The Science and the Laws Impacting Human Cloning Essay

The Science and the Laws Impacting Human Cloning Essay

Length: 5882 words (16.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Science and the Laws Impacting Human Cloning

Human cloning, long the subject of science fiction, is today a practical reality. Recent breakthroughs, most renowned the cloning of a sheep from an adult cell in Scotland in 1997, have caused the world to acknowledge that human cloning is indeed possible. Governments around the world immediately attempted to address the issue of human cloning, with varying levels of success. At the same time the pace of cloning technology continued to accelerate.

This paper will first examine the development of the technology that makes human cloning possible and the scientific uncertainties surrounding it. While this paper does not intend to take a stand on either side of the human cloning issue, a brief discussion of the human cloning controversy will be presented to help frame the legal debate. United States and international law then will be presented and analyzed. This paper argues that while there is a general consensus domestically and abroad that human cloning should be prohibited, the current legal paradigm is insufficient and unsuited to stop the proliferation of cloning technology and effectively prevent the occurance of human cloning. Finally, an this paper will examine the actors who may have an interest in cloning humans, and argue that a human being will likely be cloned in our time.

The Science

Cloning is a rather ambiguous term, and may refer to molecular cloning, cellular cloning, embryo twinning, and nuclear somatic transfer1. It is nuclear somatic transfer that is the concern of this paper and relevant to the subject of human cloning. Any competent discussion of the science that may make human cloning possible begins with the c...

... middle of paper ... horrifying visions of a future world of clones produced in human factories will prove unfounded, being dismissed by existing child abuse laws. The end product of somatic human cell nuclear transfer is nothing more than a baby, one that despite its genetic make-up, will have to chart its own path through life.

1 Gregory E. Pence. Who’s Afraid of Human Cloning? Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. New York: 1998, p. 11

2 National Bioethics Association Commission (NBAC) Cloning Human Beings- Report and Recommendations. vol. II, p. B6

3 Heagle, 4

4 Marie A. DiBerardino & Robert G. McKinnell, Backward Compatible, The Sciences, Sept./Oct. 97, p. 32

5 Heagle, 5

6 Susan Greenlee. Dolly’s Legacy to Human Cloning: International Legal Responses and Potential Human Rights Violations. 18 Wisconsin University Law Journal 537. Spring 2000, Lexis-Nexis Version p. 5

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparing History and Human Science Essay

- Historians use sources and knowledge to piece together the history of the human existence while Human scientist study the human behavior as well as the lifestyle we live in. They indeed focus on these areas and provide information to each other. However, a historian will also look to the future and foretell using his or her knowledge of the past. In the same way, a human scientist might look at human behavior today and compare it with the past. For when we look at human science, historians find it as useful term for science with the word ‘human’ as the subject (Smith)....   [tags: philosophy, human behavior]

Powerful Essays
1064 words (3 pages)

What is it about theories in human sciences and natural sciences that make them convincing?

- When looking at the human sciences and natural sciences, one may question the validity of a claim or choose to support it without any evidentiary support. For many years, science has been accepted by many as the dominant cognitive paradigm, or model of knowledge. In fact, there are also people who believe that science is the only pathway for gaining knowledge, and if something isn’t provable through science, then it should not be accepted. A person might ask, what is it about the human sciences and natural sciences that makes them convincing....   [tags: Human Intellect, Science]

Powerful Essays
1199 words (3.4 pages)

Science Of Science And Science Essay

- ... This view implies that all laws of biology can be derived from principles of physics and chemistry. However, the unity-of-science perspective falls short when applied to biology; biology has little to no laws, according to the traditional definition of a law, and most of its concepts are irreducible to other terms from different sciences. For example, molecular genetics provides the chemical composition of specific genes, but does not provide general specifications, or laws, of genes (Kitcher 70)....   [tags: Science, Scientific method, Philosophy of science]

Powerful Essays
1266 words (3.6 pages)

Is Human Activity Impacting Our Planet? Essay

- ... This puts into perspective just how much methane and carbon dioxide is emitted into the atmosphere solely due to our growing agriculture industry ("Overview of Greenhouse Gases"). Furthermore, it is important to understand the characteristics of methane and the impact it has on the environment. Why is methane such a bad thing one may ask. For one, methane has a lifespan of twelve years within our atmosphere. In addition, methane gas has the ability to trap heat in the atmosphere. Consequently the presence of methane in our atmosphere has been linked to our current global warming crisis, and it has twenty-three times the global warming impact of carbon dioxide (Lappe, 753)....   [tags: Carbon dioxide, Global warming, Greenhouse gas]

Powerful Essays
1017 words (2.9 pages)

The Human Sciences And Natural Sciences Essay

- While looking at Human Sciences and Natural Sciences as areas of knowing and memory, emotion, intuition and language as ways of knowing, we can see that shared knowledge can shape personal knowledge. Most knowledge is shared and in many cases shared knowledge exists prior to personal knowledge and plays a significant role in formulating it. Through the Human Sciences shared knowledge can be defined as knowledge that is based on cultural norms. Personal knowledge is defined as knowledge that is obtained by experience and perspective such as memories and emotions, personal knowledge can be something that an individual knows that others also know, therefore it is personal and shared, however, k...   [tags: Scientific method, Theory, Science, Sociology]

Powerful Essays
1332 words (3.8 pages)

Bisphenol-A impacting the body Essay

- BPA, Bispehenol-A, is found in so many everyday objects, but is it considered bad for the human body. BPA is an epoxy resin and found on in the inside of many metal cans. It is also found in many other things such as plastic water bottles, throw away food containers, baby bottles, dental fillings, shower curtains, and many other things (Vandenburg, et. al., 2008). BPA is also considered the most abundant chemical in the world (Vandenburg, et. al., 2008). BPA, the endocrine disruptor, is considered to be so dangerous because it is unstable under ultraviolet light and raised temperatures (Breast Cancer UK)....   [tags: human body, everyday objects, BPA]

Powerful Essays
958 words (2.7 pages)

The Human Sciences And Natural Sciences Essay

- ... Perception and reason are used to develop theories in the natural sciences, to explain observations or theoretical assumptions. These theories are often, on the surface, astonishingly simple. Therefore, an important distinction that needs to be made when questioning a trade-off between accuracy and simplicity is if whether one is looking at the background processes or the final concept. When looking at the background processes in the natural sciences, there is no sacrifice to be made in terms of the simplicity of the model and the accuracy of the final outcome because simple models provide the foundation for which more detail can be built upon....   [tags: Scientific method, Science, Social sciences]

Powerful Essays
1374 words (3.9 pages)

Science and Human Nature Essay

- Science, a field that involves various subjects including math, biology, chemistry etc, is one of those most influential aspects of human history. Merriam-webster dictionary defines it as: “such knowledge or such a system of knowledge concerned with the physical world and its phenomena: Nature Science” (“Science”, Merriam-webster Dictionary). What it studies is alway related to our nature, ourselves. It is a field that requires sophisticated knowledge and skill, as well as long-term devotement....   [tags: Science, Math, Biology, Humans, Nature]

Powerful Essays
1732 words (4.9 pages)

Human Science and History Essay

- “The historian’s task is to understand the past; the human scientist, by contrast, is looking to change the future.” To what extent is this true in these areas of knowledge. As historians study, compiles and writes events in chronological order or arranged events in the order it came to be, people understood what came before them. Historians are the authority on it that no one ever tried to question what was written but instead we accepted it as facts and from those facts we learned and knew that as time and years go by people could and can change the future....   [tags: Human Innovation, Intuition]

Powerful Essays
1027 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Biometrics: The Science of Human Recognition

- Biometrics: The Science of Human Recognition As our society becomes more and more modernized so does our need for more sophisticated ways to identify people for who they really are. Biometrics is the science of human recognition. With this rapid movement to develop this new technology, many companies have come out with different ways to distinguish people. Some of these new forms of recognition include; retinal scanning, iris recognition, finger imaging, hand geometry, face recognition, voice recognition and signature recognition....   [tags: Research Science Papers]

Free Essays
1441 words (4.1 pages)