Darwin and Gamble's Debate Essay

Darwin and Gamble's Debate Essay

Length: 1168 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Darwin and Gamble's Debate


Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Birthmark" gives a human face to Darwin and Gamble's academic debate concerning natural selection. In the story, Georgiana has a birthmark on her cheek that has been visible her entire life, but was just starting to agitate her husband, Aylmer. He used science to successfully rid his wife of the birthmark, but the procedure was fatal. The process that the couple went through appears to be a response to the theory of natural selection, with her death as the ultimate conclusion. This essay will examine the theory, the story, and the link between them.

While Darwin and Gamble's theses contain multiple arguments and have multiple conclusions, the most important of them is the notion of natural selection. In Descent of Man, Darwin summarizes his argument by saying, "through the contest of rival males…[and] from the general struggle for life…the characters gained will have been transmitted to the offspring." (Darwin 6). It is contended that change among a given species is spontaneous (and normal), and sometimes the change is good (insofar as it adds a positive trait or traits to the organism), and sometimes it is bad. Those organisms with good changes will be fit to gather food and protect offspring, and those that are less fit will be less apt to do this. Extending the logic of this statement, the fit will survive, and the weak will die. The argument of whether or not one gender has become superior to another within the same species is irrelevant to Natural Selection. However, Darwin and Gamble bring this dispute to each of their respective works. Since they agree on the original concept of the survival of the fittest, their disagreements are reconcilable.

Darwin crea...


... middle of paper ...


...t is my contention that the application of the theory of natural selection to society and humanity is relatively unimportant, when compared with the application of the theory to evolution. Hawthorne's "The Birthmark" was a very timely interpretation of the events surrounding the emergence of the theory of natural selection. It shows the reader that the academic debate between Darwin and Gamble has a human face, and that all of us can learn from Aylmer's mistake, and Aminadab's nobility.

Works Cited

1. Darwin, Charles. "Sexual Selection in Relation to Man." The Descent of Man. New York: Prometheus Books, 1998. 576-586.

2. Gamble, Eliza Burt. "The Supremacy of the Male." The Sexes in Science and History. New York: G.P. Putnam Sons, 1916. 74-92.

3. Hawthorne, Nathaniel. "The Birthmark." Anthology of American Literature. New York: McMillan, 1985. 1159-1169.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Market Competition Of Unilever And Gamble Essay

- ... Other barriers to entry would include technology. In the soap making world there are several products that can be used to make soap. Technology that is found in large factories that are quite possibly too expensive for a start-up to afford. Having such low technological tools such as a hand blender and a mixing bowl for the saponification will limit the amount of soap that I can make compared to the two large competitors, Unilever and Proctor and Gamble. However, low technology and large competition would not be my biggest barriers to entry....   [tags: Procter & Gamble, Marketing]

Strong Essays
1480 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of John Gamble And William Procter

- ... As a result, consumers will reward them with leadership sales, profit, and value creation, allowing their people, their shareholders, and the communities in which they live and work to prosper. During the next five years, Procter & Gamble India hopes to fulfill the following goals: Financial goals Increase its market share in India’s Oral Care Industry by 5%. Invest 30% of its sales figure for 2014 in a five-year marketing campaign. Nonfinancial goals Introduce to new value packs - a family bundle and a saver pack....   [tags: Toothpaste, Procter & Gamble, Marketing]

Strong Essays
1531 words (4.4 pages)

Darwin and Design Essay

- For the majority of the article "Sympathetic Science: Charles Darwin, Joseph Hooker, and the Passions of Victorian Naturalists" Endersby discusses the relationship of Darwin with other naturalist such as Huxley, Hooker and Wallace. and then goes on to comment on the separate spheres of the era and how that effected their relationships. Until the sub section labelled "Dear Old Darwin" not much is pertinent. The article concludes most enlightening by stating "nineteenth-century science flourished in the world of men- only clubs and societies, a world from which women and children were excluded....   [tags: Charles Darwin's Ideas, Comparisons]

Strong Essays
1042 words (3 pages)

Charles Darwin and Human Evolution in Intelligence Essay examples

- The great and famous Charles Darwin is still remembered today after almost 2 centuries had passed. He was one of the most significant scientists to change how we view this world. Life, as we know it, was changed by Charles Darwin. But I don’t believe that looking at the present will help in any way so I will take back to the past. It is a fact that throughout history people have always believed in some sort of god. Some religions were weak and have come and gone, where others have come and stayed....   [tags: Charles Darwin, evolution, intelligence,]

Strong Essays
1190 words (3.4 pages)

Charles Darwin 's Theory Of Evolution Essay

- Charles Darwin is well-known for his work as developing the theory of evolution, explaining the process of biological change. Charles Robert Darwin was born on February 12th February 1809 in Shrewsbury, England. Darwin dies on April 19th 1882 in Kent, England at the age of 73, and was buried in Westminster Abbey. Darwin was an English naturalist and geologist and was best known for the contributions that he made for the evolutionary theory. He was very involved with the study of life forms and Natural history, during Darwin’s time in Edinburgh University Darwin, studied medicine with the outlook of becoming a physician with his brother Erasmus....   [tags: Charles Darwin, Evolution, Natural selection]

Strong Essays
1843 words (5.3 pages)

Essay on Proctor & Gamble

- Proctor & Gamble The alarm sounds bright and early at 7:30 am, you fall out of bed, stumble down the hall Crest toothpaste in hand, brush your teeth, grab your school bag and your off to class. Fast forward to 12:00 pm—lunch. You get a scrumptious Italian hoagie—hold the mayo, extra oil—from Joegies and a can of Sour Cream and Onion Pringles. Later that night you notice a nice big oil stain on your Abercrombie & Fitch shirt from your delicious hoagie you had for lunch—time to do the laundry....   [tags: Proctor Gamble Business Papers]

Strong Essays
2002 words (5.7 pages)

Charles Darwin 's Theory Of Evolution Essay

- ... On December 27, 1831, the HMS Beagle launched its voyage around the world with Darwin in haul. Over the course of the trip, Darwin collected a variety of natural samples, including birds, plants, and fossils. Through research and experimentation, he had the distinctive opportunity to closely take under consideration principles of botany, geology, and zoology. The Pacific Islands and Galapagos Archipelago were of particular interest to Darwin, as was South America. It can be seen that this trip assisted in contrasting Darwin’s worldview as it had a monumental effect on Darwin’s theories of evolution....   [tags: Charles Darwin, Evolution, Natural selection]

Strong Essays
1301 words (3.7 pages)

Charles Darwin 's Theory Of Evolution Essay

- ... The next year, Darwin published his most iconic work, On The Origin of Species, and controversial it was. Going against every common belief held at the time, but holding so much evidence and groundbreaking ideas, the work was known as “the book that shook the world”(Mayr, 27). In the introduction to his work, Darwin lays out his theory fairly simply: As many more individuals of each species are born than can possibly survive; and as, consequently, there is a frequently recurring struggle for existence, it follows that any being, if it vary however slightly in any manner profitable to itself, under the complex and sometimes varying conditions of life, will have a better chance of survivi...   [tags: Evolution, Charles Darwin, Natural selection]

Strong Essays
1191 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on Biography of Charles Darwin

- Charles Darwin was born on February 12, 1809 in Shrewsbury, England. His father was a very wealthy physician named Robert Waring Darwin. His Grandfather, Erasmus Darwin was a famous poet, physician, and philosopher. His mother's name was Susannah Wedgewood. His mother was the daughter to a famous pottery expert named Josiah Wedgwood. Young Charles was destined to make something of himself the day he was born. In 1818, young Charles began school at Shrewsbury. His scholastic achievments were very minor and at the concern of his father he was removed....   [tags: Charles Darwin Biography]

Strong Essays
692 words (2 pages)

Charles Darwin Essay

- Charles Darwin began his scientific breakthroughs and upcoming theories when he began an expedition trip to the Galapagos Islands of South America. While studying there, he discovered that each island had its own type of plant and animal species. Although these plants and animals were similar in appearance, they had other characteristics that made them differ from one another and seem to not appear as similar. Darwin questioned why these plants and animals were on these islands and why they are different in ways....   [tags: Essay on Charles Darwin 2014]

Strong Essays
468 words (1.3 pages)