Essay about Comparing the Grimm Brothers' Rapunzel and Disney's Rapunzel

Essay about Comparing the Grimm Brothers' Rapunzel and Disney's Rapunzel

Length: 733 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparing the Grimm Brothers' Rapunzel and Disney's Rapunzel


Wilhelm and Jacob Grimm also known as the Grimm brothers are historically known for their uniqueness both in their styles of writing and the exceptional illustrations of their works. Their age old literature has been told and retold with the essence of gothic architecture and contemporary children's stories for decades now. This essay will contrast the Grimm brothers story of Rapunzel and Disney's story of Rapunzel, it will also include comparing their illustrations with Molly Bang's theory.

In the Grimms' story of Rapunzel illustrated by Paul O. Zelinsky, the pictures observed are more aged looking. Viewing the pages, one can see that Zelinsky uses gothic architecture through the whole story. The "gothic architecture period" existed in Europe where it began in the mid 1100's and lasted until the middle 1200 centuries. (Roth, 291). The Grimm brothers reason for tying in the gothic architecture was because their works and collections were very German based and nationalist. The tall pointed arch and the tall tower, along with the "flying buttress," found on the cover of Rapunzel are a few examples of gothic trends found in the story. If one looks closely, they can see the use of stone and brick, which were the primary building blocks of the gothic style. (Roth, 300). Although there are many illustrations throughout the book, each page turns with gothic scripture and lettering along with tall towers and illustrations. Zelinsky was trying to tie the Grimms' writings in with gothic style and uniqueness.

In the more recent version of Rapunzel, Disney illustrates it with a contemporary look rather than an older gothic look. Instead of using people, Disney makes the ...


... middle of paper ...


...e horse has a rounded face to make kids see that everything is happy.

Rapunzel is a story told still today and illustrated differently as more time goes on. After reviewing the Molly Bang theory with the story of Rapunzel, and contrasting the Grimm brothers story illustrated by Zelinsky and Disney, we accept that the illustrations can be viewed differently. Whether it is gothic architecture, or a contemporary style, it is all work from the Grimm brothers.

Works Cited

Arkadia, Len and Liane B. Onish. Disney's Fairy Tale Theatre Presents Mickey and Minnie in Rapunzel. New York: Golden Books Pub. Co inc., 1998.

Heiner, Heidi Anne "History of Rapunzel" The SurLaLune Fairy Tale Pages. 1998.

http://www.surlalunefairytales.com/rapunzel/index.html

Roth, Leland M. Understanding Architecture: Its Elements, History, And Meaning. New York: HarperCollins, 1993.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Feminist View Of Rapunzel Essay

- A Feminist’s View of “Rapunzel” The Grimm Brothers’ “Rapunzel” encourages women to subscribe to domestic roles. Through the tales of various female characters, “Rapunzel” teaches women to embrace their domesticity even at the risk and disadvantage of such a single-faceted lifestyle. The first female character is Rapunzel’s biological mother, who embodies the domestic women by relying on her husband and never leaving her house. Her husband encounters the enchantress in her own garden, who, though supernatural, cannot expand beyond the domestic realm....   [tags: Fairy tale, Brothers Grimm, Rapunzel]

Better Essays
1244 words (3.6 pages)

The Grimm Brothers And Their Disney Adaptations Essay

- Fairy tales teach children valuable lessons that will later on guide them as they grow up. Despite the traditional damsel in distress fairy tale formation, these stories can be easily changed to accommodate the culture and time period in which they are told. Essentially, they are often modified to reflect the needs of a society. This modification is most prominently shown between the shown between the works of the Grimm Brothers and their Disney adaptations. While both works share similar ideas, they are perceived differently within society due to the obvious contrast between the stories being told....   [tags: Fairy tale, Brothers Grimm, Cinderella]

Better Essays
1211 words (3.5 pages)

Walt Disney And The Disney Brothers Essay

- Walt Disney and Roy Disney started the Disney Brothers Cartoon Studio in 1923, the name of the company evolved over time and is currently referred to as the Walt Disney Company. The company diversified its portfolio from family entertainment to media genres such as radio, music, theatre and online content. Disney prides itself as being the second largest media empire after Comcast, this is based on revenue analysis. It has evolved over the years to diversify into more mature content as compared to its initial focus on family based entertainment such as Mickey Mouse, Donald duck among others....   [tags: Walt Disney, The Walt Disney Company]

Better Essays
769 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm’s Rapunzel

- The Consequence of Desire in Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm’s Rapunzel Historical scholars, patriots, and entertainers of an accidental nature: all have been used to describe Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, the two German brothers who, in the 19th century, dedicated much of their lives to the collection and publication of folk-tales in an attempt to help define the cultural identity of their country. The entertainment value of this collection was probably not considered at the time of its origination, especially by the collectors themselves, whose main motivation was a sense of “nationalism and Romanticism” (Hallett, xvii)....   [tags: Brothers Grimm Rapunzel Essays]

Better Essays
2966 words (8.5 pages)

Walt Disney 's Disney Brothers Essay

- Two brothers Walt and Roy Disney founded Disney Brothers Cartoon studio on October 16, 1923 in Los Angeles, California. It started when Walt Disney was contracted to write the Alice comedies, which is the foundation of the film Alice in wonderland. After losing his contract Disney needed to create a new character in order to stay in the animation business, and he created Mickey Mouse. Mickey Mouse soon became the mascot for the Walt Disney Company as they expanded to create a variety of cartoon series such as the steamboat cartoon series, the silly symphonies and Walt Disney’s first animated film Snow White and the seven dwarfs(Smith,2004)....   [tags: Walt Disney, The Walt Disney Company]

Better Essays
2278 words (6.5 pages)

The Structure and Underlining Meanings of Rapunzel by Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm

- The Structure and Underlining Meanings of Rapunzel by Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm The story of Rapunzel, by the brothers Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, has the same basic structure as all other fairy tales born from the oral tradition; what is commonly referred to as the opening, main part and ending, is the foundation of the tale. It is around this clearly defined three-part structure of the plot, that invisible layers of meaning exist – often very different for each reader. Between the clever design of the plot – which allows several stories to surface within a seeming individual tale – and multiple layers underneath the literal action, exists a limitless journey of personal exploration....   [tags: Grimm Brothers Fairytales Rapunzel Essays]

Better Essays
1407 words (4 pages)

The Difference Between Tangled and Rapunzel The Short Story Essay

- Tangled In many fairy tales, there is always a damsel in distress that is beautiful and the male character always falls in love with her. In Rapunzel the short story, Rapunzel is put into a tower and lives there most of her young life by her ‘mother’ before her prince comes to recuse her. The difference between Tangled and Rapunzel the short story is that, Rapunzel is the princess and her prince is actually a thief, which ends up falling in love with her. Tangled illustrates how a naïve and beautiful heroine, evil mother figure, and a shallow egotistical hero can make a fairy tale story end with love and marriage....   [tags: Film Analysis, Rapunzel]

Better Essays
1192 words (3.4 pages)

Religious Symbolism in Grimm's Rapunzel Essay

- Religious Symbolism in Grimm's Rapunzel   A fairy tale is seemingly a moral fiction, intended mainly for children. A lesson in critical analysis, however, strips this guise and reveals the naked truth beneath; fairy tales are actually vicious, logical and sexual stories wearing a mask of deceptively easy language and an apparent moral. Two 19th Century writers, the Grimm brothers, were masters at writing these exaggerated stories, bewitching young readers with their prose while padding their stories with allusion and reference: an example of which is "Rapunzel." Grimm's "Rapunzel" is packed with religious symbolism, which lends a new insight to the meaning of this classic story....   [tags: Grimm Rapunzel Essays]

Better Essays
723 words (2.1 pages)

A Psychoanalytic Interpretation of Rapunzel Essay

- A Psychoanalytic Interpretation of Rapunzel      The familiar story of Rapunzel, as told by the brothers Jacob Ludwig Carl and Wilhelm Carl Grimm, takes on new meaning with a psychoanalytic interpretation. It is a complex tale about desire, achievement, and loss. The trio of husband, wife, and witch function as the ego, id, and superego respectively to govern behavior regarding a beautiful object of desire, especially when a prince discovers this object. The story begins in a rural house where a man and woman live without children, near a walled garden tended by a frightening witch....   [tags: Hay Rapunzel Essays]

Better Essays
1098 words (3.1 pages)

Rapunzel Essay

- Rapunzel I have always enjoyed this fairytale, about a young woman with exceptionally long hair who is kept prisoner in a tall tower by a sorceress. The Grim Bothers and Zelinky's version is very different from each other. Zelinsky retells the story in another way. He brings the story alive and I was able to experience in a whole new way. One thing for readers to remember is that many fairytales were originally for adults, so that is the why they may not always seem quite age appropriate. Zelinky's version relates that Rapunzel reveals that she has had a visitor in the tower when she asks the sorceress to help her with her dress for, "it is growing so tight around my waist, it does not wa...   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
577 words (1.6 pages)