has been ongoing for centuries. Philosophers have not yet been able to come to a consensus on this question. Is the mind the driving force of the body. Would that make the mind and the brain one unit. How do we experience the world around us with this dire question unanswered. The mind and the body are two separate parts that combine to make one structure. It is important to answer this debate, so that each day we can understand why we do the things we do and so that we can understand how we experience these things that we do, rather than just assume and continue doing things for no understood r...   [tags: Mind, Thought, Psychology, Cognition]

Powerful Essays
1101 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Historically Black Colleges and Universities

- Through out history education has been a topic of many concerns. Historically Black Colleges and Universities were established to try and provide freed slaves education they were not able to obtain. For African Americans in the 20th century attending school was a burden. The children had to withstand long walks to get to their designated schools, being denied classes that the white students had in their schools, outdated books and hand me down classroom materials. African Americans all across the United States fought for their kids rights to get a good education, education provided to white only schools....   [tags: African American history]

Powerful Essays
1952 words (5.6 pages)

The Mind Body Interaction : How Mind And Matter Essay

- Since ancient times, philosophers have debated on the relationship between how mind and matter relates, and interact, if at all. One such view became known as dualism, where the mind and body (matter) are two distinct, non-identical entities. Under dualism, lies interactionism, or mind-body interaction; a type of dualism where the physical world causally affects the mental world and vice versa. A strong supporter of dualism was Descartes who believed that physical and mental phenomenon only affects what goes into the brain, but opponents heavily criticized such view claiming it is not humanly conceivable and inconsistent with known laws of science....   [tags: Mind, Philosophy of mind, Psychology, Metaphysics]

Powerful Essays
1241 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The Nature Of Body And Mind Separation

- In everyday life it appears that the body is overlooked in its relation to the mind. This notion of body and mind separation is not something that necessarily sits well with people. The debate can sit on either scientific knowledge or religious beliefs. Currently this is what we deal with when this sort of debate occurs. With the various belief structures prevalent in humans we can’t assume argument is stronger than another. For myself I lean more towards the side of the religious belief structure....   [tags: Philosophy of mind, Mind, Soul, Spirit]

Powerful Essays
736 words (2.1 pages)

The Relation Between Brain And Mind Essay

- The relation between brain and mind is disputed over a long time. The debate is whether mind and brain are separate entities or not and if the mind is a separate entity, then how are mental properties, functions and consciousness in relation with the brain, being things which are non-physical. Consciousness helps to understand the relation between the brain and mind, by contemplating the reason or the source of it, if it’s a manifestation of the mind or just a by-product of brain activity....   [tags: Mind, Philosophy of mind, Brain, Materialism]

Powerful Essays
1436 words (4.1 pages)

The Mind / Body Problem Essay

- When I hear about an outer body experience the image that comes to mind is our soul jumping out of our bodies floating around the room or maybe to a destination we can only imagine exists. Some may view this as a “high,” while others aim to achieve this on daily basis through meditation. Do I believe we can separate ourselves from our bodies. Sure, but a better question is does our mind, the conscious state have any relationship to our physical brain. The mind/body problem is a major problem debated by many philosophers today and throughout history....   [tags: Philosophy of mind, Mind, Dualism, Ontology]

Powerful Essays
1418 words (4.1 pages)

Essay about The Mind And Body Problem

- The mind and body problem has been one of the hottest topics that keep receiving the attention of the Philosophers. It is one of the debates if whether which one is physical and which one is mental. One of the toughest questions for us to answer has always been if are we a mind or a body, or are we both the same entity. The group of people who kept arguing about which one is which are the Dualists and the Materialists. The Dualists believed that the mind is separated from the body while the Materialists only believed in physical matter....   [tags: Philosophy of mind, Mind, René Descartes]

Powerful Essays
1062 words (3 pages)

What Does The Mind? Essay

- What is Mind. In philosophy, the majority of studies relate to the mind. Whether it is the main subject or just a helpful side topic to move the main subject along, this term is used often. Defining the term mind is difficult, and is a topic that is popularly studied and debated among philosophers. These qualified and knowledgeable people try to determine whether or not the mind is who people are or if they are their body or a combination. Although they have learned many helpful truths and defined other useful terms, the debate is still evident in the philosophical community today....   [tags: Philosophy of mind, Mind, Consciousness, Dualism]

Powerful Essays
796 words (2.3 pages)

Essay about Solving The Mind Body Problem

- Solving the Mind-Body Problem in Metaphysics The philosophical debate of the true connection between the body and the mind has been a continuous battle that has waged on through the present day. Some argue that they are one in the same, and others insist that they are separate entities. Throughout history, each side reveals their evidence based on a combination of science, belief, and intuition. The relationship between mind and body is mysterious, but can be described with the Cartesian dualism theory, first proposed by philosopher Rene Descartes, and further fortified by the property dualism theory....   [tags: Mind, Philosophy of mind, Soul, René Descartes]

Powerful Essays
1473 words (4.2 pages)