Kelly and Sale: Persuasive Or Pointless? Essay

Kelly and Sale: Persuasive Or Pointless? Essay

Length: 1921 words (5.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Kelly and Sale: Persuasive Or Pointless?


Unarguably, since technology has been introduced, it has had profound effects, permeating not only onto society, but our entire ecological system. To categorize the effects of technology as predominantly beneficial or detrimental, as Kevin Kelly and Kirkpatrick Sale claim in their interview, is difficult. "Interview With The Luddite" captures and vividly illustrates their seemingly pointless and underdeveloped ideas. Kelly, protechnology, and Sale, a contemporary neo-Luddite, discuss many technological issues, including the automation of the labor force, oral tradition, literacy, and civilization. Later, they go on to present often radical and unrealistic solutions to the issues. While at times I can fathom certain aspects of the arguments, their solutions are predominantly too idealistic. In this paper, I plan to explore the physical setting of the interview, important nonphysical aspects including the intentions of the participants, and the ideas presented, while incorporating my own perceptions of their persuasiveness and effectiveness.

The atmosphere of the June 1995 interview between Kelly and Sale is of essential importance to the initial impressions of the audience. Firstly, Kelly and Sale agreed to the interview which was published in Wired magazine. "This popular on-line magazine lacks any in-depth discussion of even the most problematic issues surrounding digital culture" (243). Obviously, the magazine offers a purely biased perspective and presents only the positive effects of technological innovations. Appearing in such a biased magazine may seem initially beneficial to the conversion intentions of Sale, the Luddite, but with deeper analysis it becomes clear that the c...


... middle of paper ...


... convincing. Still, I cannot fathom the motivations behind the interview for either participant. Perhaps Kelly's goal was to persuade Sale, which he did, and perhaps Sale's goal was to attract publicity. Nevertheless, neither was very effective or intriguing in their arguments.

I propose we invite technology and essentially the future. But we should never overstep our boundaries in this world. Instead, accept our role, have regard for nature, respect the Higher Being, and finally consider the consequences of our actions. If all aspects are considered, the undeveloped and seemingly pointless analogies illustrated by Kelly and Sale can be thankfully avoided.

Works Cited

Kelly, Kevin. "Interview With The Luddite." Andrea A.Lunsford and John J. Ruszkiewicz, The Presence Of Others: Voices That Call For A Response. New York: St. Martin's Press, 1997. (243-253)

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on What Shouldn 't Be For Sale?

- What Shouldn’t be For Sale. In the article “What Isn’t For Sale?,” author Micheal J. Sandel illustrates we as human in society must be keep “debate” in order to vote for what should belong and what must buy and sale in the economy market. Sandel asserts most of the things in this world now can buy and sale by money; well some should be for sale, but not all. He brings up some example such as, A prison- cell upgrade, your doctor cellphone number, and access to the carpool lane while driving solo....   [tags: Thought, Human, Health insurance, Sale]

Powerful Essays
1068 words (3.1 pages)

Good and Services: The Law on the Sale of Goods Essay

- Goods and services may be supplied under a range of different contracts. The transfer of property in this case is said to fall under the Section 2(1) of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 which stated “A contract of sale of goods is a contract by which the seller transfers or agrees to transfer the property in goods to the buyer for a money consideration, called the price.” Therefore, it is defined as a ‘contract of sale of goods’. Which is either for the (i) sale of specific goods or (ii) for the sale of unascertained goods....   [tags: remedies, sale of goods act]

Powerful Essays
1654 words (4.7 pages)

Essay A Poster Advertising A Reward Offered for the Caputre of Ned Kelly

- ... By 1879, the gang had already been on the run for a year by this point, with the two Colonial Governments now jointly offering £8,000 (around $1,500,000 AUD today) for the capture of the gang members for the murders of several police officers at Stringybark Creek following their fleeing their homes. There was also an underlying reason behind the significant increase in the reward and distribution of the wanted poster which is not as obvious and has roots in the social tension of the period. Prior to the release of this poster, the Kelly Gang held up a bank in Jerilderie, New South Wales and destroyed a large amount of mortgage and loan agreements which was a standard practice of the gang...   [tags: kelly gang, south wales]

Powerful Essays
654 words (1.9 pages)

A Critical Review of Kelly’s Personality Theory in Personality Development

- 1. Introduction Personality is a pattern of relatively permanent traits and unique characteristics that gives both consistency and individuality to a person’s behavior (Feist & Feist, 2008). For centuries, philosophers, personality theorists and other thinkers have been trying to answer: what personalities are like, how personalities are developed, why different personalities are developed and how personalities can be changed (Pervin & Cervone, 2013). George A. Kelly, an American psychologist born in 1905 in Kansa, is one of those major contributors in the field of personality psychology (Warren, 1998)....   [tags: George Kelly, personality psychology]

Powerful Essays
2235 words (6.4 pages)

Life as A Princess: Grace Kelly Essay

- Life as A Princess: Grace Kelly Even before Grace Kelly married a prince, she had the characteristics of a princess. Frank Sinatra once commented, "Grace was a princess from the moment she was born." She had remarkable elegance and sophistication that made her different from other Hollywood actresses. Some say she had a bit of fire beneath her charm. Alfred Hitchcock, who directed her in three films, called her "a snow-covered volcano". Grace was born into a family of fame and success. Her father was a wealthy bricklayer, her brother was a champion sculler, and her uncle, George Kelly was a famous playwright....   [tags: Biography Grace Kelly]

Free Essays
1131 words (3.2 pages)

The Is Not For Sale? Essay

- In today’s modern markets, what is not for sale. As Michael J. Sandel points out in What Money Can’t Buy, almost everything is a commodity for sale, from prison cell upgrades, to the right to emit carbon into the atmosphere and even the right to shoot an endangered animal. The unique markets for these commodities came as a result of faith in markets and subsequent deregulation as the primary means of achieving public good. The current financial crisis, which began in 2008, has cast doubt on that faith....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Moral, Religion]

Powerful Essays
1006 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Persuasive Text

- The purpose of a persuasive text is to change or alter the viewpoint of the reader for it to agree with the author’s perspective. The intention of this specific text is to persuade the reader to help end poverty today by joining ‘Make Poverty History’ and it uses persuasive language and techniques to do this – this essay will explain the effect on the reader and will focus on analysing persuasive language. Pronouns are an effective persuasive language technique because they address the reader directly....   [tags: persuasive text]

Powerful Essays
835 words (2.4 pages)

International Sale Of Goods, Trader Will Carry Out Their Management Plan

- Once reaching an agreement on the overseas sale of goods, trader will carry out their management plan, such as controlling the quality and quantity of goods and especially preparing for exports, which ensures the performance of the contract and the legality of the transaction . Therefore, trade terms in international sale contracts are different from these of domestic trade and intended to clarify the method of delivery, the estimates of the goods and any incidental charges . FOB (Free on board) and CIF (Cost, Insurance and Freight) are of the most common forms of these special trade terms ....   [tags: Contract, Contract law, Contract of sale, Sales]

Powerful Essays
806 words (2.3 pages)

Sex For Sale Essay

- I have often wondered what the problem with prostitution was; the act of selling sex is between the two participating in the act. I have heard many times how it hurts families, being the wives and children. Would it be better if it was free sex with another person where there were feelings involved. It seems to me, if a man or woman goes elsewhere in search of sex with no feeling that is better than a co-worker or other. Furthermore, many wants and needs are fulfilled throughout life; cars are bought that families cannot afford even homes and other indulgences why not sex....   [tags: selling sex, prostitution, regulations]

Powerful Essays
937 words (2.7 pages)

Gideon’s Freedom in Doris Lessing’s No Witchcraft For Sale Essay examples

- Gideon’s Freedom in  Doris Lessing’s No Witchcraft For Sale Dr. Gosby’s Comments: This student did an excellent job of applying the ideas we discussed in class relating to the obedience to authority When Europeans moved into the bush of Southern Africa and realized that they were hopelessly outnumbered, they had to develop ways to create and maintain their authority over the native population. They had tremendous advantages in the obvious areas, as author Jared Diamond writes in his Pulitzer Prize winning book: The proximate reasons behind the outcome of Africa’s collision with Europe are clear....   [tags: No Witchcraft Sale]

Powerful Essays
1074 words (3.1 pages)